I an not sure about no argument. I hate arena/stadium shows with a passion. They simply cannot touch small club or hall shows for me, where it is about the music (and maybe you are playing up the arena aspect, which just leaves me cold). I have never heard skydome sound good *ever*. Granted I was not there (500 for the pair of floor seats I was offered was a joke, and that was face value), but arena rock is more about the spectacle than the music. I also find U2 music-wise hugely derivitive and uninteresting. Glad you liked the show.. and if you are into the spectacle thing... I imagine it was good.. but some shows I have seen in the 70s (Stones, Springsteen, Clash) were incredible on a pure musical basis and rock'n'roll at its most basic. For the 60s, the 30 minute show and review style was the norm. As for impact, I think the real issue is there is no longer a common reference amongst people for shared experience. We have become too fractured. U2 may be one of the last bands that can unite a large audience.
U2 simply can not play small venues any more.
Too many people want to see them. I'm sure they'd love to play Massey Hall again, but they'd have to play it for 120 nights straight to accomodate the 125,000 people that saw them as Sky Dome over the course of 2 nights. It really isn't practical now is it.
The great thing about Thursday's show was that the roof was open. The simple act of opening the roof at Sky Dome improves the sound 1000 percent. No echo, no reverberation, no feedback, etc.
Add to that, the absolute state of the art sound system and you had a sound that was phenominal.
I've seen the Stones (several times), and Paul McCartney, and Springstein, and Van Halen, and Dave Mathews (several times) and Dylan, and The Who, and Metalica, and Smashing Pumpkins, and Pink Floyd, and Page and Plant, and piles and piles of others. I've been to large venues, small venues, clubs, etc.
I'm not talking from lack of experience.