Tim Hortons Employee Fired

Bud Plug said:
She is 27 years old, has 4 kids and is a single mother. .. She thinks it's a good idea to feed donuts to an 11 month old child.
The main conclusion I drew from this story is this country sure as hell needs immigrants.
 
milhouse said:
Actually i would, not outright obviously but i would certainly be interested in talking to her, find exactly what qualifications she has or something.

What is it that you find so intriguing about her as a potential employee? I can't see anything in the story to her credit. Maybe you're just in Neil Young's camp when he says "Welfare mothers - make better lovers"!

milhouse said:
Yes being on welfare and esp. going to the press doesnt look good, but if you were in her position what other choice would you have when you need to pay the bills. She obviously had some bad luck or made some bad choices before but at least she's trying to change that, the legal way. And she should be pushed back a few steps in changing her life for that?

How exactly is going to the press connected to trying to turn her life around? Don't you think there's plenty of other donut shops in London (or similar employment) she could have gotten employment at as easily as pursuing a media story? (In case you're unsure, the answer is yes!) She brought the story to the media because she has a personality conflict with her former manager. She thought the story would embarass the manager and possibly net her a little cash in the process.

Sorry, but I'll take a pass on this sort of potential employee every time (and I am an employer).

milhouse said:
It states that her and the manager didnt get along in the first place, so he probably just took advantage of an opportunity he saw but backfired. Even TH said termination was not necessary and a mistake so how bad of a employee/person is she? At the most she should have just gotten a warning/written up, whatever their policy is.
Do you really think that she is the only 1 in the store that gives out free timbits to pets/child? How many others in that store have been fired or gotten a warning?

What a lot of people don't seem to know is that non-union employees may be let go at any time, for no reason at all, provided that you give the employee sufficient notice (or pay in lieu) and severance pay, and provided that you aren't violating the Human Rights Code (firing someone based on their race, etc). If the manager wanted rid of her, he didn't need an excuse. She'd only worked there for 3 years. She could have been turfed without a reason with a few weeks notice or pay (she wouldn't be entitled to severence). Managers don't "trump up cases" to get rid of employees who would be so easy to terminate without the need of building a case against them.

As to whether other employees are giving out Timbits, as far as we know she's the only one who got caught. (I have to say, as a dog owner, I don't think it's a good idea to give a donut to a dog. They'll eat it, but it isn't good for them. They have different digestive systems than humans do. It's particularly bad to give them anything with chocolate in it. Too many dog owners don't seem to realize this.)

Don't put too much stock in what the TH PR guy had to say about "overreaction" "termination not necessary". After all, that's PR spin, and not necessarily a statement about what they were entitled to do as an employer.

milhouse said:
Actions speak louder than words. Interview can tell you so much but you'll never know what they are really like while doing the job. Esp in the customer service field. I'm sure everyone has seen their share of bad services, whether thru phone or person.

Yes, you're right, actions speak louder than words. Look at her actions here! No interview could persuade me that she'd actually be a dedicated employee.

We've all experienced bad service because people like her are employable in the current economy due to a labour shortage in Canada.

milhouse said:
Would you think the manager would be a better applicant than her.

In a word, yes. While the manager might have lacked some sophistication, the story doesn't leave me questioning her respect for TH corporate values or the authority of supervision.
 
Bud Plug said:
No you wouldn't. If you were in a position to, you'd know better than to hire such a poisonous, know-it-all, welfare mother, whiner. If you didn't know better, you wouldn't be in a position to offer employment to anyone for very long.

No employer would want an employee like this if they could possibly find anyone better.


OH jesh, where is it that she did anything wrong except standing up for her rights? She is a single Mother who btw was WORKING. She gave a bit (ONE) to a child. She worked already for them for years, so obviously they had no problems with her before this. Anyone with a brain would hire someone like her for one simple fact. She is kind to the regulars and keeps them coming back. Nobody wants to do business with robotic type employees that do not care for the public. If they do they do not return because of the good customer service and the warm atmosphere it would be because it is all that is available in thier location. If there was alternatives people will go to the better atmosphere. This day and age you have to fight for your rights and at least now she is not doing away with any loss pay for her and her family. Who can blame her for fighting for that. If the boss is in the wrong nothing wrong with letting others know after all he could have harmed her and her family badly. What is good for the goose is good for the gander. The guy who hired her will more than likely benifit from those going to his location now to talk to her too wanting more news.
 
xitmnt said:
Tim Hortons just had a big convention . At the end of the convention , they had enough food left over (ie doughnuts breakfast sandwiches) too feed a small country .

Now instead of sending it too the staff cafeteria (which is normal) , or calling someone too give it too the less fortunate ,they tossed it all away .

Shows you the state of the world nowadays!


True story when I was working at Cross C. Donuts the owner of the one at Bristol, the first owner was willing to give to the food bank. They even approached and asked if she would and she had everything set up for them to pick up. They only showed twice. On the third day she was expecting them to show they did not so she called them and they said they would be back the next day again they never showed. Boy was she furious because here she had the kitchen near the back door all over crowded with the stuff, blocking the refridgerators and the back door. So, she calls them back tells them to be there the next day and if they don't show and are not reliable to get the stuff do not even bother wasting her time in showing after that. Again, they did not show. Sometimes it is lack of action on both parts.

But, at least with C.C. Donuts the employees at the end of the day who ever had the last shift was allowed to take home whatever they wanted when the trays were cleared away.
 
Jade4u said:
OH jesh, where is it that she did anything wrong except standing up for her rights? She is a single Mother who btw was WORKING. She gave a bit (ONE) to a child. She worked already for them for years, so obviously they had no problems with her before this. Anyone with a brain would hire someone like her for one simple fact. She is kind to the regulars and keeps them coming back. Nobody wants to do business with robotic type employees that do not care for the public. If they do they do not return because of the good customer service and the warm atmosphere it would be because it is all that is available in thier location. If there was alternatives people will go to the better atmosphere. This day and age you have to fight for your rights and at least now she is not doing away with any loss pay for her and her family. Who can blame her for fighting for that. If the boss is in the wrong nothing wrong with letting others know after all he could have harmed her and her family badly. What is good for the goose is good for the gander. The guy who hired her will more than likely benifit from those going to his location now to talk to her too wanting more news.

You'll feel differently, and see the facts differently, if you become an employer some day.

At the end of the day, this person sees her former manager as completely at fault and thinks she did nothing wrong. Not only did she exercise bad judgement, she hasn't learned anything at all from this experience (except that the media dislikes large corporate employers and will apply PR pressure against them). While you could characterize this learning as a type of "survival skill", it will not lead her to success in the world of employment. I think her behaviour should be discouraged. Not only does her behaviour make her a poor employee (from an employer's point of view), it's also an impediment to her own success.

I don't know if you heard the radio interview with this woman, but you could hear her attitude in her voice. I've known too many employees like this to view her as a "dedicated mother fighting to keep food on the table for her children".

p.s. I'll make a wager with you that she quits the new location soon, claiming that she's being discriminated against as a result of the media complaint!
 
Bud Plug said:
You'll feel differently, and see the facts differently, if you become an employer some day.

At the end of the day, this person sees her former manager as completely at fault and thinks she did nothing wrong. Not only did she exercise bad judgement, she hasn't learned anything at all from this experience (except that the media dislikes large corporate employers and will apply PR pressure against them). While you could characterize this learning as a type of "survival skill", it will not lead her to success in the world of employment. I think her behaviour should be discouraged. Not only does her behaviour make her a poor employee (from an employer's point of view), it's also an impediment to her own success.

I don't know if you heard the radio interview with this woman, but you could hear her attitude in her voice. I've known too many employees like this to view her as a "dedicated mother fighting to keep food on the table for her children".

p.s. I'll make a wager with you that she quits the new location soon, claiming that she's being discriminated against as a result of the media complaint!

No, I didn't hear the radio interview. I do agree that somone with attitude should not be dealing with the public. But, when I was at CC Donuts it was my job to look over the store at Erin Mills and the girls who worked there and any complaints it was my job to bring it to the attention of my boss (head office and owner) Let's say it was my judgement that was always the end result of someones getting fired and/or hired. I never did the hiring or firing myself but did look over the girls behaviours and did the training and would check up on them even when I was not working myself. (like a spy) Waiting down the hall in the mall where I was not seen but could see what was happening at the counter and then walking up ordering something for myself and then reporting. They would never know what would be about to hit them. I would then see something ask it to be done and leave. Owner or not I know appearance is everything from my own experience. Yes, I agree some girls are not the right image if she is not friendly then she should not be dealing with the public. But, I do not see how one bit should be the end of a job for her. Even me with my dealings with the girls if I seen something I would in a pleasant way ask for it to be changed or done. How you treat employees also reflects in thier eagerness to satisfy and will show through in thier service to the public. If they have to be told several times again and again then yes they should not be there. Thankfully my boss always came in with a smile on his face and always showed he cared for his girls.
 
Bud Plug said:
p.s. I'll make a wager with you that she quits the new location soon, claiming that she's being discriminated against as a result of the media complaint!

She already said to the media last week she can't continue working for Tim Horton's even though it's a different location. But she needs a cheque to feed her 4 kids. Wait and see.....