The French Peril

onthebottom said:
The interesting question is France acting the way it is via Iraq becasue it's the right thing to do, they want to take the US down a peg or two or protecting their economic interestes with Iraq.
I would imagine that it's a bit of all three.

Many in France probably do believe that it's the right thing to do. As the answer to this question is very subjective, we can't be sure if France's position is the right way to go but most of us believe we know what's right, even though each of us has a different idea of what that is.

Nations are always trying to get advantages on each other. France has a chance to be in a stronger position if war is averted and they were one of the first countries to champion that side.

Finally, every nation that is involved in this whole Iraq situation is looking out for their economic interest. That includes Canada and the US as well; of course that is part of what motivates France.

Zog.
 
Last edited:
bigdik said:
Anyone remember who sent them back?

Please don't tell me you think it was the Yanks? It sure is easy to sit there and wait till the enemy is nearly vanquished and then rush in to "save the day". How convienient. While the old world powers are beating each others brains out and crippling their economies, you sit on the sidelines until 1943 and and build up your strength. How nice to reap the benefits of procrastination and become a super power while . Man I hate that "How America won the world wars" crap.

And how bout post WW2 as lesson on trusting American leaders. Though to be fair this applies to Chruchill too. The Yanks and Churchill were quite content to sell out the Baltic Countries and half of Poland to the Soviets. I wonder how much they will care about the Iraqis and Afganis in 5 years time?
 
France - All countries factor in their self interest. France lacks ethics when it comes to supplying arms etc to many regimes and is notorious for stabbing friends (do they have any?) in the back. Remember de Gaulles "Viva Quebec Libre". Remember their refusal to allow use of their air space to the US to go after Gadhafi. They don't like anyone and maybe not even themselves. Arrogance must be a French word.

US - Say what you want but they are the most benevolent Super Power in recorded history. Britain was close towards the end of their Empire but remember - they built a Empire, the US never did! Yes they have made a few mistakes but who hasn't. We are very lucky to have them as a friend and neighbor.

V12
 
V12

V12


Thank you for the kind words and perspcetive.
 
What do you call 10 000 frenchmen with their arms in the air...

The French Army

Thanks..I'm here all night. (with apologies to Q107)

But seriously - France, Germany, et. all are just looking out for their own interests. They don't want the U.S. to gain control of Iraqi oil. The oil in the northern part and the Black sea area are the only major untapped sources left. U.S. wants to control the region for that. They then build a pipline from the black sea to the Indian Ocean. But they need to go through some other countries...hmmm, Afghanistan if I'm correct. Upon further research, President Karzai, Bush and Dick Cheney have all sat on the board of directors of a certain big oil company. Coincidence...?
 
Much better than the toast!

WhOiSyOdAdDy? said:
Just remember if it were not for the french the world would not have everyday items...
How about lingerie and French Kissing? I wish those were everyday items!

Zog.
 
Don't forget many words we use today

According to Dictioanary.com the word surrender is taken from old french.

Middle English surrenderen, from Old French surrendre : sur-, sur- + rendre, to deliver; see render.]
 
Hey, I found The Simpsons' "Cheese eating surrender monkeys" thing just as funny as the next guy, but the whole, "France WWII" theme is getting tired awfully fast.

Does anyone keep harping on the fact that the Americans got their asses handed to them by a bunch of starving Vietnemese with antiquated guns and pitchforks?

Perhaps the current bitterness towards the French, (who I agree are hard to beat for cynicism), comes from the realization that they've handed the Americans their asses AGAIN in the diplomatic game on the issue of Iraq.

France wants to step up and be recognized as the defacto leader of Europe, (they're counting on the embarrassment of recent German history to keep that country in check). The U.S. is Europe's only serious rival, so anything they can do to embarrass and take the U.S. down a peg, they'll do.

For those of you who think France is shy about using force, witness their recent little trip down to Africa. They could care less what the world thinks or says about their actions.
 
Are we LOOKING for someone to bash??

Lots of English words come from French...so what?

Zog.
 
Wow!!!

Is collaboration a blanket bad thing now? Is it wrong for the US to seek allies to "collaborate" with them in their war with Iraq? Were the Allies wrong to collaborate in the war against the Axis?

I agree that the US bashing threads are getting out of hand but I'm not convinced that France-bashing is the way to correct that.

Are we really that narrow minded?

I think this has gone far past the funny stage.

Zog.
 
Enough already!

How about a thread that bashes people that make racist generalizations.

I realise that you are all free to be as offensive as you want but I, for one, am getting tired of the abusive (for no reason) posts.

In answer to several PMs, NO, I'm not French, I just have an aversion to racist biggoted crap.

Zog.
 
You got me!

OUCH!!!


Don't pull so hard!

Zog.
 
Remo said:
Please don't tell me you think it was the Yanks? It sure is easy to sit there and wait till the enemy is nearly vanquished and then rush in to "save the day". While the old world powers are beating each others brains out, you sit on the sidelines until 1943 and and build up your strength. How nice to reap the benefits of procrastination and become a super power while . Man I hate that "How America won the world wars" crap.
Remo, with all due respect: I wonder if the American veterans who landed in Normandy would feel the same way? And no, the enemy was not 'nearly vanquished' as you say - that enemy was still very much in control of a large piece of Europe at that time.

How can anyone feel that that war would have had the same outcome, had it not been for US involvement?
 
WW II

OK Guys!

Are we going tio pretend we don't get it.

Of course the Americans made a valuable contribution to the Allied cause in WWII. They certainly did not win the war all by themselves but they shortened it significantly by adding their resources to the fight.

At the same time, the US did wait quite some time before they became involved. As a result of this wait, the war lasted longer than it would have had to and many more sodiers lost their lives because the conflict was extended.

I realize that the US had complex reasons for staying out of WWII but the American members reading these threads need to remember that, by waiting, the US invited resentment from those that were fighting beginning in 1945.

Canadians: let's not pretend that the US was insignificant in WWII.

Americans: don't pretend that your army single-handedly stopped Hitler.

Now, can we talk about the present?

Zog.