Obama and the General

onthebottom

Never Been Justly Banned
Jan 10, 2002
40,880
197
63
Hooterville
www.scubadiving.com
A very good account of the General's position.....

OTB

Obama and the General
The White House finds a four-star scapegoat for its Afghan jitters.

Democrats have found someone worth fighting in Afghanistan. His name is Stan McChrystal.

The other night, House Speaker Nancy Pelosi went after the commander of U.S. and allied forces in Afghanistan, "with all due respect," for supposedly disrespecting the chain of command. Around the Congressional Democratic Caucus, we're told Members refer to General McChrystal as "General MacArthur," after the commander in Korea sacked by Harry Truman.

President Obama and General McChrystal

White House aides have fanned these flames with recent leaks to the media that "officials are challenging" his assessment asking for more troops. In the last two days, the White House National Security Adviser and the Secretary of Defense have both suggested that the general should keep his mouth shut. President Obama called him in Friday for a talking-to on the tarmac at Copenhagen airport.

Though a decorated Army four-star officer, the General's introduction to Beltway warfare is proving to be brutal. To be fair, Gen. McChrystal couldn't know that his Commander in Chief would go wobbly so soon on his commitment to him as well as to his own Afghan strategy when he was tapped for the job in AprilWe're told by people who know him that Gen. McChrystal "feels terrible" and "had no intention whatsoever of trying to lobby and influence" the Administration. His sense of bewilderment makes perfect sense anywhere but in the political battlefield of Washington. He was, after all, following orders.

Recall that in March Mr. Obama unveiled his "comprehensive new strategy . . . to reverse the Taliban's gains and promote a more capable and accountable Afghan government." The Commander in Chief pledged to properly resource this "war of necessity," which he also called during the 2008 campaign "the central front on terror." The President then sacked his war commander, who had been chosen by Defense Secretary Robert Gates, in favor of Gen. McChrystal, an expert in counterinsurgency.

Upon arriving in June, Gen. McChrystal launched his assessment of the forces required to execute the Obama strategy. His confidential study was completed in August and sent to the Pentagon. Chairman of the Joint Chiefs Michael Mullen told Congress that more troops would be needed, and a figure of 30,000-40,000 was bandied about.

The figure has clearly spooked the Administration. Soon after, Gen. McChrystal's confidential report was leaked to the Washington Post by, well, you'll have to ask Bob Woodward. The report said that the U.S. urgently needs to reverse a "deteriorating" security situation. Soon the full retreat began in Washington, led by a vocal group within the Administration that wants to scale back the mission. The White House told the Pentagon to hold off asking for troops and Gen. McChrystal not to testify to Congress. Remarkably, President Obama mused on the Sunday talks shows, "Are we doing the right thing?"

Then Gen. McChrystal gave a speech last Thursday before the International Institute of Strategic Studies in London. It was scheduled and approved by the Pentagon weeks before the Afghan political jitters seized official Washington. The General was hardly incendiary.

"We need to reverse the current trends, and time does matter," he said. Asked vaguely about taking a narrower approach that leaves Afghanistan to its own devices and strikes at terrorists from afar, Gen. McChrystal offered that "a strategy that does not leave Afghanistan in a stable position is probably a short-sighted one." He warned the country would descend into "Chaos-istan."

What really worries Democrats is the prospect of Midterm-istan if Mr. Obama escalates the war. But some thought to play up the General's innocuous comment into an attempt to torpedo the latest Administration rethink.

In fact, the White House is merely revisiting the idea rejected in its "careful policy review" last spring to move from ambitious counterinsurgency to "counterterrorism" that would involve fewer troops and target al Qaeda instead of the Taliban. Vice President Joe Biden champions the change, and Sen. John Kerry and Speaker Pelosi have endorsed it.

The Biden faction says changes in the region justify a U-turn: An expanded U.S. force would merely be fighting a motley group of insurgents who aren't planning the next 9/11. This is partly true, but the links between the Taliban and al Qaeda are longstanding, particularly in the Pashtun areas of the south. If America pulls back and lets Mullah Omar create a Talibanistan in Helmand and Kandahar, al Qaeda operatives will soon follow.

As we've learned the hard way in Iraq and Afghanistan, successful counterterrorism requires intelligence. This comes from earning the trust of the people, which in turn can only happen if they are protected. The Biden approach would pull U.S. soldiers back behind high walls, far from the field of battle, and turns security over to the Afghan army and police before they are prepared for the job.

The sudden Afghan rethink also jeopardizes progress in Pakistan, the world's leading sanctuary for al Qaeda. The Pakistani willingness to expand American drone strikes and launch a military campaign in their tribal regions dates squarely to the Administration's recommitment to the region. Now that Mr. Obama is having second thoughts, so might the Pakistanis.

The President's very public waver is already doing strategic harm. The Taliban are getting a morale boost and claiming victory, while our allies in Europe have one more reason to rethink their own deployments. Such a victory, as the head of the British army Sir David Richards warned on Sunday, would have an "intoxicating effect" on extremist Islam around the world.

Commanders in Chief can change their minds. George W. Bush waited too long to embrace the "surge." He had private doubts when the casualties also surged in 2007, but he gave the new approach a chance to succeed. Mr. Obama is blinking even before all the additional troops he ordered to Afghanistan have had time to deploy to the theater.

Gen. McChrystal's liberal critics also have very short memories. In 2003, Army Chief of Staff General Eric Shinseki clashed with his superiors by saying many more troops were needed to pacify Iraq. He became a Democratic hero and is now Mr. Obama's Veterans Secretary. In this case, Gen. McChrystal has become a political target merely for taking at face value Mr. Obama's order to fight the war properly. His superiors, the Central Commander David Petraeus and Adm. Fallon, back him, but can hardly be said to question civil control of the military.

In an interview with Newsweek, Gen. McChrystal said he wouldn't resign if the President rejects his request for more troops. If he were really trying to dictate policy, he'd have given a different answer. But we don't think Gen. McChrystal should stay to implement a Biden war plan either. No commander in uniform should ask his soldiers to die for a strategy he doesn't think is winnable—or for a President who lets his advisers and party blame a general for their own lack of political nerve.
 
Everybody is trying to cover their buts. The administration needs some good news and the congresscritters and fairygod senators have to worry about their own seats and the unthinkable actually having to work for a living. There is a major bout of nasty brewing in the U.S. electorate right now and nobody wants be the target
 
A little less simplistic look at the issues ...

Poll finds skepticism on Afghanistan democracy

By Susan Page and Jim Michaels, USA TODAY
WASHINGTON — Eight years ago, the U.S.-led assault against al-Qaeda fighters and the Taliban regime that gave them haven in Afghanistan won almost universal backing from Americans reeling from the 9/11 attacks.
Now, as President Obama wrestles with whether to deploy tens of thousands of additional U.S. troops to the war there, he faces treacherous crosscurrents that have put him at odds with some of his strongest supporters — and created a potential public faceoff with the military commander he installed.

Obama met for three hours with his top national security advisers at the White House Situation Room on Wednesday and heads back there Friday for sessions on Pakistan and neighboring Afghanistan.

Besides becoming an early test of Obama's foreign policy, Gen. Stanley McChrystal's request for more troops in Afghanistan has split U.S. public opinion. In a USA TODAY/Gallup Poll taken Tuesday, most Americans embrace U.S. goals in Afghanistan. Eight in 10 say weakening terrorists' ability to stage attacks on the United States is "an important reason" to stay, but they are less certain that progress is being made, especially in establishing a stable democracy.

At stake for Obama with his decision, expected this month, is not only the nation's strategy in a critical region but also his emerging profile as commander in chief. His advisers and analysts close to the administration suggest he is seeking a middle ground that would deploy a more modest number of additional troops while revamping some U.S. goals — with a final approach that White House press secretary Robert Gibbs acknowledges could leave all sides unhappy.

One complication: The public case McChrystal, commander of U.S. forces in Afghanistan, has made for more troops. His words could be used to criticize Obama as doing too little to protect Americans' security if the president decides on a different course.

"It's a defining moment of his presidency," says Lee Hamilton, president of the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars and a former chairman of the House Foreign Affairs Committee. "It'll determine how we direct our foreign policy resources — and domestic resources, because wars cost a lot of money. It'll signal to the world whether he has very ambitious goals in the Middle East in terms of bringing about stability and viability of the nations there, or whether he seeks a more modest goal. And it'll have profound consequences in the region."

The debate has put Obama, who repeatedly has described Afghanistan as a "war of necessity," at odds with many fellow Democrats. At a meeting with congressional leaders in the State Dining Room on Tuesday, it was Obama's 2008 Republican opponent, Sen. John McCain, who made the case for staying the course and praised McChrystal, as the Arizona senator told reporters in the White House driveway afterward.

Congress' top Democrat, House Speaker Nancy Pelosi of California, was among those raising questions about making a greater commitment to the war in Afghanistan. She refused to say later whether she would necessarily support the president's decision once it's made.

The USA TODAY survey found a similar partisan divide: three-fourths of Republicans support sending more troops; six in 10 Democrats oppose it.

Among all Americans, the divide is almost even, with 48% in favor, 45% opposed. Most of those opposed say Obama should begin to withdraw U.S. troops rather than commit more.

Those attitudes contrast with public opinion when the war began Oct. 7, 2001, less than a month after the 9/11 attacks. According to a USA TODAY/CNN/Gallup Poll taken that day, nine of 10 Americans approved of the military action against Afghanistan. Just 5% disapproved.

Few imagined that U.S. troops might still be fighting there eight years later, though. Only 22% said the conflict would last more than two years. Close to half predicted it would be over within months.

Instead, Afghanistan now ranks second only to Vietnam as the longest war Americans have fought since the nation was founded.

Rethinking assumptions

Obama isn't considering an immediate drawdown of U.S. troops in Afghanistan, Gibbs says. He dismisses that as a "straw man" critics are using to present the choices as all or nothing.

However, aides say a worsening security situation in Afghanistan and accusations of fraud against Afghan President Hamid Karzai in the Aug. 20 elections have led Obama to "reassess basic assumptions" he held when he committed 21,000 additional troops in March.

The situation "is more serious than we anticipated when the decisions were made in March," Defense Secretary Robert Gates said at a George Washington University forum Monday. House Armed Services Chairman Ike Skelton, D-Mo., calls the questionable Afghan election "the elephant in the tent."

In recent months, violence has increased dramatically in Afghanistan — one apparent factor in the erosion of public support. There were 294 U.S. and coalition fatalities in the Afghanistan campaign in all of 2008, according to icasualties.org. In comparison, there have been 401 already this year, the website says. A total of 1,446 coalition troops, including 869 Americans, have died in the war since 2001.

Now, military analysts, including some with ties to the Pentagon, describe three options:

•Go all in: McChrystal advocated a comprehensive counterinsurgency strategy in the assessment he submitted to Gates, which was leaked to The Washington Post. U.S. and NATO forces would focus on protecting civilians while bolstering Afghan security forces and helping to build governmental institutions, repelling any resurgence of the Taliban.

This labor-intensive solution resembles the increase in U.S. forces in Iraq ordered by then-President Bush in January 2007. There, the security and political situation improved after U.S. troops were redeployed off large bases and placed in small outposts to better secure neighborhoods, particularly in Baghdad and the troubled Anbar province.

McChrystal's request likely includes both combat forces and trainers for Afghan security forces, says John Nagl, a counterinsurgency expert at the Center for a New American Security and a member of the Defense Policy Board, which advises Gates.

•Redefine the mission: Narrowing U.S. goals to an antiterrorism approach that focused on combating al-Qaeda wouldn't require as many U.S. troops.

With this strategy, the United States might step up unmanned drone attacks on al-Qaeda strongholds in Pakistan and use limited numbers of Special Forces soldiers for high-level targets. Stabilizing the Afghan government and fighting the Taliban wouldn't get as much attention.

Andrew Bacevich of Boston University is one advocate of this approach, combined with an effort to pay warlords to keep al-Qaeda out of their areas. The McChrystal plan is "a synonym for nation-building," he says. "I don't believe a nation-building project in Afghanistan is either necessary or plausible."

At the congressional meeting, Vice President Biden denied reports he was advocating an anti-terrorism strategy "exclusively," Gibbs said, which he defined as "extracting" a significant number of U.S. forces now in Afghanistan.

Still, Biden acknowledged in an interview with USA TODAY in June that he had argued the case against an extensive troop buildup this year while Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton argued for it. "I had some disagreement in degree with her," Biden said then, "and the president ended up landing on a spot that was where she was."

•A middle ground: A third option would be to continue McChrystal's counterinsurgency strategy but with only a modest increase in troops. The risk: Progress would take longer and the prospects of failure would rise.

"The debate right now is, does McChrystal really need 40,000?" says Andrew Krepinevich, a counterinsurgency specialist at the Center for Strategic and Budgetary Assessments who is a member of the Defense Policy Board. "I think the administration is trying to find that sweet spot."

Under this plan, the U.S. relationship with the Karzai government might be rethought but Obama wouldn't reverse strategy or abandon McChrystal.

"It would be hard for the president not to give him additional resources," Nagl says. "How many of them, I don't know."

Reasons to stay

The White House can take some comfort in the USA TODAY poll, which finds overwhelming majorities saying that weakening terrorists and keeping the Taliban from regaining control of Afghanistan are important reasons to keep U.S. troops there.

There is less certainty that the U.S. effort is succeeding, however. Just over 50% see movement toward quelling terrorists and the Taliban, but nearly six in 10 say there hasn't been progress toward building a stable democratic government.

One more finding: By 2 to 1, those surveyed say military commanders should state their positions privately to the president and others in the chain of command, not make them known publicly, as McChrystal did.

"The president can't escape the reality that this is a momentous decision," says James Lindsay, a National Security Council official in the Clinton White House. He notes comparisons being made to Lyndon Johnson when he considered calls to increase U.S. forces in Vietnam in the early 1960s — a war that came to dominate his presidency.

Sen. Jack Reed, D-R.I., says Obama will take his time to decide. "One thing I believe the president doesn't want to do is ... look back and say, 'How did we get here?' "

Contributing: Andrew Seaman, Richard Wolf
 
Congress' top Democrat, House Speaker Nancy Pelosi of California, was among those raising questions about making a greater commitment to the war in Afghanistan. She refused to say later whether she would necessarily support the president's decision once it's made.

Sen. Jack Reed, D-R.I., says Obama will take his time to decide. "One thing I believe the president doesn't want to do is ... look back and say, 'How did we get here?' "
The President needs to make a thoughtful decision, but he doesn't have forever to make it. And the military has already told him that failure to make changes will lead to failure.

While I agree that one doesn't have to have military experience to discuss politico-military stratagy and even to be an expert in the field. One wonders quite what background Speaker Pelosi has that makes her qualified (and which makes her feel qualified) to second guess the best advice that General McChrystal's staff have given him, and that he agrees with.
 
The President needs to make a thoughtful decision, but he doesn't have forever to make it. And the military has already told him that failure to make changes will lead to failure.

While I agree that one doesn't have to have military experience to discuss politico-military stratagy and even to be an expert in the field. One wonders quite what background Speaker Pelosi has that makes her qualified (and which makes her feel qualified) to second guess the best advice that General McChrystal's staff have given him, and that he agrees with.


they are still polling... at the end of the day it is just politics for the politicians... then the soldiers have to follow the idiots
 
Wow....

Warhawk thinks more troops is the answer.......I also hear McDonalds would like to sell more hamburgers.Remember all those military brass that stood up against G.W Bushes policies?......Do some research and you'll find most of them were retired.Call their reasoning what you will, they knew the chain of command, and respected it as such.You don't step outside the chain of command.Recommendations go up the chain to your commander-in-chief and if you have any disagreements that where they get aired.

All I heard during the Bush administration was how we couldn't talk about this or that because we didn't want "the enenmy" to know our plans.How is this breach of protocol any different?.

This sounds very much like what the Republican leadership would like done and these ideas were given a voice.Can you imagine if any member of the military had stated such action so publically during the last administration?..Well...a few did..and they aren't serving anymore.
 
Warhawk thinks more troops is the answer.......I also hear McDonalds would like to sell more hamburgers.Remember all those military brass that stood up against G.W Bushes policies?......Do some research and you'll find most of them were retired.Call their reasoning what you will, they knew the chain of command, and respected it as such.You don't step outside the chain of command.Recommendations go up the chain to your commander-in-chief and if you have any disagreements that where they get aired.

All I heard during the Bush administration was how we couldn't talk about this or that because we didn't want "the enenmy" to know our plans.How is this breach of protocol any different?.

This sounds very much like what the Republican leadership would like done and these ideas were given a voice.Can you imagine if any member of the military had stated such action so publically during the last administration?..Well...a few did..and they aren't serving anymore.

You do realize Obama put him in that job this Spring?

OTB
 
You do realize Obama put him in that job this Spring?

OTB

Yes....he had to have someone there..my main point though was show me any upper level military strategist who does not think more firepower,manpower,etc is the answer........and i'll show you one a few weeks from retiring.

Republican presidents tend to know their Bread and butter is foreign policy, and hence very rarely cross swords with their Military advisiors(Even Colin Powell stepped down as opposed to yelling"bullshit" over Iraq).Democrat's tend to have more issues with their military brass because they are not as quick to suggest escalation or a military build up.

Your right.Obama did put him in there...and if he had issues with his commander-in-chief they should have been aired privately not publicly
 
Yes....he had to have someone there..my main point though was show me any upper level military strategist who does not think more firepower,manpower,etc is the answer........and i'll show you one a few weeks from retiring.

Republican presidents tend to know their Bread and butter is foreign policy, and hence very rarely cross swords with their Military advisiors(Even Colin Powell stepped down as opposed to yelling"bullshit" over Iraq).Democrat's tend to have more issues with their military brass because they are not as quick to suggest escalation or a military build up.

Your right.Obama did put him in there...and if he had issues with his commander-in-chief they should have been aired privately not publicly

And if the POTUS wasn't going to take the advice of his commanding General he shouldn't have appointed him....

I don't think our interests (NATO) are well served by a POTUS triangulating what will sell in the mid-term elections.....

OTB
 
And if the POTUS wasn't going to take the advice of his commanding General he shouldn't have appointed him....

I don't think our interests (NATO) are well served by a POTUS triangulating what will sell in the mid-term elections.....

OTB

He is a community organizer and what he does best is sell what others can give.
 
And if the POTUS wasn't going to take the advice of his commanding General he shouldn't have appointed him....

I don't think our interests (NATO) are well served by a POTUS triangulating what will sell in the mid-term elections.....

OTB

POTUS does not "Take anyone's advice"..he listens to all points of view and then makes an informed decision.If this general can not handle the fact that the president may not follows his recommendations to a tee.He should resign.

That said,even if he was not taking his advice ,this general did not follow protocol.He arguement would have had much more weight if he had discussed it privately......he did a "ring and run"....and i'm pretty sure he knew it too.

I'm not a "lefty" on this issue.I believe that overwhelming force will not work there now for a variety of reasons.If more troops..equipment are needed they should be of a more covert nature.
 
He is a community organizer and what he does best is sell what others can give.

He's not a community organizer,he's the President of the United States and, doesn't he deserve at least the same amount of respect as the children do?

If we're describing our president's now by their former titles and actions, I have a whole list of rather inappropriate ones for the last POTUS.
 
Yes....he had to have someone there..my main point though was show me any upper level military strategist who does not think more firepower,manpower,etc is the answer........and i'll show you one a few weeks from retiring.
That's not really true. There have been plenty of cases of Senior Military Officers advising that a smaller force is all that is necessary, or not to invade in a particular spot.

Generally more manpower and greater firepower saves lives and although it is shocking to most doves, Generals and Admirals want victory to come at the cost of the fewest lives possible.
 
He's not a community organizer,he's the President of the United States and, doesn't he deserve at least the same amount of respect as the children do?

If we're describing our president's now by their former titles and actions, I have a whole list of rather inappropriate ones for the last POTUS.


The man is President and so far he has done little. He needs to support the troops and that means following the advice of the people he has in charge of them.

You obscure reference to child here is lost.
 
Right now is hesitation is percieved as weakness by the enemy. Instead, he needs to be percieved as being decisive and supportive of the military.

If Obama was smart he should commit to more troups but decline to give actual numbers. This will buy him some time until he can decide how best to handle it.

Also, it's never a good idea for politicians to make military decisions for the sake of political exediency.
 
Right now is hesitation is percieved as weakness by the enemy. Instead, he needs to be percieved as being decisive and supportive of the military.

If Obama was smart he should commit to more troups but decline to give actual numbers. This will buy him some time until he can decide how best to handle it.

Also, it's never a good idea for politicians to make military decisions for the sake of political exediency.

He may also decide on more troops the day after they get there.I've never gotten the idea of a country agreeing to any strategy and then making it public.EX.We're going to send in 30,000 more troops...to give plenty of time for our enemy to react and co-ordinate a withdrawal.

People have critized what they see as a hesitation.I personally like seeing a world leader who thinks a bit longer, deeper then going with their gut or god.

He has got to stop letting people play"the patroit" card with him.Alot of people are tiring of this war in Afghanistan for one very good reason.They suspect the opportunity was missed to avenge the attacks of 9/11 long ago, and now they see it as a "nation-building exercise" that president Bush made very unpopular over the last years in Iraq.

With troubles at home alot of independants and far lefties feel alienated by a goverment that seems to be continuing down this road.Your right,politicans should never make decisions for the sake of political expediency.Especially when your opposition is chiding you to go in the direction that will benefit them the most politically.
 
The man is President and so far he has done little. He needs to support the troops and that means following the advice of the people he has in charge of them.

You obscure reference to child here is lost.

He has done little that you support.Which is probably why you did not vote for him.He seems to be pissing off the far left and far right..sooo he may be doing a little something right.
 
He has done little that you support.Which is probably why you did not vote for him.He seems to be pissing off the far left and far right..sooo he may be doing a little something right.
Personally I did not think either he or McCain were the right person for the job.


What has he accomplished?

Ok having a swing set built on the White House lawn is huge.