US Oil Grab Coming?

Nearlynormal: You ignorant liberal pig-dog who's mental capacity borders on the infinitessimal...

Oh, wait...

*muttering "Be the example, be the example"*

*ahem*

Nearlynormal: I respectfully disagree with you. I respect your opinion, and your views on this crazy planet. All the best to you and yours! *hugs*
 
Goober Mcfly said:
So the US is going to plant evidence of WMD?

*tosses tin-foil hat to TravellingGuy*

I would be amazed to hear at the end of it all that they didn't find any, that would have a huge negative affect for the US. What I want to know is how come they haven't targetted any of the WMD that they knew existed. Before the war the US was slow in delivering "evidence" to the UN, they claimed to be protecting intelligence sources etc, what is there to protect now?

If you want to support your troops why not ask why they haven't been targetting the WMD,you would think that neutralizing the WMD would be a primary objective,potentially saving your troops lives as well as many innocent Iraqi's if Saddam is crazy enough to use WMD, and if he's not crazy enough to use them then why are we focusing on Iraq instead of North Korea?

Perhaps the US doesn't want to take out the WMD because they want to give Saddam time to use them to prove their point to the world, I'd hate to think this because thats a great loss of life. Could it be the US can't find the WMD? They haven't found Bin Laden yet either.

*tosses oil-filled-hat to Goober*
 
Not another one of these posts again. How interesting to find out that Dick Cheney's company Haliburton has one of the major oil contracts lined up after this war. The Iraqi people may want to be liberated, but dropping cruise missiles on them is not the way i would do it. Today they dropped bombs on a shopping mall and as per usual they called it a accident. This war will cost well over 500 billion dollars, i am sure there are more pressing things in the world that money could have gone too.

Bababooie stick to watching Howard Stern!. There is no connection between 9/11 and Iraq. The only terrorists are south of us and they are called AL-Republicans. As Lennon would say give peace a chance, look what they did to him.
 
With

nearlynormal said:


Rebuilding Iraq is going to take a few years. Even with the UN firmly on side, it will be a difficult task to restabilize the ME and repackage the US as an agent of goodwill. If the US tries to go it alone without plenty of UN cover, they are going to look way too dominant and all-conquering. Then they will have to do everything the hard way and will still end up being hated. Not an option!

UN assistance a couple of years, shorter without. I think Powell made a speech within the last 24 hours that said that the UN would "have a role to play" or something like that. A Congressman on NPR aliened it to the UN troops in South Korea under US command. The US and UK will have paid the price (in cash and blood) and will not turn over control to the UN, who can't manage their way out of a paper bag. This is especially true if there was any way for the French to benefit.

OTB
 
Wouldn't it

nearlynormal said:
Yep!! I find it interesting that they keep finding gas masks and injectors to administer the antidote for nerve gas but no chemical weapons. Why would they equip all these guys with gas masks etc. but not the gas? Very fishy! I think we can be absolutely certain that they will "find" every imaginable WMD. As the saying goes: "The first casualty of war is the truth."

have been better to plant WMD in Iraq 2-3 weeks ago when the second resolution was dying? There have been special forces in Iraq for months, not that hard to drop a trailer into the desert I wouldn't think.

The real evidence will be the scientist that talk about their work, or will those be plants as well?

Ah how they yearn for the great conspiracy....

OTB
 
Are we sure

MRMARCUS said:
.... Today they dropped bombs on a shopping mall and as per usual they called it a accident. ....

it was the US? If this is the same report I'm thinking about the US said there was nothing targeted in that area and they suspect Iraqi missiles accidentally or purposely landed there. Or has there been a more recent development.

I think it's a bit surprising that after a week of intense bombing the Iraqi's have so little propaganda to show for it. Says something about how well the US / UK targeting has been.

I'm sure there will be civilian casualties, and that is tragic. But at least our guys are not standing behind them shooting.

OTB
 
The problem with Powell is that he doesn't have too much influence in the Bush Adm for now. Specially, when many superhawks in DoD camp can't wait to get rid of him. I doubt whatever he is saying right now will not be adopted by dumb&dumber GWB.

This illegal war has nothing to do with liberation of Iraqi people, WMD, or anti-terrorism. It's all about oil grab and geopolitical expansion of American power. Sadly, average Americans are buying these liberation lies. Isn't it curious to average Americans why American GI's are only getting bullets instead of flowers?
Why are Iraqis giving unexpected strong resistence to so called American liberators? American media are now telling people that resistence is manly from some sorta Saddam death Squat or Saddam loyalists. Personally, I think not. It's really average iraqi who are picking up arms fighting the foreign invaders. Between Saddam and American Invaders, many iraqi would probably think Saddam is lesser of 2 evils. I believe many American GIs will soon ask why we are at this war?

What's worst is that the Iraqi War is only the beginning of series of wars planned by bunch of neoconservative ideologues. People like Richard Perle, Paul Wolfwitz, Bill Kristol are true "Axis of Evil". They have planned this outright aggression dated back 1992. And they cease the moment when 9/11 tragedy occured.
 
TravellingGuy said:
What I want to know is how come they haven't targetted any of the WMD that they knew existed.
How do you know they haven't?
Before the war the US was slow in delivering "evidence" to the UN, they claimed to be protecting intelligence sources etc, what is there to protect now?
Umm, the intelligence sources? Now, more than ever, they need to protect their assets within the Iraqi government.
If you want to support your troops why not ask why they haven't been targetting the WMD,you would think that neutralizing the WMD would be a primary objective,potentially saving your troops lives as well as many innocent Iraqi's if Saddam is crazy enough to use WMD, and if he's not crazy enough to use them then why are we focusing on Iraq instead of North Korea?
I don't think Saddam will hesitate to use any WMD he has, as a last resort. He's most concerned with his stature in the Arab world. He's going to be a martyr, and take many, many of his own people along (as "martyrs") in the battle against the infidel.

Perhaps the US doesn't want to take out the WMD because they want to give Saddam time to use them to prove their point to the world, I'd hate to think this because thats a great loss of life. Could it be the US can't find the WMD? They haven't found Bin Laden yet either.
*checks TravellingGuy's tin-foil hat for fit, and adjusts accordingly*
 
you aint seen nuttin yet...
 
Goober Mcfly said:
How do you know they haven't?
If they had don't you think they would have released that information to the skeptics to help increase the support for this war? By not finding any WMD,or by finding them and not releasing the information they are making themselves look even worse in the international community.

Goober Mcfly said:
Umm, the intelligence sources? Now, more than ever, they need to protect their assets within the Iraqi government.

They don't have to reveal their source, all they have to do is use this great information that they supposedly have/had and neutralize the threat from the WMD.

Goober Mcfly said:
I don't think Saddam will hesitate to use any WMD he has, as a last resort. He's most concerned with his stature in the Arab world. He's going to be a martyr, and take many, many of his own people along (as "martyrs") in the battle against the infidel.

I don't doubt that Saddam would be a martyr, if Saddam has WMD then we'll see him use them, however what if he doesnt use any then maybe he never had them to use, that combined with none being found would throw a wrench into the whole belief that this was about WMD.
 
TravellingGuy...

No amount of evidence would ever convince the skeptics! This is obvious because the skeptics have forgotten Iraq's track record over the last 12 yrs.

Neutralizing the threat of WMD is easier said than done. The information that is coming out of the war now does point to the Iraq's planning an attack. And if they don't...all the better. This war has never been about the WMD solely. It is much more!
 
Posit: The US provides evidence they destroyed/captured a chemical weapons plant. The world asks for hard evidence, and when presented with pictures/canisters/whatever, the conspiracy theorists begin to say that it's all staged to justify the invasion.

Another posit: The US releases the proof from an intelligence source, without revealing the identity. The Iraqi gov't will be able to trace the leak (they have ways, selected disinformation for example). The 'leak' is executed, together with his family. What does that gain?
 
I don't know about that....

fortiffanyonly said:
The problem with Powell is that he doesn't have too much influence in the Bush Adm for now. Specially, when many superhawks in DoD camp can't wait to get rid of him. I doubt whatever he is saying right now will not be adopted by dumb&dumber GWB.

It was Powell and Blair that encouraged Bush to pursue the diplomatic route, that didn't work out so well. He's a bit more moderate than some in Bush's cabinet but I don't think it's lost on the Bush admin how popular he is. I think when he turned the corner for war that was when many in the US turned the corner as well.

Bush can't talk his way out of a paper bag, but as someone who is very good at public speaking I'd tell you there is a difference between presentation and an ability to think.

fortiffanyonly said:

This illegal war has nothing to do with liberation of Iraqi people, WMD, or anti-terrorism. It's all about oil grab and geopolitical expansion of American power. Sadly, average Americans are buying these liberation lies. Isn't it curious to average Americans why American GI's are only getting bullets instead of flowers?

Is this view printed in some sort of leftist propaganda manual that you all have under your pillow? I think the US has a very distinguished record of giving people their country back after a war, in fact I'd challenge you to find a better role model for that than the US!

The American people would not stand for colonialism, it would be the surest way to a single Bush term.

fortiffanyonly said:

Why are Iraqis giving unexpected strong resistance to so called American liberators? American media are now telling people that resistance is manly from some sorta Sadam death Squat or Sadam loyalists. Personally, I think not. It's really average iraqi who are picking up arms fighting the foreign invaders. Between Sadam and American Invaders, many iraqi would probably think Sadam is lesser of 2 evils. I believe many American GIs will soon ask why we are at this war?

I think if you're too young to remember Vietnam this seems like resistance. A limited number of guys standing behind civilians (or posing as them) shooting a small number of our guys is not what you call strong.

This fight was over before it began, the only question is how may casualties on both sides and how much time.

fortiffanyonly said:

What's worst is that the Iraqi War is only the beginning of series of wars planned by bunch of neoconservative ideologues. People like Richard Perle, Paul Wolfwitz, Bill Kristol are true "Axis of Evil". They have planned this outright aggression dated back 1992. And they cease the moment when 9/11 tragedy occurred.

I'd have to say that while Bush was mocked for his Axis of Evil speech he's looking a bit prophetic at the moment. Don't forget that Bush is begging the UN and the region to deal with North Korea. The Chinese are walking away. Perhaps Canada should handle this one, you're closer.

9/11 has changed everything down here. Before 9/11 offense was never considered a political reality even if it was the best course of action, only defense. I think the American people have come to understand that a good offense is sometimes the best defense. Seen Osama on TV lately?

OTB
 
Re: Re: With

nearlynormal said:
I agree about the efficiency of the UN. Too many fingers in the pie and too many conflicting interests. Most western governments could outmanage the UN blindfolded etc. But the US still needs UN cover (sanction) and a fairly broad range of international partners to give legitimacy to the rebuilding effort. To get that UN sanction, the US will have to hold its nose and give something to the French and the Russians.

The Iraqis, their ME neighbours and the EU/UN could make the rebuilding almost impossible if they perceive the US as acting out of spite or self interest rather than for the good of Iraq. The US tried desperately to get UN sanction before the attack for a damned good reason. It would have sanitized the war effort and shifted the overall responsibility (blame) onto the UN community as a whole. The same logic applies even more for the rebuilding phase. If he acts alone, Dubya's critics will be watching his every move, just waiting for the slightest abuse of power or unfair benefit to the US. He'll be the one holding the smoking gun if he's not careful.

Because Dubya went ahead and attacked without UN sanction, he needs everything to go off with a minimum of glitches. He is out on a political limb which gets weaker as the casualties mount and the war drags on. By the time it is over, he probably won't be in a position to be too picky about who his partners are. And he'll no longer be protected by that patriotic imperative to rally 'round our troops fighting overseas. The political knives will be back in force so he'll need a happy ending, many happy partners and a happy UN.

I think that's the traditional view and one that Tony Blair is pushing. I also think that Bush was so stung by what happened at the UN that he will seriously consider largely ignoring the UN and let it play only a token roll (think troops in South Korea).

I find average Americans (what ever those are) that would have thought UN basher were just crazies 12 months ago are starting to wonder why we bother. The League of Nations fell apart because it became irrelevant, I think the UN will have to work hard to show it can do anything worth doing. Otherwise why pay for all those guys here in NY that are double parked with diplomatic plates.

I think the key to turning Arab opinion around has nothing to do with the UN and everything to do with balancing our policy toward the Palestinians and Israel. Peace in Israel and a Palestinian state will go along way. If Bush doesn't spend the rest of his first term (after this war) making that happen then he is an idiot.

OTB
 
Re: Re: Wouldn't it

nearlynormal said:
Neither of us is really much of a fan of conspiracy theories but I'll make a rare exception in this case. I think Dubya would have little choice but to plant some token WMD if none are used during the war and they can't be found afterwards. If Dubya were to let that happen, he would be practically crucified for all that bogus WMD evidence and for causing the unnecessary deaths of thousands. He would be part laughing stock and part monster. It would also damage US credibility beyond repair. Not going to happen.

I agree that such a WMD plant would look pretty flimsy once the Iraqi scientists spoke out but it would allow the spin doctors to muddy up the waters enough to shield Dubya from a direct hit. Maybe the scientists don't really know WTF happened to the WMD after all this time. Maybe only a portion was destroyed etc. Meanwhile Dubya wriggles free.

If it were going to be done it would have happened a month ago. Think for a minute how hard this is to find. We still can't find the *sshole who mailed those Anthrax letters to Senators. Now this is in our own country with active participation from everyone except one person and we still can't find him (it's always guys who do this *sshole *hit). Now extrapolate that to a country the size of California with Stalinist dictator, police state and no independent access to scientists.

What large credible country has asserted that Iraq has no WMD? None. Do you think that is an oversight?

OTB