We have had this discussion before on TERB. It is basically a Blue Water v a Brown Water view of the world. Interestingly when the claim was British, before it was transferred to Canada (and there is an entire discussion there as to whether such a transfer was/is possible) being a major naval power the British perspective was "Blue Water" i.e. that the straits were international straits save for those (under current law) 24 nautical miles or less across. Canada most definitely being a minor naval power takes a "Brown Water" approach, that the entire Arctic Archipelago are internal waters even when a strait is say 100 nautical miles wide.I think the real question is "what part of the Arctic will be ours?" The americans will show their true colours (colors) when they impose their distorted logic to why it is all theirs. I still own a 1960's globe manufactured in Ohio which shows the Arctic as part of Canada.
Should this not be obvious from the above, the U.S.A. is not the only state to have a “Blue Water” perspective on the Northwest Passage, so do the U.K., France and Russia among others.

