being christian

wrong: we are dumping on christians because they hurt women and gays
Are you attempting to tell us with anything approaching a straight face that the United Church or the Anglican Church currently have a policy of hurting women and L/G people?
 
Women and gays (and Muslims) have more freedom and rights in Christian countries than in any other countries. Try being a woman in Pakistan or a homo in Iran.

tell that to the 15 year old gay kid in Ottawa who just committed suicide...oops, too late.
 
Are you attempting to tell us with anything approaching a straight face that the United Church or the Anglican Church currently have a policy of hurting women and L/G people?

the united church is very progressive and the anglicans are getting there, but the catholics, evangelicals, baptists, and orthodox are the majority and remain backward.
 
we are dumping on christians because they hurt women and gays

What about the atheists that hurt women and gays?

Unfortunately religion (all kinds) has been used by people to justify many things. That's really not the fault of the religion. That's people being people. If you want someone to dislike than you should choose people who want power over other people. They can be found among all ethnic groups and religions and genders and they love people (like yourself) who can't see deeper than the surface of the water.
 
tell that to the 15 year old gay kid in Ottawa who just committed suicide...oops, too late.

Shit happens even in a Christian country but unlike Iran our government does not legally hang homos by the neck until dead. Or, how about that woman sentenced to 90 lashes for criticizing the Iranian government.
 
the united church is very progressive and the anglicans are getting there, but the catholics, evangelicals, baptists, and orthodox are the majority and remain backward.
Good of you to agree that you are painting with a overly broad brush.
 
To me being a Christian is simple. Just try to be a good person towards other people realizing that no one is perfect. And if you fuck it up, just try again tomorrow.
 
the united church is very progressive and the anglicans are getting there, but the catholics, evangelicals, baptists, and orthodox are the majority and remain backward.

The UCC is the second largest denomination in Canada.

And here is the deal on homosexuality. They don't hurt homosexuals directly, they just think the acts they engage in are wrong. Guess what, they live in a free country and are allowed to have different morals from me (and presumably) you. They are not in government lobbying to have homosexuals thrown in jail, they don't suggest they cannot have the vote etc. They just disagree with what they do. And you happen to disagree with them, that is how a civil society works.

In fact you will find that many famous Christians have fought in favour of gay rights and advocate on behalf of gays. It is one of the little known facts about President Reagan that before he was President he fought hard for gay rights.

The question on women is a little more detailed, and really requires looking at one denomination at a time. But if you look at RC's all they really do is prevent women from being clergy.
 
To me being a Christian is simple. Just try to be a good person towards other people realizing that no one is perfect. And if you fuck it up, just try again tomorrow.
Although I believe Jesus limited the essentials of religion to loving God with all one's heart, mind and soul, and one's neighbour as oneself, I think to be a capital 'C' christian, would require some belief in the Christ dying on the cross to redeem sinners.

It is fascinating how seldom the eponymous Saviour has made it into these posts. Even more so when we consider that in less enlightened times 'our' Christianity went head-to-head with 'their' Mohammedanism. Before we recognized that the central prophet of Islam was just a man.

But I like your criteria a lot as it allows for atheist, buddhist, animist, muslim and other sorts of Christians, and any of those believers could easily find texts and traditions in their religions that said the same.
 
Are you saying that non-faith based systems or causes or not causing any deaths right now? You are aware that the overwhelming majority of historical wars were fought over causes other than religion? And the very, very worst of them were not about religion either? You are aware of these facts right?
Non faith are causing, but religion certainly plays a MONSTEROUS role in deaths, no doubt about it. If not the MAJOR cause then it's an INCREDIBLY close second, if not, it's definitely too close to call. A LOT of people base their life decisions through their faith - ie - Obama being Muslim was a huge issue for a lot of Christian conservatives in the 2008 election cycle. Anyone remember this incident when it came to light?
http://abcnews.go.com/Blotter/us-military-weapons-inscribed-secret-jesus-bible-codes/story?id=9575794

http://www.secular.org/issues/chaplains

Heading into enemy territory and causing more problems.

http://blog.beliefnet.com/news/2009/05/new-accusations-surface-agains.php

But deaths in the name of religion is ironic and it just shows that anyone kills in the name of their religion is a hypocrite and anyone who believes their religious faith to be "THE" is also part of the problem. I can go on and on...
 
Don't think any bible scholar can provide a definitive answer to your question.
According to Jesus it is sinful for a man just to look at a woman with lust.
So it is reasonable to infer from his teaching that hobbying is unacceptable.

Matthew 5:27--30
“You have heard that it was said, ‘You shall not commit adultery.’ But I tell you that anyone who looks at a woman lustfully has already committed adultery with her in his heart. If your right eye causes you to stumble, gouge it out and throw it away. It is better for you to lose one part of your body than for your whole body to be thrown into hell. And if your right hand causes you to stumble, cut it off and throw it away. It is better for you to lose one part of your body than for your whole body to go into hell."



This just needed a refresher for Aard' and the like...
 
This just needed a refresher for Aard' and the like...

Except back when the scripture were written it was much the case and therefore not wrong. Those who read the scriptures as guidelines got that message a long time ago and those who haven't, bitch loud and clear how out of dated the scripture are in some places. so should be tossed aside all together. There certainly isn't anything wrong with the golden rule. It's passed the test of time and has been adopted by many great and not so great cultures and religions.
 
Personaly I would rather look at John 8:3 -8:11 "The woman taken in Adultry"

The question I suppose boils down to do you believe that God is Love.

There is a great scene from You've got Mail which in a way addressses this.

Joe Fox says to Kathleen: "Well, let me ask you something. How can you forgive this guy for standing you up and not forgive me for this tiny little thing of... of putting you out of business? . . . Oh, how I wish you would."

If God forgave the repentant thief, what does it say about anyone's understanding of God that they do not believe God will forgive non abusive fornication?

Cobster apparently missed this the first time - puzzling given his obsession.
 
Non faith are causing, but religion certainly plays a MONSTEROUS role in deaths, no doubt about it. If not the MAJOR cause then it's an INCREDIBLY close second, if not, it's definitely too close to call. A LOT of people base their life decisions through their faith - ie - Obama being Muslim was a huge issue for a lot of Christian conservatives in the 2008 election cycle. Anyone remember this incident when it came to light?
http://abcnews.go.com/Blotter/us-military-weapons-inscribed-secret-jesus-bible-codes/story?id=9575794

http://www.secular.org/issues/chaplains

Heading into enemy territory and causing more problems.

http://blog.beliefnet.com/news/2009/05/new-accusations-surface-agains.php

But deaths in the name of religion is ironic and it just shows that anyone kills in the name of their religion is a hypocrite and anyone who believes their religious faith to be "THE" is also part of the problem. I can go on and on...

That is some pretty ticky-tacky shit there. The interesting phenomena you might wish to consider as that as Europeon Society became less religious, it became much more violent. The numbers killed in WWII and other non-religious persecutions and wars dwarfs anything religion has brought about. The 30 years war IIRC barely breaks the top 20 list.

And many people, probably you included believe that your way of thinking is likely the best. Scientists often function the same way, politicians, doctors, lawyers, judges...why should the religious have to act differently than the rest of the population?
 
That is some pretty ticky-tacky shit there. The interesting phenomena you might wish to consider as that as Europeon Society became less religious, it became much more violent. The numbers killed in WWII and other non-religious persecutions and wars dwarfs anything religion has brought about. The 30 years war IIRC barely breaks the top 20 list.

With all due respect (and I do mean that), I think the numbers killed in WW2 (and WW1, and the Vietnam War, and the Korean War, etc.,.) had more to do with the advancement of technology, rather than lack of religion.

I'm pretty sure that if that if they had the ability to carpet bomb during the 30 years war, they would have seen a much higher body count.
 
With all due respect (and I do mean that), I think the numbers killed in WW2 (and WW1, and the Vietnam War, and the Korean War, etc.,.) had more to do with the advancement of technology, rather than lack of religion.

I'm pretty sure that if that if they had the ability to carpet bomb during the 30 years war, they would have seen a much higher body count.

Perhaps, but so what? The claim was that more people have died in the name of religion and apparently that's not the case overtly or not.

Where do you file the the Spanish flu and the Black Plaque; shit happens, the hand of God, human ignorance, or the straw that broke the camels back?
 
Perhaps, but so what? The claim was that more people have died in the name of religion and apparently that's not the case overtly or not.

Where do you file the the Spanish flu and the Black Plaque; shit happens, the hand of God, human ignorance, or the straw that broke the camels back?

What I was trying to get across was that as religion was becoming less important in society, technology was advancing..

So the fact that the body count was so low before isn't necessarily related to anything other than the fact that they didn't have the weapons of mass slaughter that we have today.

rld made the connection (not me) in an effort to show that killing in the name of god isn't so bad (as killing for other reasons than god has resulted in more deaths).

I tend to agree.. Shit happens.

I think if people weren't killing other people in the name of god, they'd be killing for other reasons..
 
With all due respect (and I do mean that), I think the numbers killed in WW2 (and WW1, and the Vietnam War, and the Korean War, etc.,.) had more to do with the advancement of technology, rather than lack of religion.

I'm pretty sure that if that if they had the ability to carpet bomb during the 30 years war, they would have seen a much higher body count.

Well, if you like we can compare the numbers of wars that were based on religious issues with those that were not...it is also overwhelmingly in favour of non-religious.

You also underestimate the way that armies in that period razed the countryside and what they did to populations after sieges. But certainly there can be no doubt that non-religious causes have influenced people to act is ways that are at least as bad as the worst religious causes...

Edit: I don't make the point to prove that non-religious wars are inherently worse than religious wars...I make the point to disprove the oft-repeated muyths that:

a) religion has killed more people than anything else; or

b) most wars in history were started by religion or fought for religious reasons.

Which are both untrue.
 
What I was trying to get across was that as religion was becoming less important in society, technology was advancing..

So the fact that the body count was so low before isn't necessarily related to anything other than the fact that they didn't have the weapons of mass slaughter that we have today.

rld made the connection (not me) in an effort to show that killing in the name of god isn't so bad (as killing for other reasons than god has resulted in more deaths).

Except the number of deaths from carpet/strategic bombing was a lot less than the methods used by the Stalinist Russians and the Eastern communist.

Dresden has been estimated to be anywhere from 15,000 to 50,000 depending on who's counting. Oddly enough, the German in their ever efficient methodical way claimed the lesser. The other great raid into Germany produced similar numbers.

I can't remember where I read it but more than 2 million people died in France from D-Day to Liberation and most by far were not killed in combat or bombing, but at the hands of the soldiers and civilians.
 
how many people in Africa died of Aids before the Catholic church would condone the use of condoms?