U2 @ Skydome (Yes, Skydome!)

I saw U2 on Wednesday and Green Day earlier this summer and Green Day BLEW THEM OUT OF THE WATER.

Timbit

I too saw Green Day and I totally agree with you, they had alot more energy (played about 2 1/2 hours). U2 stage set was creative, especially the movement of the 360 screen, but it seemed the music set was more subdue.

As well, I was not impressed when Bono thanked Blackberry at the end of the concert, just thanking the fans would have bee enough (which he did).
 
U2 sucks!

They are over-rated (just like The Hip)....even on the Blackberry commercial the Edge couldn't change the sound of his guitar. There are signature sounds, and then there are the same sounds over-and-over. :rolleyes:

Talk about still living on your hits from years ago....

War/ The Unforgettable Fire/ Joshua Tree and early albums are excellent, but the recent stuff...just so-so.

I can't stand Bono anymore..ever since he started telling other's how much to give to Third World countries.
 
Labels like "greatest" are meaningless.

U2 has been my favourite band since they began. I went to both shows this week and I've seen them 10 times now. They are the only band I'd still go to a stadium to see. The second night in Toronto was way better than the first.

But...they are a shadow of the band they were, and seeing them live now is mostly a nostalgic experience. Yes, they're still able to make a stadium feel like an intimate place at times, but the technology, the spectacle, the running around they feel they need to do in order to reach 70 000 people...it all detracts and distracts.

I know I sound like a crank...but the cell phones at these shows bother me. I don't understand people who pay up to $250.00 to attend...and then watch the entire concert through a 2.5 inch screen pointed at a 40 ft screen...when the artists are standing right in front of them, live.

Equally irritating are fans who clearly have no idea of what the band is about. When they sang One, and all these daft couples embrace and kiss like it's a love song...aieee...people are dumb. Reminds me of a wedding I attended, where the couple chose that song as their first dance.
 
I was also there last night and was in awe of their great talents. They come across as very humble guys and have been friends from their teens. Apart from Springsteen when i saw them at the grandstand for the " Born In the USA" tour, this was one of the best concerts that i have attended in my over 30 years of concerts. They have so many hits that it would be difficult to get them to play them all in one concert.


I wouldn't go that far....

I saw that Boss show too, actually saw Springsteen during "The River" tour for the first time.

Anyway, I was at the Rogers Centre for both shows and I have been a huge fan of U2 since they were first introduced to America-Buffalo radio-back during the WAR lp. They have certainly come a long way and I'll never forget how "New Year's Day" was the first song played on 97Rock in Buffalo. I was hooked and saw them on the "WAR" tour @ Shea's threatre in Buffalo and the balcony nearly collapsed from everyone jumping up and down...

However, last night reminded just how far this established band has peaked! Don't get me wrong-a big production-thousands of people, the Rogers Centre blah blah blah but it was missing a true U2 element only the diehards could understand. We were standing on the floor next to a couple who had no clue about a great tune such as "The Unforgettable Fire" was performed...Talk about a wide range of old and young in the crowd.

I can understand bands like U2 have so many hits that they cannot perform them all especially when you're pushing new material. However, trademark songs and a stack of known hits from an impressive catalogue were absent! Songs that made this band a live spectucale such as "BAD" (actually went to the second show hoping to hear "BAD") and "I Will Follow" and even "40" which had been a traditional closing tune for the band back in the day when each band memeber would leave the stage one by one....The good old days!

Not to harp on the past success of this band but to totally avoid any tunes from "Boy" an album that introduced the Irish band to the world, was strange.

Great time nonetheless but certainly not the best U2 concerts I have seen. For the record, the "WAR" "Joshua Tree", and even the "Achtung Baby" tour at Maple Leaf Gardens blow this tour away by a mile...

The best setlist so far has to be that at Soldier Field in Chicago on September 12th. A longer setlist too! And yes, "BAD" a snippet of "40" were played and so was "I will Follow" and even "All I Want Is You" WOW!

Lucky people indeed!

U2 Concert at Soldier Field, Chicago, IL, USA Setlist on September 12, 2009



 
Now that they are shilling for Balsillie, how much of that Blackberry money is going to African relief?

Bono = Pompous Ass

This is actually the first concert where U2 has had a corporate sponsor in 30 years. Previously, U2 had Apple as a corporate sponsor, but they didn't take the money. (Seriously) Apple made donations to various U2 charities.

But keep talking.
 
I an not sure about no argument. I hate arena/stadium shows with a passion. They simply cannot touch small club or hall shows for me, where it is about the music (and maybe you are playing up the arena aspect, which just leaves me cold). I have never heard skydome sound good *ever*. Granted I was not there (500 for the pair of floor seats I was offered was a joke, and that was face value), but arena rock is more about the spectacle than the music. I also find U2 music-wise hugely derivitive and uninteresting. Glad you liked the show.. and if you are into the spectacle thing... I imagine it was good.. but some shows I have seen in the 70s (Stones, Springsteen, Clash) were incredible on a pure musical basis and rock'n'roll at its most basic. For the 60s, the 30 minute show and review style was the norm. As for impact, I think the real issue is there is no longer a common reference amongst people for shared experience. We have become too fractured. U2 may be one of the last bands that can unite a large audience.

U2 simply can not play small venues any more.

Too many people want to see them. I'm sure they'd love to play Massey Hall again, but they'd have to play it for 120 nights straight to accomodate the 125,000 people that saw them as Sky Dome over the course of 2 nights. It really isn't practical now is it.

The great thing about Thursday's show was that the roof was open. The simple act of opening the roof at Sky Dome improves the sound 1000 percent. No echo, no reverberation, no feedback, etc.

Add to that, the absolute state of the art sound system and you had a sound that was phenominal.

I've seen the Stones (several times), and Paul McCartney, and Springstein, and Van Halen, and Dave Mathews (several times) and Dylan, and The Who, and Metalica, and Smashing Pumpkins, and Pink Floyd, and Page and Plant, and piles and piles of others. I've been to large venues, small venues, clubs, etc.

I'm not talking from lack of experience.
 
Just watch any ABC Good Morning America show with George Step-on-op-po-less. That's where that prick said that. I liked U2 before he did that shit, however. Now they are a corporate band. I'm sure the concert was terrific nevertheless, since they can't get real jobs.

Gyaos Baltar.


So, the fact that Bono raises awareness about Extreme Poverty in this world makes him a prick?

You have a misguided sense of reality friend.
 
Labels like "greatest" are meaningless.

U2 has been my favourite band since they began. I went to both shows this week and I've seen them 10 times now. They are the only band I'd still go to a stadium to see. The second night in Toronto was way better than the first.

But...they are a shadow of the band they were, and seeing them live now is mostly a nostalgic experience. Yes, they're still able to make a stadium feel like an intimate place at times, but the technology, the spectacle, the running around they feel they need to do in order to reach 70 000 people...it all detracts and distracts.

I know I sound like a crank...but the cell phones at these shows bother me. I don't understand people who pay up to $250.00 to attend...and then watch the entire concert through a 2.5 inch screen pointed at a 40 ft screen...when the artists are standing right in front of them, live.

Equally irritating are fans who clearly have no idea of what the band is about. When they sang One, and all these daft couples embrace and kiss like it's a love song...aieee...people are dumb. Reminds me of a wedding I attended, where the couple chose that song as their first dance.

I hear you, but it comes with age now doesn't it.

U2 is not U2 of the 1980's. I'm not the same guy I was in 1983 either (when I first heard War).

I believe it was Larry who once said, "It's hard to be pissed off at the world when you've got shit loads of money in the bank"

I agree with you about the cell phone thing.

By hilarious co-incidence, so does Bono if you check out this clip:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jpR9t4ZZfAo&feature=related
 
I'm a life long HUGE U2 fan. I saw them first on Oct 3, 87 and have not missed one Toronto show since. I get so tired of idiots saying U2 is over hyped or past it. U2 really has nothing to prove. Yet they don't rest on their laurels. They have managed to stat relevant and not become "that band from the eighties." I was at both shows this week and I loved every moment. They made me love songs I hadn't really liked at first. Bono is still an amazing front man. I think U2 is different because we all know they are at any given moment capable of still being "the biggest band in the world". Sure there are periods of U2 I'm partial to but I don't think they've lost anything. I left those concerts really excited about what's next.
 
I wouldn't go that far....

I saw that Boss show too, actually saw Springsteen during "The River" tour for the first time.

Anyway, I was at the Rogers Centre for both shows and I have been a huge fan of U2 since they were first introduced to America-Buffalo radio-back during the WAR lp. They have certainly come a long way and I'll never forget how "New Year's Day" was the first song played on 97Rock in Buffalo. I was hooked and saw them on the "WAR" tour @ Shea's threatre in Buffalo and the balcony nearly collapsed from everyone jumping up and down...

However, last night reminded just how far this established band has peaked! Don't get me wrong-a big production-thousands of people, the Rogers Centre blah blah blah but it was missing a true U2 element only the diehards could understand. We were standing on the floor next to a couple who had no clue about a great tune such as "The Unforgettable Fire" was performed...Talk about a wide range of old and young in the crowd.

I can understand bands like U2 have so many hits that they cannot perform them all especially when you're pushing new material. However, trademark songs and a stack of known hits from an impressive catalogue were absent! Songs that made this band a live spectucale such as "BAD" (actually went to the second show hoping to hear "BAD") and "I Will Follow" and even "40" which had been a traditional closing tune for the band back in the day when each band memeber would leave the stage one by one....The good old days!

Not to harp on the past success of this band but to totally avoid any tunes from "Boy" an album that introduced the Irish band to the world, was strange.

Great time nonetheless but certainly not the best U2 concerts I have seen. For the record, the "WAR" "Joshua Tree", and even the "Achtung Baby" tour at Maple Leaf Gardens blow this tour away by a mile...


[/LIST]

The best U2 I have ever seen was March 1992 - Maple Leaf Gardens - Auchtung Baby. They were so good, I could have cried.

U2 is the last of the rock and roll super-groups.

They still put out relevant music after 30 years and they still find a way to top their previous concerts. (Something for everyone)

The Beatles = Gone since 1970. Imploded due to their own egos.

Led Zepplin = Gone since 1980 with the death of John Bonham due to suffocating in his own puke, the odd concert along the way (2 I think, but obviously lacking John Bonham). Jimmy Page is by all accounts completely full of himself and Robert Plant would rather trapse around town with his girlfriend than do a Zepplin Tour. Though, to Plant's credit, he recently stated, "I felt like I was a cover band of myself" (with respect to why he doesn't want to do a Zepplin Tour) Maybe Robert if you worked with Page and Jones and actually wrote some NEW material.......

Pink Floyd = Gone since 1985 when Waters stormed off in a huff. They can't fucking stand the sight of each other. They were offered something like 500 million to do a tour but the hatred runs so deep, they would not even consider it. With the recent death of Rick Wright - let's face it - why fuck up the memory.

The Who. = Should be called "Who's Left" Died when Moon died of his own excess.

The Stones = still playing in one form or another. Never really been the same since Wyman left and frankly haven't made a relevant album since "Some Girls" in 1978 (30 years ago).
 
I'm a life long HUGE U2 fan. I saw them first on Oct 3, 87 and have not missed one Toronto show since. I get so tired of idiots saying U2 is over hyped or past it. U2 really has nothing to prove. Yet they don't rest on their laurels. They have managed to stat relevant and not become "that band from the eighties." I was at both shows this week and I loved every moment. They made me love songs I hadn't really liked at first. Bono is still an amazing front man. I think U2 is different because we all know they are at any given moment capable of still being "the biggest band in the world". Sure there are periods of U2 I'm partial to but I don't think they've lost anything. I left those concerts really excited about what's next.

I agree. Very well put.

Funny (true) story about U2.

Back in 1981, I remember I was in High School and I was reading the HAMILTON SPECTATOR (seriously - the Spectator) and this guy wrote an article about U2. In a nutshell, he wrote that U2 was "the next Beatles" At the time, I had never heard of U2. But I was a MASSIVE Beatles fan (which all my High School friends thought that I was nuts for because the Beatles were so yesterday). Anyway, it was blasphemy to my Beatle-maniac heart. It was not even remotely possible for anyone to be "the next Beatles".

I automatically had a hate on for U2. (And I didn't even know a single song that they sang!!) Didn't matter. If anyone dared say that someone was the next Beatles, I hated them.

Then came 1983 and the release of war. I was 19 years old and incredibly angry at the world at the time. I heard "New Year's Day" in my buddy's Honda Civic as we were bombing around one day and he CRANKED it up. I was completely blown away.

"Who is that band?" I asked him.

"U2" he said

"No fucking way, I can't like them. They are the band that that prick said was going to be the next Beatles"

I tried to hate them again. Silly as it may seem.

He played New Year's Day again. I loved it even more.

I went out and bought the album (still have all my vinyl albums) and I've been a huge fan ever since.

That journalist - whoever he was, back at the Hamilton Spectator in 1980 or 81 was right. He saw it all before it ever happened.
 
I never have understood people who are so sure Bono is a prick. Maybe he is...I don't know...is it the glasses? They bug me a bit. But when I ask, usually the answers I get have something to do with his attempts to raise money for poor people. Yeaaaah.....I guess they're right, he's a prick.
 
I'm a major U2 fan.. but I'm not a huge fan of large concert venues.

Unfortunately the only time I saw them play live was the zooropa tour at the CNE grounds some years ago.. I wasn't impressed. I prefer listening to them at home cranked to the hilt!
 
Like most things with a generation gap you can't compare them. Those of a particular age will reflect on what was the best to them during that time.

I grew up with U2 growing into the biggest band in the world. There's no way I could say they helped define an entire generation like the Beatles did. Not even close.
 
Loved them years ago, really cant get into their new stuff. I'm also in the camp that they are corporate sellouts now, the BB relationship flies in the face or what rock is all about.

Bono is taking his lumps these days in the mass media. On Sirius XM O&A were ripping him good today about his "carbon footprint" with 203 tractor trailers hauling two stage set ups all over North America.

Yes, but if you boil that down to 125,000 fans entertained at Skydome in 2 days, how does it compare to say some band tooling around in an old beat up bus playing to 20 fans a night? How much pollution is generated per fan in each case?

I'll think you'll find that U2 is far more environmentally friendly than that small bar band when you actually do the math.