What's a good weakness?

Interviewers hear "I'm a perfectionist", "I often work so hard that I don't take breaks", "I sacrifice my personal time to ensure that a job is performed to perfection" ALL THE TIME. People think that they can state something that isn't a weakness, pretend that they think it's a weakness, and therefore impress the interviewer. You're insulting the interviewer's intelligence by hoping that he/she will think, "Wow, that's not really a weakness at all. I'd love to have someone here that thinks he has a PROBLEM with working TOO hard...." These are answers to AVOID. Even if they are true, they have become cliche and your interviewer will likely feel that you're hiding a TRUE weakness or just trying to tell them what they want to hear. Remember, most interview questions are designed to test behavioural traits.

The proper way to answer this question is to choose something (true) that is shortcoming, but isn't a critical skill in the job that you're seeking. Additionally, you want to indicate what you're doing to overcome or eliminate the weakness. As an example, if you're applying for grad school, (depending on the subject matter) you might say that you don't like to have delegate because you find it challenging to assess the skills of the people to a particular role. That's a skill that may not be needed in your job so the person that's doing the hiring likely wouldn't care and (more importantly) might appreciate your 'honesty'. You wouldn't want to give that 'weakness' if you were applying for a role as a bank manager, though, since that skill would be crucial. After naming the weakness, though, you'd quickly name the way that you cope with it. e.g. "...but I find that since I've identified that it's not something that I like to do, I tend to be more observant now about those that I work with to identify their strengths. That way, if I'm called upon to delegate, I can confidently assess the situation and match the role to the employee..." It's an interview. Impress the person!....don't give them the answer that 4 people before you gave and the 2 people after you will give. What if they're better looking than you or are better actors/actresses than you?
 
It's a bad question. If you truly have a weakness of significance that you haven't been able to overcome, whatever you do don't reveal it during the interview; you'll just give the other candidates a leg up.

Just pick something minor and say how you overcome it. I usually say I take on too much responsibility or work too much on one project and I overcome these things by setting priorities and deadlines.

Trust me, it's a garbage question. Unless you're dumb enough to spill the beans on something important ("I was fired for fraud from my last job..."). It's more of a "Why shouldn't we hire you?" question and it tests the intelligence to weed out the idiots. If you really think being honest is going to help you in an interview, there's about another thousand unemployed chumps out there who you should meet.

Note: I'm not telling you to lie, I'm telling you to emphasize the positive over the negative.
 
sbbohm said:
Interviewers hear "I'm a perfectionist", "I often work so hard that I don't take breaks", "I sacrifice my personal time to ensure that a job is performed to perfection" ALL THE TIME. People think that they can state something that isn't a weakness, pretend that they think it's a weakness, and therefore impress the interviewer. You're insulting the interviewer's intelligence by hoping that he/she will think, "Wow, that's not really a weakness at all. I'd love to have someone here that thinks he has a PROBLEM with working TOO hard...." These are answers to AVOID. Even if they are true, they have become cliche and your interviewer will likely feel that you're hiding a TRUE weakness or just trying to tell them what they want to hear. Remember, most interview questions are designed to test behavioural traits.

The proper way to answer this question is to choose something (true) that is shortcoming, but isn't a critical skill in the job that you're seeking. Additionally, you want to indicate what you're doing to overcome or eliminate the weakness. As an example, if you're applying for grad school, (depending on the subject matter) you might say that you don't like to have delegate because you find it challenging to assess the skills of the people to a particular role. That's a skill that may not be needed in your job so the person that's doing the hiring likely wouldn't care and (more importantly) might appreciate your 'honesty'. You wouldn't want to give that 'weakness' if you were applying for a role as a bank manager, though, since that skill would be crucial. After naming the weakness, though, you'd quickly name the way that you cope with it. e.g. "...but I find that since I've identified that it's not something that I like to do, I tend to be more observant now about those that I work with to identify their strengths. That way, if I'm called upon to delegate, I can confidently assess the situation and match the role to the employee..." It's an interview. Impress the person!....don't give them the answer that 4 people before you gave and the 2 people after you will give. What if they're better looking than you or are better actors/actresses than you?

Couldn't have said it better.
 
sbbohm said:
Interviewers hear "I'm a perfectionist", "I often work so hard that I don't take breaks", "I sacrifice my personal time to ensure that a job is performed to perfection" ALL THE TIME. People think that they can state something that isn't a weakness, pretend that they think it's a weakness, and therefore impress the interviewer. You're insulting the interviewer's intelligence by hoping that he/she will think, "Wow, that's not really a weakness at all. I'd love to have someone here that thinks he has a PROBLEM with working TOO hard...." These are answers to AVOID. Even if they are true, they have become cliche and your interviewer will likely feel that you're hiding a TRUE weakness or just trying to tell them what they want to hear. Remember, most interview questions are designed to test behavioural traits.

Makes perfect sense in writing, but in real life, I've seen many (including myself) that uses this answer and is successful in landing the job. Perhaps there aren't as many 'seasoned' interviewers as you think. Or, it might just be in the delivery itself.

The proper way to answer this question is to choose something (true) that is shortcoming, but isn't a critical skill in the job that you're seeking. Additionally, you want to indicate what you're doing to overcome or eliminate the weakness. As an example, if you're applying for grad school, (depending on the subject matter) you might say that you don't like to have delegate because you find it challenging to assess the skills of the people to a particular role. That's a skill that may not be needed in your job so the person that's doing the hiring likely wouldn't care and (more importantly) might appreciate your 'honesty'. You wouldn't want to give that 'weakness' if you were applying for a role as a bank manager, though, since that skill would be crucial. After naming the weakness, though, you'd quickly name the way that you cope with it. e.g. "...but I find that since I've identified that it's not something that I like to do, I tend to be more observant now about those that I work with to identify their strengths. That way, if I'm called upon to delegate, I can confidently assess the situation and match the role to the employee..." It's an interview. Impress the person!....don't give them the answer that 4 people before you gave and the 2 people after you will give. What if they're better looking than you or are better actors/actresses than you?

How about, "I have a weakness for women, and I'm coping with it by surfing Terb and booking incalls/outcalls" :p
 
fearnoevil2005 said:
Makes perfect sense in writing, but in real life, I've seen many (including myself) that uses this answer and is successful in landing the job. Perhaps there aren't as many 'seasoned' interviewers as you think. Or, it might just be in the delivery itself.

In a job-seeker's market, yes. In an employer's market, you will need whatever edge you can get, and saying something original will help you to stand out from the rest.