Acupuncture, Cupping? It's all B.S.

Adrenaline

Banned
Mar 26, 2009
381
0
0
So my friend recommended that I try acupuncture. She claims that it makes her feel so incredibly relaxed, and it heals every ailment under the sun.

I went last week, and boy was I sorry. First of all, the needles did absolutely nothing, at all. Secondly, the cupping was just painful, and I had marks left on my back for days. All of this painful nonsense for $60. To top it all off, acupuncture is one of those professions where you're not really sure if the person doing it is qualified or licensed. I hope the person I went to was, otherwise my insurance won't cover it, that would be even more painful.

What a waste of time and pain that was. If you believe in that B.S. and the placebo effect does wonders for you, then kudos.
 
Traditional Chinese Medicine Act, 2006

http://www.health.gov.on.ca/english/public/legislation/bill_50/hu_tcm.html

Your Ontario tax dollars at work.

I wanna get me one o'them chickens to sacrifice after I dance round and hoop and hollar a bit. Who needs an MRI when da'bones will tell you what's wrong.

P.T. Barnum was completely correct (another sucker is born every minute) and people who are in desperate situations will reach out to the worst charlatans that tell them what they want to hear.

After a while the lies have been said so often, and the politicians are so scared of offending a block of voters, that any sort of crap gets substituted for real patient care.
 
Well, all I can tell you is that I had a friend who had severe arthritis. Severe. Crippling.

The ONLY relief they experienced was through acupuncture.

Yes, the possibility was discussed that it was a placebo effect. But the upshot was, for this person it was the only relief short of mind-numbing doses of pain killers.
 
Traditional Chinese Medicine Act, 2006

http://www.health.gov.on.ca/english/public/legislation/bill_50/hu_tcm.html

Your Ontario tax dollars at work.

I wanna get me one o'them chickens to sacrifice after I dance round and hoop and hollar a bit. Who needs an MRI when da'bones will tell you what's wrong.

P.T. Barnum was completely correct (another sucker is born every minute) and people who are in desperate situations will reach out to the worst charlatans that tell them what they want to hear.

After a while the lies have been said so often, and the politicians are so scared of offending a block of voters, that any sort of crap gets substituted for real patient care.


Exactly, they're all charlatans, it should be illegal.
 
Exactly, they're all charlatans, it should be illegal.

funny, I seem to recall many people condemning use of leeches too but some of the top surgeons in the world today use them to reduce swelling and inflammation after surgery and many cases are documented as to their benefit......
 
I see a great Japanese shiatsu therapist who also does acupuncture, and while I don't usually have any major problems that need curing, his treatments are amazing, and he's helped me with chronic tension headaches and minor pain.

At least in my experience it causes no harm and probably has some benefit.
 
Is it true it makes your penis last longer?
 
As a Chinese man, I believe all that Chinese medicine, herbs, acupuncture is complete nonsense. A lot of Chinese believe in that stuff but end up resorting to Western medicine in the end.
 
I am very opposed to medical treatment based on magic, such as chiropractors, naturopaths, etc. But my understanding is that acupuncture has actually been proven effective for some types of pain relief, in proper scientific tests, beyond just placebo effect. It is plausible to me to, in that you could be blocking nerve signals by what you are doing.

I have never tried it, and likely never would.
 
I am very opposed to medical treatment based on magic, such as chiropractors, naturopaths, etc. But my understanding is that acupuncture has actually been proven effective for some types of pain relief, in proper scientific tests, beyond just placebo effect. It is plausible to me to, in that you could be blocking nerve signals by what you are doing.

I have never tried it, and likely never would.

chiropractic and naturopathic medicine is not based on magic.

The problem is with our western medicine is people look for a quick fix.. and don't really want to deal with the underlying problems.. but a quick fix often means a drug.. which has side effects that need another quick fix.

In the history of chinese medicine a family doctor was hired by the family on retainer and only paid if everyone was well.. regular acupuncture treatments are required. One rarely will do anything for you considering you probably created the problem over several years.

In our system of medicine our physicians, hospitals and pharmaceutical companies make more money as they learn new uses for each drug, surgery or other medical treatment.

Whenever there is a hospital strike.. the death rate goes down. Think about it.

yeah.. right over 2000 years of history of acupuncture.. must simply be '''maaagggic!!''
 
chiropractic and naturopathic medicine is not based on magic.

The problem is with our western medicine is people look for a quick fix.. and don't really want to deal with the underlying problems.. but a quick fix often means a drug.. which has side effects that need another quick fix.

In the history of chinese medicine a family doctor was hired by the family on retainer and only paid if everyone was well.. regular acupuncture treatments are required. One rarely will do anything for you considering you probably created the problem over several years.

In our system of medicine our physicians, hospitals and pharmaceutical companies make more money as they learn new uses for each drug, surgery or other medical treatment.

Whenever there is a hospital strike.. the death rate goes down. Think about it.

yeah.. right over 2000 years of history of acupuncture.. must simply be '''maaagggic!!''

Good post.

I have a session a week and have had it just about every week for the past 5 years. I have not had anything worse than a cold in 5 years. Works for me.
 
They had a Documentary on Tv showing a brain surgery done with acupuncture anesthesia. The patient was concious, they scalped her, then they used a saw to open her scull all this while the patient talked to the nurse and was laughing.

I also visited the Lincoln hospital in the Bronx where they treat crack with acupuncture , very interesting.

http://www.nytimes.com/1986/11/20/n...uncture-on-crack-addicts.html?&pagewanted=all
 
it takes all kinds...

Acupuncture may not be for everyone, just as many medical treatments don't work for everyone. A lot of the result depends on your frame of mind going in and during the treatment period. I see a physiotherapist regularly who is also licensed to pratice acupuncture. He swears by it, especially for pain treatments, but he aslo says that it isn't a one-shot fix. Just like anything else, if it's worth getting and you expect it to last, you have to put in the time.
 
I've tried it for a bad knee and it did help.
You need to go to someone that has had more than a weekend learning annex course!
I've seen a woman that has university training in Chinese medicine including years of study in acupuncture...she knows what she is doing. Also have a cousin that has a BSc. and spent 5 years getting his Naturopathic Doctors training in the school in Toronto...he knows what he is doing.
Smart, well trained people, practising a healing art thousands of years old....not quacks or charlatans!
 
Nothing in the Holistic field of medicine is absolutley the ultimate cure.

You have to try various methods till you find the one that works for you.

Accupuncture given properly is very effective providing that it is used as the correct diagnoses. But if your therapist is proactive and not all caught up in their own importance they will advise you properly.
 
I have gone once a month to check on my overall health and "tune-ups" to re-balance me. Every month, they check my organ pulses and overall health and then make corrections to ensure that any issues I may have do not turn into something worse. It is my proactive health plan where western medicine is my reactive plan. It's good to have both working for you and I hope that by being proactive, I don't have to use the reactive, which is usually to kill all organisms in your body (good and bad) with antibiotics or cut it out.
 
It worked...

...for me. No placebo effect. Western medicine, drugs and physios couldn't help me. Went to acupuncture and it worked miracles! I swear by it.

JMHO...

OP