I've always liked Springbank, Oban and Lagavulin. Lately, I've been into the Caol Ila, and I find I like the 12 year old better than the 18, altough some of the cask strength stuff is a good wake-me-up now and again.
The best scotch I ever had was the 30 year old Ballantines. It was so smooth, almost sweet like a liqueur. I like to try different ones so i don't have a favourite. I am not a fan of JW but I do like the green label. I had the blue a few times, was not impressed especially for the money. To be honest, i prefer the green to the blue and it's alot cheaper. The Ballantines was impressive though.
I think variety is key like anything else. You tend to get sick of drinking the same thing and need a change.
Scotch-Bowmore 12yo(having a wee dram right now) and Old Pulteney
Bourbon-Evan Williams Single Barrel Vintage and Woodforde Reserve
Irish-Michael Collins and Green Spot
Canadian-Glen Breton Reserve and Alberta Premium
Japan-haven't tried any yet, but meaning to try Yoichi 10yo
Tennessee-George Dickel #12
Very likely, but not necessarily in my budget, even if I could find it(must look at Century next time I'm there). Besides, I have more than enough unexplored possibilities in the $35-55 range to concern myself too much with ultra-premiums.
Cheers!