Nobody had any recommendations, so I relied on local reviews and decided on the Cotton Club.
It opened at 6 on Sunday and I got there around 9. It was dead with three girls visible and one guy.
By the time I left a few hours later, I had two girls dance for me. The first I forgot her name, but enjoyed her dancing. The second, Treasure, was black and a little heavier than my ideal, but she was a lot of fun and we spent a lot of time together.
The place got busier and time passed quickly.
The stage was dark, it was hard to see the girl dancing.
I can't say I saw any knockout girls there, but I'd go back if I was ever in St. Johns.