The Real David Miller.........exposed.

Quote from OldlJones
Absolutely as you say: Majority rules. Since a tie means no majority, the proposed measure fails to pass. End of story. What's the problem? Do get a copy of Roberts Rules at any library. Democratic bodies from the US Senate to the local Stamp club have run their proceedings by rules like those for hundreds of years. They're the rules that define "majority".


Umm... I don't have a copy of Robert's Rules here but doesn't the chair vote to break a tie -- not create one?
 
Tiger Williams said:
Here's the problem, OJ:

Previously we had a situation where 3 members of the Police Services Board wanted a new chief and 3 wanted Fantino.
Tie vote= motion defeated and Fantino loses his job.

Yesterday a motion was put forward to officially start the search for a new Police Chief. Guess what? Another tie vote. Motion is defeated.
So now we are getting rid of the old guy, but we can't look for the new guy?

Please tell me again what you like about this ridiculous method of deciding crucial issues in government?
(oh yeah.........and where do we go from here? I haven't picked up my copy of the 'Roberts Rules' as of yet.)
Hey Tiger: since you asked, this was 'your side' getting their way and stopping the search before it started. If every issue is to be fought to the last drop of blood like this, nothing will get done, and the levels of anger and animosity will become astronomical. No motion which divides the Board that way will pass. Stagnation. The Province steps in.

Personally, I'd have hoped one of them would have abstained, realizing no good could come from delaying the start of the search. We can only hope no more harm is done. Meantime Fantino still has a contracted departure date, so I really can't fathom their strategy.

But you are quite right, the whole thing is appalling.

Earlier you asked what I found factually wrong with Rosie's piece. The point I've tried to make over and over about the 'objections' is that the facts—which as stated are essentially true—simply don't support the venomously negative opinions she, and others have drawn from them. It's the everyday stuff of civic politics, and certainly merits no more condemnation than was heaped on ,say our last Mayor who ran for office with nary a mention of his plan/need to spend every other fortnight in Florida.

As to where we go from here: the calendar will still bring forward term ends and replacements for the various Board members and the Chief (who certainly doesn't deserve all this junk swirling around his quite ordinary action, any more than the Mayor deserves it for his) so one day all this posturing will be behind us. Who will have gained anything? No one I can see, except the new hire on College St—and maybe us, if she's a good Chief.

One could hope someone will wake up realizing that in democracy it is the minority's consent to majority rule that keeps things functioning peacefully* and the guns outta the streets.

Otherwise we can only hope someone with a gift for brokering compromise gets busy behind the scenes since the on-stage guys have retreated behind their barricades. A Mayor who had stayed off the Board might be a perfect candidate (a non-trivial reason for doing so) but one might almost suspect some folks saw the possibility coming asnd set out to make sure that was impossible

See how silly that sort of attributed motivation sounds if you don't share it—just wanted to give you a taste.

Sorry about the harshness of "put up etc"; I just got tired of asking, "yes, agreed, but what's wrong with the facts as stated?", I shouldn't have let myself be seduced by the phrase's pithyness. Nevertheless, I note above; you still seem to think the facts prove some self-evident fault, that can only be disproved by disputing them, and I say yet again, (and to Rosie by extension) the facts look fine to me, tell me what is wrong.

And if all you come up with is: "It's a @#$%^& mess, let's go for a beer. I'm with you"