Who's the victim?

Von Wigglestaff

Rock me Amadeus
Jan 23, 2004
804
0
0
Takeshi Castle
By now everyone must have heard the news that Robert Baltovich has been granted a new trial for the murder of his girlfriend Elisabeth Bain. He was convicted in 1992 on circumstantial evidence since Bain's body has never been found.

My gut tells me that he's guilty as sin, but my head isn't entirely sure. However, I find it galling that Baltovich's lawyers claim that he's a victim - GIVE ME A FARGIN BREAK! The Bain family has not been allowed to mourn their loss and now they must re-live the nightmare all over again.

Baltovich's lawyers say that Paul Bernardo should be considered as a possible suspect - this could be Baltovich's undoing. Elisabeth Bain's body has never been found and we already know that Bernardo is too stupid to pull that trick. The behaviour of the prosecution, after Bernardo's conviction, suggests that he may not have actually killed anyone. All we know conclusively is that Karla killed her youngest sister Tammy.

Whatever happens, the Bain family has my deepest sympathies.
 
Baltovich is either not guilty and got shafted or his lawyer is very smart and tries shift blame from him away to Bernardo. Same thing happened in B.C. with the pigfarmer, his lawyer tried to shift blame away to the Green River Killer who was caught a few years ago.
Problem was, however, that his farm was littered with DNA form at least 20 murdered women. Try talking your way out of that one.
 
Von Wigglestaff said:
However, I find it galling that Baltovich's lawyers claim that he's a victim - GIVE ME A FARGIN BREAK!

Certainly the Bain family has suffered and are victims of a terrible crime, but IF Baltovich is innocent, then he and his family have also suffered and are victims for sure. Being dragged through the courts and thrown in jail for years for a crime he did not commit would be a personal disaster for him and his family. Sure that if you were in that position you would feel like a victim.

If someone else did commit this crime, they not only destroyed the Bain family, but also the Baltovich family.
 
Whenever these difficult cases are dragged through the courts and the media and victim word is applied, I tend to reflect on other justice methods and have utopian thoughts on applicability to our grotesque bureaucracy.

Many "tribal" justice systems focus on immediate remedy to the hurt family and almost ignore determination of guilt. Debate centers on amount and type of compensation. Example - a death or a theft occurred, it's obvious, investigation of method and time is irrelevant and compensation is to be payed for the loss. However, they rely on a fundamental different concept of family: the collective.

Like I said, utopian thoughts, difficult to apply to our society. Except for this: the deceased isn't "hurt", her family is hurt. In this aspect we are no different.