When an Expert Disagrees with the Experts

Look. You don't have to run an antibodies test on every one. I agree. However, we can say to the YOUNG people who have had covid and no side effects(pretty much all of them)- don't worry, go back to your lives. Wanna shot take it, but it's not necessarily. Simply, you run the honest numbers, assess the risks and act accordingly. Most importantly, let the family doctors call the shots. And what are we doing instead? We are vaccinating everyone, whether they need it or not, and pretending that once we got all vaccinated, everything will be fine.... while using a drug that lasts 5 months.

I think you are not taking the situation seriously enough. We are in a worldwide pandemic of a new unknown virus. Local family doctors follow protocols and guidelines. When there is none yet written, facing a new virus for which they knew nothing, they suggest to follow public health advice and measure. It would be a complete waist of their time to give consultation to all the population on what to do case by case. And they would be too busy to treat their regular patient for other healthcare issues.

I do not know about Ontario but here in Quebec the vaccine passport is doing great. It made most of the younger (12-30) who were not vaccinated to get the shot.
 
you mean politics works by consensus.

In a democracy politics should absolutely work by consensus. Same in science. Consensus from your peers is the most fundamental thing.

A business does not have to work by consensus. This is where most people are not capable to draw the line.
 
I think you are not taking the situation seriously enough. We are in a worldwide pandemic of a new unknown virus. Local family doctors follow protocols and guidelines. When there is none yet written, facing a new virus for which they knew nothing, they suggest to follow public health advice and measure. It would be a complete waist of their time to give consultation to all the population on what to do case by case. And they would be too busy to treat their regular patient for other healthcare issues.

I do not know about Ontario but here in Quebec the vaccine passport is doing great. It made most of the younger (12-30) who were not vaccinated to get the shot.
Do you know what the vaccine passports include in the EU? Yes, you can get one if you are unvaccinated providing that you have recovered from COVID-19. Curious, isn't it?
 
Do you know what the vaccine passports include in the EU? Yes, you can get one if you are unvaccinated providing that you have recovered from COVID-19. Curious, isn't it?

I didn't know that but it's not curious at all. Their public health leader think that antibodies from recovery is enough to get the passport. Fine with that. Here it's not. Honestly there is not right or wrong here because the passport is only a tool to get more people vaccinated.

Oracle posted a few weeks ago about a study that shows that antibodies were stronger then the vaccine. This weeks some studies came out that it may not be. For me this debate is futile because herd immunity, without a vaccine, is absolutely out of the equation.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Valcazar
I didn't know that but it's not curious at all. Their public health leader think that antibodies from recovery is enough to get the passport. Fine with that. Here it's not. Honestly there is not right or wrong here because the passport is only a tool to get more people vaccinated.

Oracle posted a few weeks ago about a study that shows that antibodies were stronger then the vaccine. This weeks some studies came out that it may not be. For me this debate is futile because herd immunity, without a vaccine, is absolutely out of the equation.
You know that and I know that, but where is the policy reflecting that in Canada?
 
You know that and I know that, but where is the policy reflecting that in Canada?

As far as I know Canada's policy is focusing on global Covid research, providing vaccine distribution and border access. Then they imposed a vaccination policy within their own federal employee.

It's each province that decides their own policy regarding vaccine passport and public health measures.
 
As far as I know Canada's policy is focusing on global Covid research, providing vaccine distribution and border access. Then they imposed a vaccination policy within their own federal employee.

It's each province that decides their own policy regarding vaccine passport and public health measures.
You know that the health.policy is driven by Ottawa, right?
 
You know that the health.policy is driven by Ottawa, right?
Actually no, JC. It's driven by the provinces.

That's why your heroes in AB and SK fuck up so much. If Trudeau was running things, they'd go a lot better.
 
In a democracy politics should absolutely work by consensus. Same in science. Consensus from your peers is the most fundamental thing.

A business does not have to work by consensus. This is where most people are not capable to draw the line.

It's also why people say stupid things like "Government should be run like a business."