Hello James, in response to your counterpoints:
Cyclists should be required to put lights on their bikes front and back just like cars by law under penalty of the law. Enough with the free pass in that.
I DO have lights on the front and back of my bike, though, as per my original point, this is not an all-solving visibility panacea. I ride in the CITY, where there are street lamps everywhere lighting up the area (and ME). I don't go off-road often, but the few times I do, they front light does come in handy and I don't want to be stopped by cops, so I mounted them. Back in the day, reflectors had to be on the front of the bike (where the light is), the back of the bike under the seat (where the rear light IS), and on the pedals. Reflectors become illuminated when a headlight shines on them, and created visibility already. Worked for decades...
Cyclists (like many pedestrians) can utterly disregard every single rule of the road with impunity and get away with it. Enough already. But I digress.....
This sub-rant has nothing to do with what I'm talking about. Bad cyclists breaking the rules and endangering everyone (motorists, cyclists, pedestrians, etc.) has nothing to do with making them mount lights and people now pushing for reflective vests. All I'm trying to say is the vest is overkill. I simply wear LIGHT clothing. If a driver can't see my white t-shirt or canary yellow hoodie for warmth, he's got issues!
It makes no sense to me whatsoever your argument that a driver or anyone else should be able to see a pedestrian in the dark with dark clothing on. No sense at all.
I'm not advocating that people should dash across the road in dark clothing, but the claim "they're a ninja and materialized out of nowhere!" doesn't hold water with me. By this line of reasoning, do you also believe there shouldn't be dark car colors available either? Because not all of them out there have constant running lights and as I driver I've seen more than one vehicle on the 401 at dusk/evening without their lights yet on and thus being a black moving blob in one's vision, yet I'm still able to SEE them.
Take a look at any construction site. Day or night, they have to wear reflective safety vests[...] Working on the 401 behind concrete barriers (even) at night, they need vests, reflectors on their hard hats, reflectors on the cuffs of their pants. The reason is simple. High visibility. You want to be seen so as not to be injured. Humans are not cats.
I'm an engineer, I've seen plenty of construction/industrial sites as well as the OHSA. What you willingly seem to be obtuse about is that construction sites have vehicles with differing fields of vision. In the mining insustry there is a giant truck known as a Kress Hauler. The operator cab is like 10 feet off the ground and has a blind spot you could park a bus in. Naturally visibility is a major concern for heavy industrial equipment.
As for working on the 401, you're standing on the FREAKING HIGHWAY. Of course you need to be as visible as possible, and hence the reduced speed zones and "double fines when workers are present" signs. It's a very dangerous situation to be in... However I have yet to successfully get my bicycle on the 401 so I consider that a moot argument for why I should have to wear a Reflective vest. I simply don't dress in dark colors, that is more than enough common sense without the sissy nanny-state measures some are proposing. I take my personal safety in my own hands since I'm black and we learn from an early age that no one is going to give a shit running us over. I cross purposefully, I drive defensively, and I cycle the same. I don't follow every rule of the road (I practice the Idaho Stop), but I don't launch myself without regard into a busy intersection... If there's no cars, THEN I jay-walk, cross illegally, etc. No harm done.
Cheers and best wishes to you. Believe it or not, I think we both believe in sensible road conduct for ALL users. We just seem to slightly disagree over what that entails.