Toronto congestion

james t kirk said:
I have read all the "Toronto is poorly planned" posts.

The 401 is a masterpiece of Engineering.

Do you people have ANY clue of what you are talking about?

Exactly WHY do you feel that Toronto is poorly planned? Cities are not supposed to be built around the automobile. Our whole "Auto Centric" line of thinking has to end. Sooner or later something is going to give.


The 401 is a mess , the condition of the surface is appaling. Toronto is poorly planned because you ar esupposed to plan to deal with the situation you have . I agree with you we should have better public transit but for some reason the city doesn't feel this is a priority . It is poorly planned because planning has to allow for an expanding population you can't ignore it and no new roads have been built or new subway lines nor are they planned for in the near future . Toronto is quite simply a mess with no planning , something like the company I work for.
 
booboobear said:
The 401 is a mess , the condition of the surface is appaling. Toronto is poorly planned because you ar esupposed to plan to deal with the situation you have . I agree with you we should have better public transit but for some reason the city doesn't feel this is a priority . It is poorly planned because planning has to allow for an expanding population you can't ignore it and no new roads have been built or new subway lines nor are they planned for in the near future . Toronto is quite simply a mess with no planning , something like the company I work for.

The 401 has sections that are in poor condition, no doubt about. That has nothing to do with the design of the highway and everything to do with budgetary limitations. As highways go, it's first rate. Collector system, grade separations, exits on the right, 120 km/hr design speed, COMPASS system, 18 lanes wide, tall wall medians, high mast lighting. The only part of the highway that is under designed is the 400 interchange. That's a disaster.

The solution isn't catering to more suburbs and expanding population. The solution is densification, and this is something that Toronto has been actively working towards for 20 years.

Toronto as a city has its collective head up its ass at City Hall. There is no focus on priorities (at least as I see it). The homeless budget is something like 200 million bucks. The bridge budget is 55 million. Something is wrong with that picture.
 
James, it almost sounds like you work, or are involved with, the DOT?

As for the 401 being a master of engineering, well, maybe an old locomotive engineer but as for traffic engineering, it bites the big one.

You think the only problem area is the 400/401 interchange? the DVP/401 is a clusterfuck and to make matters worse, they keep changing it. I don't think, in the last 12 yrs, they haven't stopped working on that one.

If the 401 had the following, and fixed the choke points, THEN I'd say it is a master of engineering:
1) No entrances to the expresslanes within 5 kms of an onramp to the collectors (ok, so the collectors come to a complete stop all the time at kennedy/401 eastbound from all the yahoos trying to get across 3 lanes of traffic)
2) 6 lanes condensing down to 3 at kennedy, where the hell are the other 3 lanes supposed to go?
3) 401 westbound, vic park on ramp 500 yds to the DVP north on ramp. What fucking idiot thought up THIS brilliant plan: HEY I've got an idea, let's get 100 cars a minute trying to get onto the highway at the exact same point 100 cars a minute will be trying to get off the highway. A better idea yet is to put them ALL in the same 500 yds of pavement, ya, that'll work.
4) exressway westbound exit to the collectors. Oh another brilliant idea: let's make it so that we continuously have vehicles trying to get over 4 lanes within a 500 yd stretch...at the same point vehicles are trying to get out of the far right lane because it is now the off ramp to the 400 north.
5) ANother brilliant design: the avenue road onramp and the bathurst off ramp, not 500 yds apart, I bet they aren't 100 yds apart.
6) 401 westbound at islington. Oh brilliant idea: lets put open a stretch of highway 6 lanes wide, then take 4 of them away immediately! Positively BRILLLIANT idea.....
7) 401 eastbound exit to vic park north: Oh let's make an onramp that even a gallardo can't take at more than 20 kms per hour.....Then let's make sure the pavement is washboard so that if you even try to take it any faster you will bounce right off the pavement.
8) 401 eastbound ext to dvp south: who in their stupid mind thought that putting a major entrance to the main downtown route would be ideal if there was an exit 20 ft away? (the exit to york mills). To top it off, you've got 2 lanes exiting from the express and 2 lanes from the collectors ALL GOING DOWN TO ONE ENTRANCE LANE....

Good points:
1) Allen road north exit from the 401 west, in the LEFT LANE...now that was a good idea, (they had to because they already had an exit and an onramp within 100 yds) AND you can get to allen north via the expresslanes AND there is one lane for each, the express AND the collectors
2) 400 westbound and 427 south. HEY someone was actually thinking this time: let's give 2 full lanes to the exit PLUS a third lane that has a choice to stay on the highway or take the exit. (bad point was putting the dixon rd entrance so close to a major intersection).

There's probably a few other good ones but just can't think of any right now....