Winter Tires

Winter Tires

  • Goodyear(I am leaning toward these)

    Votes: 3 5.9%
  • Firestone

    Votes: 1 2.0%
  • Dunlop

    Votes: 2 3.9%
  • Bridgestone

    Votes: 7 13.7%
  • BF Goodrich

    Votes: 1 2.0%
  • Michelin

    Votes: 28 54.9%
  • Cooper

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • other, please name

    Votes: 9 17.6%

  • Total voters
    51
Stating the obvious here but, other than convenience, the reason to use steel wheel in the winter is to avoid salt damage to expensive aluminum alloy wheels.
 
Stating the obvious here but, other than convenience, the reason to use steel wheel in the winter is to avoid salt damage to expensive aluminum alloy wheels.

The other part that can be purchased, especially if you hate the look of bare steel wheels and the obvious protection factor, are the plastic hub caps. I had my set thrown in for cost, $29 a set. Kind of makes you wonder what profit they make on them at CT.
 
The other part that can be purchased, especially if you hate the look of bare steel wheels and the obvious protection factor, are the plastic hub caps. I had my set thrown in for cost, $29 a set. Kind of makes you wonder what profit they make on them at CT.

Yeah. A couple of times I've bought plastic caps from a dealership. In both cases, they originally quoted some outrageous price, and then when I declined, they offered a 4-for-1 deal on the price. Funny how much and how quickly they could drop like that. lol. Happened at both Acura and VW dealerships.

Alloy rims will corrode a bit but I've seen many black, steel rims rusting, and in bad condition.

Aluminum anodizes in the presence of salt. It starts as blackening, but will progress to blistering. It's true that steel wheels will rust, but they are a lot cheaper than alloy wheels ($50, versus hundreds of dollars), and they can be sanded and spray painted fairly easily when they start looking too rough.
 
Alloy rims will corrode a bit but I've seen many black, steel rims rusting, and in bad condition.

Replacing steel wheels is a lot cheaper than replacing alloy wheels. Steel will rust but a little care and plastic hubs help. Seel wheels can take a lot more punishment against hidden potholes and such. I've had mine trued up after hitting a snow covered man eating pothole.
 
I priced out a few places and it looks like I can get Michelin X Ice for a great price at Kal, with a mail in rebate of something like $70 each. With new steel rims, I'm looking at about $1000 all in. The dealer was about $1200 plus tax, but they also store the set not being used. Canadian Tire was a reasonable price for Nordics, and the benefit there is they will swap the wheels for free in the spring and fall.

Apparently the Kal tire website wasn't clear enough for me. The $70 rebate is per set, not per tire lol. Regardless, they can't get them in my size, as the Michelin warehouse shows zero stock. He priced out the Nokian's mentioned upthread, and it was pretty reasonable. They are a little high on the price of steel rims, so I might buy elsewhere (Costco is $48 per wheel). Costco was a touch cheaper for Blizzaks as well.

As for rims, we have a 2009 Grand Caravan, and the wheels I had from our 2005 Grand Caravan didn't fit. Canadian Tire didn't have anything to fit it, and the dealer quoted me $135 each for plain black steel rims. I went to a wrecker and they got me the exact same alloy rims the van already had for $75 each. Regular car washes through the winter has kept them looking good after 4 winters so far. They are actually in better looking shape than the ones used for summer. Money talks though, so I doubt I will bother asking them for a quote for my Sorento.
 
Hi all.

Thanks for your opinions ... I went with the Michelin X Ice.
 
Hi all.

Thanks for your opinions ... I went with the Michelin X Ice.

Good decision on the tires. I have used Michelin X-Ice and Bridgestone Blizzaks on the same car. I give the edge to the X-Ice tire for both snow and ice traction and and also wear. I found OEM wheels on the internet for the winter but I would consider steel rims if they could be found in the proper size. Remember it can be better to go with a very slightly narrower rim and tire for winter because of the increased weight per square inch on the road. That can open up more sizes that would be available.

Also, you might need to have the car computer reprogramed if you have radio frequency tire pressure senders on the valve stems. RF senders are now available after market for about $65 each. I stayed with a separate set of OEM rims and OEM RF senders but I still need to have the computer reset when I make the seasonal switch.
 
In the end, the OEM steel rims cost me $20 more than the multi-fit ones that I could have got from crappy tire, so, about $90. So, now, I have a good, hub-centric fit.