I don't post often but do read these threads and there are clearly some educated fight fans on here.
Which if why I find it confusing that whenever there is a close decision that education seems to slip completely from there brains.....he was robbed....that guy looked like he was beaten to a pulp....etc. There seems to be little understanding of a 10 point round system although its been in place since the UFC has been relegated.
Damage done does not continue over on the score card. In the cage between the fighters for sure, one guy may be wobbled, tired etc and it will affect his ability to perform giving the other fighter and edge in the next round but on the score card once a round is done its scored and the next round starts even, every round is its own entity.
That being said I had scored the fight for Hendricks but there was plenty of room for doubt when watching the fight objectively that the judges call wasn't shocking.
Round 1. I scored it close and gave Hendricks the edge.
Round 2. Hendricks clearly had his best round and rocked GSP numerous times, if he had shown more killer instinct maybe he pushes harder and gets a 10-8 round but they are and should be hard to get from a judge.
Round 3. GSP goes to work and wins this round, whether Hendricks was starting to gas or conserve energy he should have gone balls out this round based on damage he did in the previous round. If you give a round away you have no one to blame or complain to after the fight, they all know how the round system works and if your corner is wrong on one round that's the fight. They assumed Hendricks was up 2 going into 3rd and were wrong.
Round 4. Hendricks clearly wins this round and does some damage in ground and pound after GSP slips. Again he did damage but the score card doesn't care in the next round that you cut him with an elbow, it only counts on the scorecard for that round and that round only.
Round 5. GSP clearly wins this round IMO and Hendricks and his corner make the mistake once again in thinking they are well ahead and don't take the fight to GSP. Hendricks looked fresher and was stronger than GSP(a rarity in all of GSP's career) but GSP was the one trying to finish even if he didn't have the power or energy to do so.
The judges, online writers and most fans I have talked to and read comments from had Hendricks winning 2 and 4, with GSP winning 3 and 5. Not a whole lot of dissention on those rounds and how they were scored. Leaving the 1st round which I thought was close and had given to Hendricks, the judges obviously thought it was close as well as that was the only round they were split on with 1 giving it to Hendricks and 2 to GSP.
As stated earlier I had Hendricks winning the fight but when its that close calls of :Robbery", "What a Joke" baffle me.
My thoughts exactly. Thank you for taking the time to post.
Fightmetric's full statistical report:
http://blog.fightmetric.com/2013/11/st-pierre-vs-hendricks-official-ufc.html
Couple of additional thoughts:
Johny Hendricks was the stronger (I was shocked the way he muscled GSP around in the clinch) fighter who, for the most part, controlled the fight. But he didn't act like a champion - during the fight, in the ring after the decision an in the press conference.
Round 1 was very close - Hendricks power shots probably carried it. The challenger had GSP rocked in round 2 and instead of trying to finish the fight, he grappled and rode out the clock. He basically took round 3 off, doing virtually nothing. In round 4, Hendricks had Georges down and was ground and pounding him and inexplicably let the fight go back to their feet. And in round 5, he just went through the motions, didn't finish strong, didn't show any hunger/desperation and barely made more of a showing than in 3. A real champion would have made the effort to take the title in at least a couple of those instances.
Worse, after the decision, he showed absolutely ZERO class by not only berating the judges and fans, but by not showing GSP even a modicum of respect befitting the long-time classy champion and ambassador of the sport. Even after having time to reflect afterwards, he followed it up in the press conference with further disrespectful comments. (I won't even comment on the dip and spitting into a bottle in front of the media, but yuck.)
Dana White should learn to STFU. GSP does not "owe it to the fans, the UFC and Johny Hendricks" to have an immediate rematch. GSP owes it to himself to take care of his health and personal issues before even thinking about getting back into the octagon. If anyone noticed, Georges wasn't even going to say anything about taking some time off until Rogan kept badgering post-fight in the octagon. Worse, after his "private" talk with GSP and Lorenzo Fertitta, Dana had the nerve to say Georges' issues "aren't as bad as he thinks they are." Douche.
Personally, I hope GSP leaves them all in limbo until he's good and ready to make a decision.
Onto the card:
Evans-Sonnen: that's what happens when a motivated Rashad fights a blown-up middleweight pretender. Not sure what's next for Evans; he's still way down the light heavyweight pecking order. Sonnen can now go and focus on Wanderlai for an old-timers' grudge match after their stint on TUF: Brasil.
MacDonald-Lawler: not sure what's going on with Rory. The Jake Ellenberger fight was a bad sign, but this one was inexcusable. He should have easily won that fight. Part of me wonders if the Carlos Condit fight has had the same effect as the Matt Serra fight had on GSP. Good for Lawlor, but he'll get badly exposed by the top experienced 170lb-ers.
Woodley-Koscheck: Kos 2.0 destroyed the original version. Woodley has a lot of work to do to be a legit title contender, but he's a hard worker and a HUGE welterweight. Good luck to Kos in the future - either in Bellator or as UFC welterweight gatekeeper; he always worked hard and gave his best.
Bagaulinov-Elliott: the fight was 'meh', but the Dagestani was the star of the press conference. Hilarious!