I am beginning to think Fuji is the shoplifter.
lol me too, or at least related to him!
Can't believe he's defending a criminal.......
I am beginning to think Fuji is the shoplifter.
I am beginning to think Fuji is the shoplifter.
Incorrect. The shopkeeper did not apprehend him at a time that he was committing a crime, but instead played deputy dodge, and "arrested" him based on prior evidence, in other words, on nothing more than suspicion.
I put "arrested" in quotes because in reality there were no lawful grounds for a citizens arrest and therefore it was actually assault and forcible confinement.
Unrelated. The shoplifting plea related to events at a different time and are irrelevant.
Just asking - how do bounty hunters stay within the law? They don't seem to have to wait for their quarry to commit a crime before their very eyes -- they just dive in and grab him. Does anybody know how that can be legal?
Why can't the shopkeeper be classed as a bounty hunter, rather than a vigilante?
lol me too, or at least related to him!
Can't believe he's defending a criminal.......
People like fuji are a danger to our society
Actually not incorrect, the person plead out the shop lifting charge that was the cause of this incident.
If a citizen sees an offence take place they have every right to pursue and detain for the authorities a suspect.
The fact that the crown has withdrawn the kidnapping charge is sproff of this if there were any basis for the charges to be upheld as a matter of law they would have been carried through.
There was no loack of evidence that the shopkeeper did chase down and detain him.
I don't know if I have all the facts, I'm sure some of you will help me out here, lol, but this is what I know:
-owner of a store was robbed of some plants
- owner checked video surveillance and has the culprit on video
- culprit returns to the store about an hour later and store owner chases the culprit as he tries to get away, captures him, ties him up, puts him in the back of a truck until police arrives.
Now, this store owner has been charged for assault, forcible confinement, carrying a concealed weapon and kidnapping. The judge threw out the concealed weapon and kiddnapping charges but said he will go to trial for assault and forcible confinement. WTF? And to add salt to the wound, the culprit is going to testify against him and he may face a maximum of two years in jail!!!!! The culprit only got 30 days and he's out, if not soon.
This is what happened to a Toronto grocer, David Chen.
Am I missing something here? Are our laws better suited for crooks than the law abiding citizen? This sounds so bizarre.
Ok, your turn, lol.
So many posts, so little time. In a nutshell, everything Fuji says is right, and I am actually having problems believing the ignorance level in some posts about the law. Apparently we have no rights, but we can:
a) defend ourselves
b) defend others
c) defend our property and
d) intervene to stop a crime in progress by placing someone under citizen's arrest
Sounds like we can do everything we need to do. As fuji has pointed out frequently in this thread once the crime is over, it is a matter for the police. Even if you witness a crime in progress, most lawyers would advise you to dial 911 instead of trying to play Starsky and Hutch. Why? Because citizens are like most people in this thread, and don't understand the law. They don't know how to effect a legal arrest, and they expose themselves to prosecution, and may limit the crown's ability to pursue charges.
Let's assume that the shop keeper did have the legal right to place the shoplifter under citizen's arrest. Did he: a) inform him he was being placed under citizens arrest; b) inform of him of the charge for which he was being arrested; c) inform him of his right to remain silent and his right to counsel; and d) turn him over to a police officer at the earliest opportunity? Unless he did that, it was not a legal arrest. Now you may say, "but he's not a cop, he doesn't have to do that." Well, yes he does.
See Thompo, if you follow the letter of the law (which has been my point all along) the VICTIM (the shopkeeper in this case) loses his right to protect his property. Yeah yeah yeah, the thief didn't actually get around to stealing THIS time, but with photographic proof that he did previously, the shopkeeper had a pretty good idea that he was about to commit another crime.
See, the point I am trying to make is, as you stated, we SHOULD have the right to defend ourselves, our property, others etc. According to the LETTER OF THE LAW, we cannot prevent a crime from being committed. For example, someone can come up to us, demand our money, pull a knife, and according to THE LETTER OF THE LAW we have no RIGHT to defend ourself as he has yet to assault/rob/or committed any other offence against us. Telling us to give him our money? That's not against the law. Carrying a knife? Unless it is oversize that isn't against the law.
To make matters worse, according to THE LETTER OF THE LAW, he could rob rape and murder your wife right in front of you, then come back the next day and say the above, and, according to the LETTER OF THE LAW you cannot do a damn thing about it. (because, according to the LETTER OF THE LAW he has to be actually in the act of committing an offence before you can do something). Taking that one step further, you actually have to let someone stab you before you can defend yourself......
My biggest problem with this case is the fact that we, as citizens, cannot truly prevent crime, cannot actually catch criminals, even though the police can't be bothered, are too busy, or ??
As I've quoted before: you can convolute the wording all you want, but you cannot change the concept behind the law (which SHOULD be that if we are a victim of a crime, and the perpetrator comes back for more, we should be able to defend ourselves, detain them, and turn them over to the police).
See Thompo, if you follow the letter of the law (which has been my point all along) the VICTIM (the shopkeeper in this case) loses his right to protect his property.
Yeah yeah yeah, the thief didn't actually get around to stealing THIS time, but with photographic proof that he did previously, the shopkeeper had a pretty good idea that he was about to commit another crime.
See, the point I am trying to make is, as you stated, we SHOULD have the right to defend ourselves, our property, others etc.
According to the LETTER OF THE LAW, we cannot prevent a crime from being committed. For example, someone can come up to us, demand our money, pull a knife, and according to THE LETTER OF THE LAW we have no RIGHT to defend ourself as he has yet to assault/rob/or committed any other offence against us.
To make matters worse, according to THE LETTER OF THE LAW, he could rob rape and murder your wife right in front of you, then come back the next day and say the above, and, according to the LETTER OF THE LAW you cannot do a damn thing about it.
My biggest problem with this case is the fact that we, as citizens, cannot truly prevent crime, cannot actually catch criminals, even though the police can't be bothered, are too busy, or ??