The invisible hand at work

nobody123

serial onanist
Feb 1, 2012
3,557
5
38
nowhere
Wow! The private sector really is more efficient! Edward Snowden and Aaron Alexis (the Navy Yard shooter) would probably never have gotten their security clearance if lumbering old bureaucrats had handled the paperwork. Fortunately, the company that handles such things since the late 90s is focused on efficiently processing as many clearances as it can flush through its system, oversight and thoroughness be damned. Free market efficiency, is there anything it can't do?


The calls and e-mails from top executives came toward the end of each month, former managers at USIS recalled. The company needed to swiftly complete investigating security clearances for the government in order to reach its monthly revenue goal, the managers said they were told. Finally, there was an order: “Flush” everything you’ve got.

The directive to give quick final approval of background investigations without reviewing them for quality — known as flushing — was sent, the managers said, to a branch office of USIS, a company that has performed 700,000 yearly security checks for the government. Among the individuals the company vetted were Edward J. Snowden, the National Security Agency leaker, and Aaron Alexis, who the police say shot and killed 12 people at the Washington Navy Yard last week.

... To speed investigations, the federal personnel office hired private companies like USIS to do the majority of the work, which significantly eased the backlog.

But since questions about the security clearances for Mr. Snowden and Mr. Alexis came to light, some in Congress are asking if speeding up cases led to unintended consequences: investigators prone to cut corners and, in extreme cases, to falsify reports.

“My confidence in the system has been shaken by those two cases,” said Senator Susan Collins, Republican of Maine, who introduced a bill that first mandated deadlines for investigations in 2004. “There was a lot of pressure to get rid of the backlog. What O.P.M. did to cut the backlog is it contracted about half of the background checks it’s responsible for doing. It seems to me that there are quality questions about the work done by the contractors.”

http://www.nytimes.com/2013/09/28/u...-and-aaron-alexis.html?hp&pagewanted=all&_r=0
 
Somehow I don't believe Adam Smith was arguing for contractors performing essential government functions.

Nor that the way to reduce backlogs in the granting or denying of clearances was to do slapdash investigations.
 
Somehow I don't believe Adam Smith was arguing for contractors performing essential government functions.

Nor that the way to reduce backlogs in the granting or denying of clearances was to do slapdash investigations.
Setting aside the relevance of some historical dude with a frilly shirt and long hair coming up with something that was a seemingly good idea at the time and the silliness of applying it unthinkingly to contemporary circumstances (why hello, founding fathers and the 2nd amendment!)....

I am genuinely curious as to how the "small government" fetishists care to respond to this article. Maybe if there was just some oversight, right? OF course, a rational small government would have to outsource that oversight, but nothing could go wrong there, could it.
 
I am genuinely curious as to how "small government" [proponents] respond to this article.
First, one presumes that conducting national security background investigations is an essential government function (at least I do). Second, there was a very good article about this I read the other day, now I have to see if I can find it again.
 
And did you hear that the Federal Government has gotten rid of the division of the CRA
that investigates tax fraud from organized crime (Special Enforcement Program) is being eliminated to save money?
So underworld figures and those really rich guys who hide their money in the Turks and Caicos and Switzerland must be sipping the champagne now.

They'll continue to nail the little guys though.

Really?
Hadn't head that one, though I wonder if its related to the $400k check to the Montreal Mafia dude who owed $1.5 million.
Is this just a plan to liberate some conservative supporters?
 
And did you hear that the Federal Government has gotten rid of the division of the CRA
that investigates tax fraud from organized crime (Special Enforcement Program) is being eliminated to save money?
So underworld figures and those really rich guys who hide their money in the Turks and Caicos and Switzerland must be sipping the champagne now.

They'll continue to nail the little guys though.
Was this before or after Revenue Canada awarded a huge tax return to whatsisname - the Montreal mobster who is in prison for all sorts of massive tax fraud and whatnot?
 
Nice review.
Love the glory hole concept.
The fantasy is enhanced even further if its anonymous, if one is up to it.
 
The invisible hand of the market is a metaphor conceived by Adam Smith, interpreted by some, to describe the self-regulating behavior of the marketplace creating a common good of all.

However, there is little support in what Smith actually wrote that can substantiate the interpretation it has been given.
 
And did you hear that the Federal Government has gotten rid of the division of the CRA
that investigates tax fraud from organized crime (Special Enforcement Program) is being eliminated to save money?
So underworld figures and those really rich guys who hide their money in the Turks and Caicos and Switzerland must be sipping the champagne now.

They'll continue to nail the little guys though.

There will always be some one else who will take up the slack at the CRA or the RCMP for this work. Rest assured.
 
The invisible hand of the market is a metaphor conceived by Adam Smith, interpreted by some, to describe the self-regulating behavior of the marketplace creating a common good of all.

However, there is little support in what Smith actually wrote that can substantiate the interpretation it has been given.
Constantly forgotten and overlooked is Adam Smith's underlying premise, that all this 'free market' stuff will be happening in a well-regulated society.
 
Constantly forgotten and overlooked is Adam Smith's underlying premise, that all this 'free market' stuff will be happening in a well-regulated society.
I like what one of the saner economists once said (Krugman? Stieglitz? one of those two I think): "The reason it's called an invisible hand is that it isn't even there". I'm sure I butchered the quote and the attribution, but ya gets the ideer.
 
Setting aside the relevance of some historical dude with a frilly shirt and long hair coming up with something that was a seemingly good idea at the time and the silliness of applying it unthinkingly to contemporary circumstances (why hello, founding fathers and the 2nd amendment!)....

I am genuinely curious as to how the "small government" fetishists care to respond to this article. Maybe if there was just some oversight, right? OF course, a rational small government would have to outsource that oversight, but nothing could go wrong there, could it.

Right, because its better to call the police after you have been a victim of crime than to protect yourself from the crime in the first place.
 
Right, because its better to call the police after you have been a victim of crime than to protect yourself from the crime in the first place.
Ah. So some of them will respond by latching their little gopher brains onto some throwaway line and not even noting what the actual thread is about. Shirley there are some who are able to follow a train of thought without going all Lac Migantic on us though. And to those I re-pose the question: how do you respond to the article?
 
Wow! The private sector really is more efficient! . . . Free market efficiency, is there anything it can't do?

Answer - No. Provided, of course, that the free market is backed by strong government, to keep it free.

Some things government does best, some things a free market does best. When things are bought and sold for money, the free market keeps the market supplied, maximizing product quality while minimizing product prices. As Adam Smith suggested, the free market does this by harnessing the greed of the participants in the market.

The government's job is to prevent the free market from being distorted by those who seek to carve it up for or between themselves. There is no end to the number of people whose aim is to monopolize the market, and no end to their ingenuity and ambition.

The task of preserving the free market cannot be done by the free market. That task must be performed by government. The government must see to it that the law is exactly the same for everyone. The role of government is to regulate the market, to provide and enforce safety standards and professional qualifications. To ensure that investments and savings cannot be hijacked. That contracts are enforced by law. Also, top provide an independent and non-corrupt police. Also independent courts whose rulings are respected and enforced.

As it has turned out, free-market democracy, and its associated independent institutions, is the most stable and self-sustaining form of government. Get down on your knees and give thanks (to whoever you give thanks to) for this miracle.

And while you're down there, pray that no-one takes any notice of these dangerous wankers who actually think the government should be in the market as participants.
 
Answer - No. Provided, of course, that the free market is backed by strong government, to keep it free.

Some things government does best, some things a free market does best. When things are bought and sold for money, the free market keeps the market supplied, maximizing product quality while minimizing product prices. As Adam Smith suggested, the free market does this by harnessing the greed of the participants in the market.

The government's job is to prevent the free market from being distorted by those who seek to carve it up for or between themselves. There is no end to the number of people whose aim is to monopolize the market, and no end to their ingenuity and ambition.

The task of preserving the free market cannot be done by the free market. That task must be performed by government. The government must see to it that the law is exactly the same for everyone. The role of government is to regulate the market, to provide and enforce safety standards and professional qualifications. To ensure that investments and savings cannot be hijacked. That contracts are enforced by law. Also, top provide an independent and non-corrupt police. Also independent courts whose rulings are respected and enforced.

As it has turned out, free-market democracy, and its associated independent institutions, is the most stable and self-sustaining form of government. Get down on your knees and give thanks (to whoever you give thanks to) for this miracle.

And while you're down there, pray that no-one takes any notice of these dangerous wankers who actually think the government should be in the market as participants.
So you are saying (in a very roundabout, paean to the glorious free market way) that there are things the free market CANNOT do better than the government? And that the market should stick to goods and services bought and sold and NOT take over huge swaths of what the gov't does. I see. Thanks.


...Blasphemer!
 
Last edited:
So you are saying (in a very roundabout, paean to the glorious free market way) that there are things the free market CANNOT do better than the government?
Gee I thought those few things the government should be going are known as core or essential government functions.
 
Okay was I the only one who read the title of this thread and immediately thought I was going to be reading a story about how someone found a magical invisible hand at work? Kinda like "The Thing" from The Adam's Family? Lol, I'm going back to bed, I need more sleep. But this thread was very interesting too.

images
 
Okay was I the only one who read the title of this thread and immediately thought I was going to be reading a story about how someone found a magical invisible hand at work? Kinda like "The Thing" from The Adam's Family?

y e s
 
Gee I thought those few things the government should be going are known as core or essential government functions.
And now we get to the crux of things, in a very roundabout way. Back to the article, even. What falls under said core services? I would think vetting people is a core service, personally. Same with pretty much every aspect of the security industry. But I'm a rabid pinko, and I am sure the free marketeers would disagree with me. Hell, the U.S. administration disagrees with me and contracts it all out already (with shitty resluts, mind you). So, let's hear it. How can the free market "fix" the problems in the article?
 
Gee I thought those few things the government should be going are known as core or essential government functions.
But let's leave out the preconception in the word 'few' and keep an open mind. After all, there are just one thing the 'free' market (as if such a thing had ever existed or could) does: provide a means for individuals to exchange things between each other for their mutual benefit.

Of course they cannot do any such thing outside a well-ordered society—which is the business of government—which among other things must establish and maintain standards of weights and measure, honest disclosure, proper warranty, contract fulfillment and fair dealing, as well as policing and defending the society from more violent forms of unfair dealing both internal and external.

Once you have that social mechanism of government then it's a perpetual open question how few or how many things it should do, and there isn't anyone in that market who doesn't use whatever influence they can to make government work to their advantage in that marketplace. No one whose government ever recognized slavery—pretty much every government in the history of mankind to date—should ever be imagining there is any such thing as a free market. No one looking at the lawless state of the free and unregulated market in illegal drugs should ever imagine that a truly free market is a good thing.

Let the greed-driven look out for themselves; they always have and always will. The proper business of people intelligently concerned with existing together is not self-aggrandizement but social improvement. Making that well-ordered society. With a a world population increasing exponentially on a single limited planet, we have no other choice if we want to survive.

Unless we choose to kill as many as we can to seize as much as we can for our own profit. And then set up just a few rules to run the little enclave we and our buddies must defend against the world we pillaged, and then maybe figure out buying is less dangerous, and then promise to behave and make others behave too, and then …

Economics is not life. That's why it's just the science of the marketplace and neither a philosophy, a moral system nor a political theory. First we need a well-ordered society, then we can indulge the luxury of economics.