Toronto pedestrian Cross walk protocol question

Just my opinion, but he should have pressed the button to double-down on his personal safety, or just waited until you shot by if you were the only car coming. I'm a pedestrian/cyclist and there are times where we need to get off our high horses and wait 2 seconds to let a car go by, especially if it's the only one impeding us before we can cross safely anyway.

The only part of your original post I care less for is the "color of his clothing argument". Your car has headlights, and if they are operating correctly, there is no reason you can't see someone crossing PERPENDICULARLY to your direction of travel. That should stand out like a sore thumb, and even a mystery black humanoid shape crossing the road should give any driver pause.

This past 15 years I've watched things shift from bicycles simply needing reflectors on their pedals (a normal expectation), to having to have lights on them (front white and rear red), and now even some are lobbying for people to wear bright neon vests. If your contrast vision is THAT bad that you can't see a person floating 3 feet off the ground on a bicycle, you might need an optometrist and a bus pass.
 
I saw him at the last minute and stood on the brakes. Not even close, but he gives me the one finger salut and so I roll down the window and tell him, "push the button moron"

If you can use the law of physics to gravitate to a no ticket outcome if set forth automobile pass crosswalk, than the finger salute would just be a fuck you salute.

Stopping Distance Formula
If a driver puts on the brakes of a car, the car will not come to a stop immediately. The stopping distance is the distance the car travels before it comes to a rest. It depends on the speed of the car and the coefficient of friction (μ) between the wheels and the road. This stopping distance formula does not include the effect of anti-lock brakes or brake pumping. The SI unit for stopping distance is meters.

d = stopping distance (m)
v = velocity of the car (m/s)
μ = coefficient of friction (unitless)
g = acceleration due to gravity (9.80 m/s2)

crossing.gif
 
but he gives me the one finger salute...This guy just walked and didn't give a fuck.

Toronto pedestrians are the worst in Ontario.

I have seen them...

* Cross at a light in a slow deliberate manner while gawking at you. Out side of the GTA most people put a bit of hustle in it and wave/smile.
* When jay-walking they will give you the one finger salute if they feel you are encroaching on their right of way (which they are clearly in the wrong). Out side of the GTA most people would hustle across or wave you through.
* Start to cross a 6 lane road when the stop crossing warning flashes red and then take their time getting to the other side.
* Not taking the time to either push the cross-walk button or make themselves visible in the dark or in bad weather conditions. It is like they think that cars can automatically detect them and they have some cloak of invincibility around them that will stop a two tonne vehicle from hurting them.

One other main challenge in the city is the TTC buses. So many people want to catch the bus they see coming and will risk their life to do so.

It is no surprise that there are numerous pedestrian fatalities in Toronto as some, and not all, are simply due to their attitude.
 
The right of way is not a suit of armour that will protect a pedestrian from coming to harm. Unfortunately most pedestrians believe that it is.

In JTKs case, if the pedestrian was struck, the accident investigator would take time of day and clothing into account, as it is pertinent to the investigation. It's a simple thing to figure out where each party was, pedestrian and vehicle, knowing approximate speeds, driving and walking. They can determine if there's fault to be found.
 
There is no law requiring you to use hand signals when crossing a road. It's a concept called gestures (?) originated by the Japanese (?) It is meant to co-ordinate body and mind. Look - point - act. It's proven to work well in Japan, but it doesn't fit the NA culture.

.



It might not be a law, however, it is posted at the buttons to hit the lights, to look and to point.



Lights = Nope

Look = Nope

Point = Nope

But despite all that I did manage to stop.

Took a closer look at the X'ing in question last night in the dark. Cars parked on either side of the road make seeing the pedestrian at the curbside impossible until you are almost adjacent to the curb where the pedestrian would be standing. I saw him when he was in the cross walk because that was the first moment I could see him. He basically emerged from behind a parked car without looking or without pointing, or most importantly, without hitting the lights.

I get that pedestrians have the right of way, but that doesn't mean that they shouldn't have to think about what they are doing. This was not a child, this was a middle aged man who should know enough to follow the rules.

It all could have been avoided if he simply pressed the button to actuate the lights.

I guess he thought that he was above such common folk nonsense.
 
Last edited:
I do appreciate in the OP that you admitted he was likely right. Your yelling at him was a typical reaction due to the adrenalin.

That and he gave me the finger for coming to a very abrupt stop so as to avoid running him over.
 
On lights, the law does not require them. Cities put them up to heighten pedestrian safety.

And from your description, you were not so close that it is impracticable to stop, you just weren't paying enough attention.

I didn't expect a pedestrian to cross without using the lights.

Not to use the lights is foolhardy.

They are put there to make the crossing safer. Use them.

Maybe it's time that pedestrians like drivers HAVE to follow some simple rules. Like pushing the button to actuate the lights. Seems to me that the rules are put in place to protect 5 year old who don't know better. But a 50 year old should know better.
 
This past 15 years I've watched things shift from bicycles simply needing reflectors on their pedals (a normal expectation), to having to have lights on them (front white and rear red), and now even some are lobbying for people to wear bright neon vests. If your contrast vision is THAT bad that you can't see a person floating 3 feet off the ground on a bicycle, you might need an optometrist and a bus pass.

Cyclists should be required to put lights on their bikes front and back just like cars by law under penalty of the law. Enough with the free pass in that. Cyclists (like many pedestrians) can utterly disregard every single rule of the road with impunity and get away with it. Enough already. But I digress.....

Marcuss Gee wrote an excellent article in the Globe and Mail back maybe 6 months ago about Toronto cyclists and their disdain of putting lights on their bikes. He's absolutely 100% correct.

It makes no sense to me whatsoever your argument that a driver or anyone else should be able to see a pedestrian in the dark with dark clothing on. No sense at all.

Take a look at any construction site. Day or night, they have to wear reflective safety vests. This is mandated by the Ontario Occupational Health and Safety Act. Working on the 401 behind concrete barriers (even) at night, they need vests, reflectors on their hard hats, reflectors on the cuffs of their pants. The reason is simple. High visibility. You want to be seen so as not to be injured. Humans are not cats.
 
Took a closer look at the X'ing in question last night in the dark. Cars parked on either side of the road make seeing the pedestrian at the curbside impossible until you are almost adjacent to the curb where the pedestrian would be standing. I saw him when he was in the cross walk because that was the first moment I could see him.

Its quite possible that:
a) he pointed before you saw him and before he started crossing
b) the crosswalk lights don't work
c) you have become conditioned, like many including myself, to not trust crosswalk lights anyways since it seems about 50% of the time I drive through one with lights blinking there is nobody crossing

Narrow street, parked cars on both sides, rainy, dark and poor visibility.
Why weren't you slowing down as you approached the crosswalk?

Crosswalk lights are great when they work and the pedestrian should have hit the button (assuming he didn't and they work).
I still remember taking driving lessons with Young Drivers of Canada, where they preached defensive driving, slowing down when visibility is bad and being cautious generally.
 
Its quite possible that:
a) he pointed before you saw him and before he started crossing
b) the crosswalk lights don't work
c) you have become conditioned, like many including myself, to not trust crosswalk lights anyways since it seems about 50% of the time I drive through one with lights blinking there is nobody crossing

Narrow street, parked cars on both sides, rainy, dark and poor visibility.
Why weren't you slowing down as you approached the crosswalk?

Crosswalk lights are great when they work and the pedestrian should have hit the button (assuming he didn't and they work).
I still remember taking driving lessons with Young Drivers of Canada, where they preached defensive driving, slowing down when visibility is bad and being cautious generally.

Sorry, you're wrong on all accounts.

I wasn't speeding and the lights work.

I was able to stop, though abruptly.

I am not conditioned like you not to trust cross walk lights. I think I've seen them flashing maybe once in my life when no-one is there and even then, probably someone was just there. Plus, if you see them come on, it's because someone pushed the button and even if there is no-one there, I would still think that someone IS there and DID push the button. Unlike you, my first thought is not (nay, never) that the lights "just came on". My thinking is always, someone pushed the button.
 
I didn't expect a pedestrian to cross without using the lights....

You should. As has been mentioned, a driver should always expect the unexpected.

Legally he is in the right. Yes, common sense says he should have made sure the light was activated but provincial law does not require it.
 
Cyclists should be required to put lights on their bikes front and back just like cars by law under penalty of the law. ...

They are. It's by-law, not a criminal offense though and is poorly enforced (like use of turn signals or rolling stops for cars).

Basically the rest of your post is just arguing for a different set of laws and does not change that the pedestrian in your case had legal right of way.
 
Cyclists should be required to put lights on their bikes front and back just like cars by law under penalty of the law. Enough with the free pass in that. Cyclists (like many pedestrians) can utterly disregard every single rule of the road with impunity and get away with it. Enough already. But I digress.....

Marcuss Gee wrote an excellent article in the Globe and Mail back maybe 6 months ago about Toronto cyclists and their disdain of putting lights on their bikes. He's absolutely 100% correct.

It makes no sense to me whatsoever your argument that a driver or anyone else should be able to see a pedestrian in the dark with dark clothing on. No sense at all.

Take a look at any construction site. Day or night, they have to wear reflective safety vests. This is mandated by the Ontario Occupational Health and Safety Act. Working on the 401 behind concrete barriers (even) at night, they need vests, reflectors on their hard hats, reflectors on the cuffs of their pants. The reason is simple. High visibility. You want to be seen so as not to be injured. Humans are not cats.
Yup. Just like cyclists and perdestrians, workers and their employers (who are responsible for ensuring safety) did little or nothing about making everyone really visible. Not until a law forced them to.
 
They are. It's by-law, not a criminal offense though and is poorly enforced (like use of turn signals or rolling stops for cars).

Basically the rest of your post is just arguing for a different set of laws and does not change that the pedestrian in your case had legal right of way.

I think you mean the Ontario Highway Traffic Act, not the Canadian Criminal Code.
 
Sorry, you're wrong on all accounts.

I wasn't speeding and the lights work.

I was able to stop, though abruptly.

I am not conditioned like you not to trust cross walk lights. I think I've seen them flashing maybe once in my life when no-one is there and even then, probably someone was just there. Plus, if you see them come on, it's because someone pushed the button and even if there is no-one there, I would still think that someone IS there and DID push the button. Unlike you, my first thought is not (nay, never) that the lights "just came on". My thinking is always, someone pushed the button.

I didn't say you were speeding, just that if its dark, raining and the sides are obstructed by parked cars the prudent thing would be to slow down, even if you're just driving the legal limit or under.
Excuse me for mentioning, but I think you used to post about living in Hamilton, is that correct? Don't know if the state of crosswalks are different there or in the burbs or wherever you drive or live now. I'm downtown and crosswalk lights here aren't dependable even when they are flashing. Downtown driving is always crazy, chances for actually speeding are rare and there are always enough 'surprises' on every street to slow you down. Bikes, pedestrians, kids, construction, cab drivers, electric bikes, tourists, anyone texting..... So maybe my experiences are coloured as there is hardly any roads where I think I won't get a surprise.
 
You should. As has been mentioned, a driver should always expect the unexpected.

Legally he is in the right. Yes, common sense says he should have made sure the light was activated but provincial law does not require it.

This works for a driver if he can see the person and can therefore expect that person to do something dumb and be prepared for such an occurrence. Tough to do when they are all but invisible.
 
I think we've beaten this one to death.

JFK accepts that ultimately the responsibility falls on him. I believe he's just trying to make the point that the pedestrian was an idiot and unnecessarily put himself in danger. I agree with JFK, although it's fun yanking his chain.

Too bad we can't legislate common sense. One day it might become necessary to issue a formal law requiring all pedestrians/bikers to wear reflective clothing at night and restrict them from entering a roadway if a car is approaching within 75m (assuming 50kh/hr). Hard to police, but with all the traffic cameras being rolled-out, maybe one day this will be enforceable. I'm also thinking that maybe in 5-10 years car black boxes that include cameras that the driver can't tamper with may be standard equipment.

In general pedestrians are pretty idiotic, especially in parking lots. Yorkdale can be downright scarey, you almost need a signalman to help you back out of a spot. Bell Canada during a summer job taught me to always back into parking spots and I've done that ever single. Much, much easier to pull out safely.
 
Hello James, in response to your counterpoints:
Cyclists should be required to put lights on their bikes front and back just like cars by law under penalty of the law. Enough with the free pass in that.
I DO have lights on the front and back of my bike, though, as per my original point, this is not an all-solving visibility panacea. I ride in the CITY, where there are street lamps everywhere lighting up the area (and ME). I don't go off-road often, but the few times I do, they front light does come in handy and I don't want to be stopped by cops, so I mounted them. Back in the day, reflectors had to be on the front of the bike (where the light is), the back of the bike under the seat (where the rear light IS), and on the pedals. Reflectors become illuminated when a headlight shines on them, and created visibility already. Worked for decades...
Cyclists (like many pedestrians) can utterly disregard every single rule of the road with impunity and get away with it. Enough already. But I digress.....
This sub-rant has nothing to do with what I'm talking about. Bad cyclists breaking the rules and endangering everyone (motorists, cyclists, pedestrians, etc.) has nothing to do with making them mount lights and people now pushing for reflective vests. All I'm trying to say is the vest is overkill. I simply wear LIGHT clothing. If a driver can't see my white t-shirt or canary yellow hoodie for warmth, he's got issues!
It makes no sense to me whatsoever your argument that a driver or anyone else should be able to see a pedestrian in the dark with dark clothing on. No sense at all.
I'm not advocating that people should dash across the road in dark clothing, but the claim "they're a ninja and materialized out of nowhere!" doesn't hold water with me. By this line of reasoning, do you also believe there shouldn't be dark car colors available either? Because not all of them out there have constant running lights and as I driver I've seen more than one vehicle on the 401 at dusk/evening without their lights yet on and thus being a black moving blob in one's vision, yet I'm still able to SEE them.
Take a look at any construction site. Day or night, they have to wear reflective safety vests[...] Working on the 401 behind concrete barriers (even) at night, they need vests, reflectors on their hard hats, reflectors on the cuffs of their pants. The reason is simple. High visibility. You want to be seen so as not to be injured. Humans are not cats.
I'm an engineer, I've seen plenty of construction/industrial sites as well as the OHSA. What you willingly seem to be obtuse about is that construction sites have vehicles with differing fields of vision. In the mining insustry there is a giant truck known as a Kress Hauler. The operator cab is like 10 feet off the ground and has a blind spot you could park a bus in. Naturally visibility is a major concern for heavy industrial equipment.
As for working on the 401, you're standing on the FREAKING HIGHWAY. Of course you need to be as visible as possible, and hence the reduced speed zones and "double fines when workers are present" signs. It's a very dangerous situation to be in... However I have yet to successfully get my bicycle on the 401 so I consider that a moot argument for why I should have to wear a Reflective vest. I simply don't dress in dark colors, that is more than enough common sense without the sissy nanny-state measures some are proposing. I take my personal safety in my own hands since I'm black and we learn from an early age that no one is going to give a shit running us over. I cross purposefully, I drive defensively, and I cycle the same. I don't follow every rule of the road (I practice the Idaho Stop), but I don't launch myself without regard into a busy intersection... If there's no cars, THEN I jay-walk, cross illegally, etc. No harm done.

Cheers and best wishes to you. Believe it or not, I think we both believe in sensible road conduct for ALL users. We just seem to slightly disagree over what that entails.