Transmission Fluid Change Question

This is where old info crashes new info. .... The best way to maintain your car is to do as suggested in the manual.


How about the clue in the very first line of the original post?

"Over the weekend, I uncrewed the bolt on my auto transmission drain pan, drained out the fluid, cleaned the debris on the bolt magnet"

His transmission has a drain plug, and with a magnet on it no less. I think that is a pretty good clue that the manufacturer intended the transmission fluid to be changed as a matter of routine maintenance.

Would you not agree?


What
 
Over the weekend, I uncrewed the bolt on my auto transmission drain pan, drained out the fluid, cleaned the debris on the bolt magnet, and the put in 4 new litres of transmission fluid in the funnel up top.

The question I have is with the drain and refill method how long do you go before doing a second drain and refill.

i understand with the drain and refill of the pan as opposed to system flush, you don't get any of the dirty transmission fluid in the torque converter. So you have to drive a while so that the dirty oil in the torque converter slushes in and mixes with the oil in the drain pan.

But how long do I have to drive before draining and refilling again. Is one week good enough or should I drive 4000 km before draining and refilling again.

Thanks for any info. I've never changed my own transmission fluid before.



You did good!

You could drain off and refill another 4 litres after driving around for 4-5k kms so that the new fluid's fresh detergent additives might help clean up the transmission a bit and then replenish and dilute with some fresh fluid.

I don't know the mileage on your vehicle or how hard you drive etc etc but it would not be a bad idea or wasteful to drain off and refresh 4 litres every 20-30k when it is so easy to do with the drain plug.
 
You did good!

You could drain off and refill another 4 litres after driving around for 4-5k kms so that the new fluid's fresh detergent additives might help clean up the transmission a bit and then replenish and dilute with some fresh fluid.

I don't know the mileage on your vehicle or how hard you drive etc etc but it would not be a bad idea or wasteful to drain off and refresh 4 litres every 20-30k when it is so easy to do with the drain plug.

Excellent advice :thumb: On my Equinox I have a drain plug as well with magnet and there's not even a trans. pan to remove. it also has a permanent oil filter . So I drain and refill every 35K Keeps the fluid fresh.
 
Transmission fluid should never be changed in most cars. You should never have to break the sealed compartment which contains the transmission fluid.

lol
i guess you should do the same for engines

mind blowing how people come up with this shit
 
You did good!

You could drain off and refill another 4 litres after driving around for 4-5k kms so that the new fluid's fresh detergent additives might help clean up the transmission a bit and then replenish and dilute with some fresh fluid.

I don't know the mileage on your vehicle or how hard you drive etc etc but it would not be a bad idea or wasteful to drain off and refresh 4 litres every 20-30k when it is so easy to do with the drain plug.


Yea, thanks. I'm thinking about driving for about 4 or 5 weeks before swapping out another 4 liters of fluid then doing 4 liters every year or so.
It might be my imagination but, I think the shifts are smoother with the newer transmission fluid.

I watched a few videos on Youtube of people doing the drain plug method to freshen up their transmission fluid.

One video was from a guy in the States who just bought a used Corolla or something like that with 150,000 miles on it or so, and the stuff coming out into his drain pan was just pure dirty brown mud. No way you could guess it was transmission fluid.

He was talking through the video and said his guess is that this car had never had a transmission fluid change in it's entire life.
That must have been amazing engineering work that went into that transmission to be able to go so long on such dirty, polluted transmission fluid.
 
Yea, thanks. I'm thinking about driving for about 4 or 5 weeks before swapping out another 4 liters of fluid then doing 4 liters every year or so.
It might be my imagination but, I think the shifts are smoother with the newer transmission fluid.

I watched a few videos on Youtube of people doing the drain plug method to freshen up their transmission fluid.

One video was from a guy in the States who just bought a used Corolla or something like that with 150,000 miles on it or so, and the stuff coming out into his drain pan was just pure dirty brown mud. No way you could guess it was transmission fluid.

He was talking through the video and said his guess is that this car had never had a transmission fluid change in it's entire life.
That must have been amazing engineering work that went into that transmission to be able to go so long on such dirty, polluted transmission fluid.

You don't need to wait that long. You can literally drain some out, refill go for a 15 minute drive come back and repeat. The fluid mixes almost instantly.
You'll never get rid of all the junk in your fluid this way but it sure beats doing a mr.lube complete flush that can really fuck your car up.
 
One mechanic told me that transmission is like a pair of boots. Once it's broken in, best thing is to leave it alone. My father, who is a mechanic, never changed tranny fluid in any of his vehicles. He did for other people as requested. I've never changed transmission oil on any of my Monte Carlos or Buicks. I never lost a transmission.

And that info is based on how many cars and miles? When I changed the tranny oil on my car (Aisin 5 speed auto) at 109K km, it was definitely much darker then new fluid, the magnet plug was full of metal, and it definitely shifted smoother after, and the hard downshift when stopping was gone. So far another 80K km has passed. A friend of mine had his mother Camry tranny fail at 160K km (aisin as well) original fluid, 20 years old city driven. It really has a lot to do with temperature and shifts. If you do mainly highway driving, its probably fine to never change the fluid. If you are stopped in traffic with the engine constantly at high temps in the summer, or towing, then you are asking for it if you do not change the fluid. When you are cruising on the highway the transmission is locked up, so the torque converter is not being used and you are getting very little fluid shear. The valve body and clutches are not cycling and the gears are not shifting. When you are stopping and starting all that changes. And when all these things operate they wear, shed metals and fiber and shear the fluid.
 
This is where old info crashes new info. New fluids are different from old fluids. When I had my first car the automatic transmission fluid change was at 80,000 km. There was also this notion that if you had an old car that had old transmission fluid that was never changed past the recommended time it was better to leave it alone. The reasoning is that if you drain the old oil out and put new fluid in, the new fluid had detergents that would wash the dirt off the interior of the transmission and cause it to float around and make problems. The fluids today are different from back 30 years ago, these days many are synthetic and the transmissions are no longer 4 speed automatic and many are 8 steeps dual clutch. The best way to maintain your car is to do as suggested in the manual.


How can you assume that. The manual would be a MINIMUM, also many things like 0W20 oil are really designed to help the manufacturer meet things like CAFE while they allow more wear (although making it through the warranty period) How does BMW or Mercedes or any manufacturer lose when your transmission fails at 160K km? Unlikely even to be the original owner.
 
Honda recommends never flushing the transmission, just draining and refilling.
 
And that info is based on how many cars and miles? When I changed the tranny oil on my car (Aisin 5 speed auto) at 109K km, it was definitely much darker then new fluid, the magnet plug was full of metal, and it definitely shifted smoother after, and the hard downshift when stopping was gone. So far another 80K km has passed. A friend of mine had his mother Camry tranny fail at 160K km (aisin as well) original fluid, 20 years old city driven. It really has a lot to do with temperature and shifts. If you do mainly highway driving, its probably fine to never change the fluid. If you are stopped in traffic with the engine constantly at high temps in the summer, or towing, then you are asking for it if you do not change the fluid. When you are cruising on the highway the transmission is locked up, so the torque converter is not being used and you are getting very little fluid shear. The valve body and clutches are not cycling and the gears are not shifting. When you are stopping and starting all that changes. And when all these things operate they wear, shed metals and fiber and shear the fluid.

All cars I ever had ended up as high mileage vehicles(above 200k). I put almost 400k on a Superduty before retiring it earlier this year from full time use. All city driving. Perhaps I'm lucky. I do service our vehicles religiously, including engine oil every 20k, air filter, etc. The new medium 6 cylinder, turbo diesel truck that we use in the city(3k per week so far), is currently at 140k. The tranny oil is as clear as the day I picked it up at the dealership. New technology, I guess.
 
All cars I ever had ended up as high mileage vehicles(above 200k). I put almost 400k on a Superduty before retiring it earlier this year from full time use. All city driving. Perhaps I'm lucky. I do service our vehicles religiously, including engine oil every 20k, air filter, etc. The new medium 6 cylinder, turbo diesel truck that we use in the city(3k per week so far), is currently at 140k. The tranny oil is as clear as the day I picked it up at the dealership. New technology, I guess.

Fewer temperature cycles are also a plus. Each cool down and warmup cycle on a transmission results in outside air being cycled thorough the housing. Also cruising around in towtruck that is designed to pull 12000 lbs but is empty most of the time is not really a good comparison to cars.
 
Fewer temperature cycles are also a plus. Each cool down and warmup cycle on a transmission results in outside air being cycled thorough the housing. Also cruising around in towtruck that is designed to pull 12000 lbs but is empty most of the time is not really a good comparison to cars.

I don't own a tow truck.