Canada's International Reputation

Rockslinger

Banned
Apr 24, 2005
32,764
0
0
It never fails to amaze me why some Canadians are so overly concerned about Canada's "internationl reputation". What has the international community ever done for Canada except criticize us for our oil sands and seal hunt?
 
Sounds like something to be proud of and not complain about Aardie....;)
 
The Germans treated captured Canadian soldiers better than we're treating the Afghans.

Except for those they murdered.

Seriously, Canada is hardly gaining a reputation as a nation of war criminals. This is a non-story outside of a Canadian media that is giddy with a chance to throw rocks at Steven Harper and those nasty conservatives. We are one of, if not the, most anal nation when it comes to treating others well, and the fact that some poor Afghan who the Canadians rescued from some of his asshole countrymen was beat up a bit (not tortured, by the way, but beat up - yes it may seem like semantics but there is a difference) is simply another indication of how good an upright we Canadians are. We RESCUED the guy.

But....by all means keep spinning this into a Canadian Watergate. MacKay should definitely be fired for not having read the field notes of some obscure Sergeant three years ago. :rolleyes:
 
The point isn't really how Canadians are perceived abroad, but that the Liberals are able to trash Canada's reputation abroad in order to attempt to score political points at home.

Not even the NDP have been so crass political opportunists, even though they have a stronger position on the topics the Liberals are currently attempting to leverage.
 
The point isn't really how Canadians are perceived abroad, but that the Liberals are able to trash Canada's reputation abroad in order to attempt to score political points at home.

You are right. Canada can do a million things right in Afghany and maybe do one thing less than perfect and the Liberals are harping on that one thing ad nauseam. This has to be demoralizing to our brave troops risking their lives in the field.
 
You are right. Canada can do a million things right in Afghany and maybe do one thing less than perfect and the Liberals are harping on that one thing ad nauseam. This has to be demoralizing to our brave troops risking their lives in the field.

Of course they are....

They're chomping at the bit to be "entitled to their entitlements" yet again....
 
and the Liberals are harping on that one thing ad nauseam

Yeah you're right, what are a few war crimes anyway.

Let me get this straight: The C's commit war crimes. Now it's the L's fault that our reputation is being damaged for pointing it out and demanding it stop.

Are you guys on drugs?
 
Yeah you're right, what are a few war crimes anyway.

Let me get this straight: The C's commit war crimes. Now it's the L's fault that our reputation is being damaged for pointing it out and demanding it stop.

Are you guys on drugs?

OxyContin does seem to be their drug of choice.
It helps explain the peculiar way they simulate reasoning....:rolleyes:
 
I'm just wondering how brainwashed you have to be to blame the opposition for the damage to our reputation as a result of the governments war crimes.

Let me put it this way: Better we deal with this ourselves than have the ICC issue arrest warrants for our cabinet ministers.
 
You are right. Canada can do a million things right in Afghany and maybe do one thing less than perfect and the Liberals are harping on that one thing ad nauseam. This has to be demoralizing to our brave troops risking their lives in the field.

What is probably even more demoralizing to our troops is knowing that their political leaders and top military brass are not abiding by the accepted standards of modern warfare. I'm sure there are times when our troops have absolutely no doubt that the Taliban fighters they've captured were engaged in hostilities against us. So they may not feel any remorse about those detainees eventually being tortured by the Afghan gov't. But there would also be times when our troops feel compelled to detain bystanders and people whose guilt is purely circumstantial. How would you feel about handing someone over to the authorities knowing they may be innocent but knowing also that they'll probably be beaten or worse? There are enough bad things happening to our troops without them having to worry about the proper treatment of detainees. That proper treatment should be a given.

The fact that the opposition and Canadians in general want the government to abide by the terms of the Geneva convention should not demoralize our troops. They would know all about those guidelines and it should come as no surprise that there will be repercussions if those guidelines are ignored.
 
Why not? The Conservatives blame the Liberals for everything past, present and future.

Yeah you're right, what are a few war crimes anyway.

Let me get this straight: The C's commit war crimes. Now it's the L's fault that our reputation is being damaged for pointing it out and demanding it stop.

Are you guys on drugs?
 
their are more people in canada screming about our reputation than there are people outside the country complaining about it. Not surprisingly the bulk of them are opposition politicians.

As for Fuji's statement that the Germans treated our soldiers better than we treat the Afghans

You Sir ARE FULL OF SHIT
 
The Germans treated captured Canadian soldiers better than we're treating the Afghans.

The naivite of this remark is astounding. Does this fellow have the foggiest idea about the subject ? Is he typically this way ?
 
Excuse me? Having lost many relatives to the Germans during WW1&2, I take personal offense to your statement.

Your relatives must have been Soviet soldiers then.

The documentary evidence is that the Germans treated Western POW's in accordance with the Geneva Conventions, including even Jewish soldiers who were in British, Canadian, or American uniform. The main complaint POW's had was the lack of proper food, but realistically, the food provided was similar to what the Germans provided to their own soldiers. They simply had a shortage due to the allied blockade.

Soviet POW's in Germany, on the other hand, were not treated in accordance with the Geneva Conventions and in fact over a million of them died. The Germans perceived that the Soviets weren't following the GC with their soldiers, and so they reciprocated. The German justification for this was that the Soviets had not signed the Geneva Conventions, but legal historians generally agree the German treatment of Soviet prisoners was illegal and constituted a war crime. The GC specifically requires signatories to extend GC protection to the soldiers of non-signatory nations.

Statistically speaking, an equivalent number of Western allied POW's died in Germany camps (3.5%) as German POW's died in Western POW camps, a reasonable figure on both sides given that some of those captured had battle injuries.

I defy you to find a credible source that alleges gross systematic mistreatment of Western POW's in WW2.