TQM said:
find one sentence - one sentence that I've said that was false.
Since you asked........
TQM said:
So far, I've claimed:
a) not much was gained
False: The germans held the ridge since 1914. There was a huge tactical advantage in holding the ridge and the Germans realizing this, dug in like no other place along their line.
The Great War was fought incorrectly by both sides. The advances in weaponry were not considered and the war was fought along lines in a traditional manner that failed to incorporate weapons advances. Because of a failure to adjust tactics to suit these advances in technology, neither side made any significant advanace during the entire course of the war.
The capture of Vimy Ridge was a huge gain in a war that was plagued with insignificant territorial gain by either side.
TQM said:
b) the cost was very high
False: Although losing only one of those fine Canadians in battle was a loss, the enemy suffered greater losses. The Canadians suffered 10,000 casualties vs. 20,000 casualties for the Germans. What is most remarkable about this is that the Germans had a huge tactical advantage of the higher ground. Any battle commander will tell you that holding the higher ground almost always gaurantees victory (Pickett's charge at Gettysburg comes to mind).
In the 2 years since Germany occupied the ridge, the French suffered 150,000 casualties trying to take it back. Although significant, the Canadian cost was not very high in comparison.
TQM said:
c) there had been only two previous attempts on the Ridge.
False:The French tried repeatedly to take the ridge since 1914. Hence the 150,000 casualties.
TQM said:
d) Canadians were used because those in charge devalued Canadians.
I'm not privy to any information that proves British command devalued Canadians, are you?
TQM said:
e) It led to a great sense of Canadian nationalism.
True: You finally got one right.