Toronto Passions

Tech Startup Is Helping the Cops Track Sex Workers Online

No, not in Canada but of course down here in the U.S. where $millions of funding is going to get rid of all sexwork and all the new laws with increased funding for LE for enforcement from the "rescue" industry. Every sexworker needs rescuing since had to be abuse victims or trafficked per the abolistists.

Tech Startup Is Helping the Cops Track Sex Workers Online
April 17, 2015 by Melissa Gira Grant highlights

"Big data" and "sex trafficking." That it took so long for someone to combine these buzz terms into one money-making venture is just one of several mysteries surrounding Rescue Forensics, a new startup.

The "big" in the Memphis-based company? Rescue Forensics claims it "archives massive quantities of data from classified advertisement sites specializing in commercial sex ads." It gathers a lot of text, and even more nude and semi-nude photos. Then it turns all that over to the cops.

What Rescue Forensics appears to be selling is just one more tool to help cops track people engaged in sex work through their online activities.

Rescue Forensics purports to have brought on more than 100 law enforcement agencies, including the FBI.

There's a good chance that if you've placed an ad online in the last two years for escorting, massage, BDSM, stripping, private modeling, nude housekeeping, Rescue Forensics has a copy. And because Rescue Forensics has a copy, so do their users in law enforcement.

The tools the company says they provide to police sound pretty powerful: Apparently, through image matching, they can connect photos from deleted classified ads they've archived with existing social media profiles. The only search tool Dalton would tell me about in real detail was something they've built to clean up some of the data, like phone numbers, which advertisers are usually prohibited from typing out in an ad (and so might have obscured with extra characters or spaces). Rescue Forensics' users in law enforcement can more easily search for text that advertisers took steps to conceal.

But for Dalton (co-founder), the fight against trafficking isn't just about finding the people Rescue Forensics believes are "exploited": It's about abolition.

Before he co-founded Rescue Forensics, Dalton was a policy advisor to Shared Hope International, a faith-based anti-prostitution organization involved in "rescuing and restoring" people it describes as trafficked. The group claims that demand for commercial sex drives demand for trafficking and argues that websites like Backpage are facilitators of trafficking. They are currently lobbying Congress to redefine men who buy sex as "traffickers." They also organize a men's group called the Defenders, who pledge not to consume porn or any other form of commercial sex.

In their campaign "Demand Justice," Shared Hope makes the claim that "sex trafficking will end only when men stop buying sex." Last August, Dalton authored the campaign's launch announcement, inviting Shared Hope's supporters to become "an ally in the effort to eradicate the market force that fuels sex trafficking and victimizes the vulnerable."

Of sex work generally, Dalton told me, "I know there are people who choose to do that, but I'm not talking about those people... but there's a subset of those ads for people who do not choose that lifestyle."

To date, Dalton told me his company has collected "18 million records" from over 800 cities—a great number of them ads presumably posted by people who are not trafficking victims.

Scraping websites primarily used by sex workers can have even more serious consequences for the people who advertise there. "The ability to advertise online provides a level of safety for many," D'Adamo told me, "but does come with the very real fear of exposure and leaving behind a footprint." Despite Rescue Forensics claim to focus on those who are "exploited," their product runs on sex workers' ads. "Compiling all of this information and making it easily searchable will only exacerbate these fears," D'Adamo added.

Though he insisted to me multiple times that he does believe there's a difference between sex work and trafficking, Dalton still stands to profit from a product that can't make that distinction, placed in the hands of law enforcement officers who also routinely fail to make it. Police use every weapon at their disposal to harass and arrest sex workers, and Rescue Forensics can't guarantee it won't end up being one more.

If the so-called abolitionist movement is where Dalton's coming from—a movement that believes demand for the sex trade is responsible for trafficking, and therefore seeks to abolish the sex trade—you start to get a sense of why he might not be "clear."

Dave notes this could really help Arizona LE go after the new escort license law where your license has to be on your ad. Scottsdale seems to be enforcing the most so far. I have yet to see an ad that complies with the new law. I do not know nor have heard of any escort that has the required license which has to be carried on the sex worker, logging requirements of all activities (no sex) and log of all the clients with positive ID.

Or, of course if bad words like GFE or worse are used, its an automatic easy solicitation arrest without having to even set up a appointment, just get the records of who placed the ad advertising GFE or any sex act abbreviations or slang.

https://www.vice.com/read/this-tech-startup-is-helping-the-cops-track-sex-workers-online-417
 
Doesn't this goes against the US constitution of invasian of privacy?
The argument is that since ads, etc. were posted in public on a website that there is no privacy. There still is a Court case pending filed by Craiglist related to them being forced to remove their adult section that argues misuse for purposes not intended by CL. There is also an issue that usually to find out info on an ad (who paid for it) LE needs to subpoena the host, CL or BP, or wherever the ad is. I have seen hundrends of pages provide to LE in Phoenix by BP in one case after such a subpoena.

Rescue Forensics tells LE they can save all the paperwork by just buying their data.

A major problem down here in the U.S. is almost no one takes a case to trial but is threated with long prison terms (often lied to about why they are guilty) if they don't take a plea.

Websites probably do not have an interest on this issue to try for a declaratory judgement and may not have standing. If a companion is arrested based on info obtained this way without a subpeana she might challnage it - if she has $100k to afford the legal costs. Unlike in Canada we do not have any well organized advocates for sexworkers. Probably because it has always been illegal here vs mostly legal for all private sexwork (at least outcall) in Canada before C-36. Therefore, it seems Canadians sex workers were more free to organize than in the U.S,.
 

dirkd101

Well-known member
Sep 29, 2005
10,329
93
48
eastern frontier
This is Big Brother in action.

It was of course, only a matter of time that the tool used to ply their trade was used to thwart said trade.

There are some in the trade that are unwilling participants and do need to be rescued. But, there are some who are there by choice. If the government and LE really want to help, then why don't they have a special team that tracks the girls and creates a data base. This would be a cross jurisdictional team federally run. With some surveillance and over several interviews and surprise visits they could determine those that are being slaved in the trade and then they can rescue them and haul the bad guys/gals who run these girls into the clink.

Instead they want to create a nanny state, controlling everyone within it. Stopping of course anything that they deem against their moral code. Doing nothing to help the true victims, but spending large amounts of money and creating a whole new bureaucracy to stop this.

BTW, what ever happened to the separation of Church and State?
 

Frankfooter

dangling member
Apr 10, 2015
87,552
20,390
113
I would have thought that the wholesale copying of the ads amounted to copyright infringement.
It would only be copyright infringement if they were trying to make money from the ads.

Goodbye backpage in the US.
How will sp's advertise now down there?
Back to the street?

Yikes.
 
The copyright issue is interesting. Don't think it would qualify under the fair use exemption (giving credit and just excerpts). It is for profit since LE pays for the data base.

For Dirkd101 response:
The trafficking excuse includes all sex work with probably 90% of arrest consenting adults. A boyfriend that drives an escort or phone person is a pimp and trafficker automatically, no bad intent. Trafficking is deceit used to go after mostly consenting adults.

At least in Toronto, Vancouver and some major cities police are only enforcing if abuse or underaged is involved. However, it seems Calgary and some others are using it to go after all sexwork. Montreal it seems just if abusive or underaged.

With CP36 is probably easy to avoid just like in the U.S. where smart folks don't use any sex terms in ads or communications and pay for time only not sex. At least in the U.S. usually as in AZ there has to be a specific offer of sex for a "fee arrangement'. Has to be explicit but LE good at getting workers to say the wrong thing on calls, texts or e-mails.

The biggest issue in AZ is all escorts have to have a license on them, numbers in all ads (like in I forget what Canadian city) but also open for inspection during business hours and keep detailed log of activities (not sexual) and positive ID log of every customer. I have yet to see an ad that complies or anyone getting the required escort license. Scottsdale is especially aggressive in no license arrests which is criminal not just civil.

The current declaratory lawsuit in CA challenging the prostitution law is partly based on Lawrence v Texas where the Supreme Court (US) ruled laws can not be based on morality and in the case of gay sex the State has no business in private bedrooms. Many think this can be applied to consenting adult prostitution. However, it will be a long battle eventually probably winding up at our 9th Circuit appeals level (which AZ and most of the West U.S is in). The compliant is done by very good attorneys and the best I've ever read on the constitutional challenge to consenting adult prostitution laws in the U.S.

At least in Canada it is about harm reduction. This is the opposite of in the U.S. where its about saving all sexworkers since they all have been abused or trafficked or have to end demand for all prostitution to go after the rare case of forced sexwork. As in Canada, there are real cases. But in the U.S. the arrests and everyone is a victim industry is dominant.

The Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms is also much stronger on individual rights than the U.S. Constitution.

The U.S. argument to uphold prostitution laws is that the State has a compelling interest to protect women from being victims of prostitution (all are considered since the argument is no sane women would abuse herself by being a prostitute. All must have low self-esteem, have been sexually abused as a child, etc.

I like the idea of:
Happy Hookers of Canada
"A true voice of the proud sex workers across Canada."
In Canada, there are many well organized private sexwork groups
http://www.happyhookersofcanada.com

On separation of Church and State
The Federal Religious Freedom Act does not apply regarding State criminal laws. Most States have similar acts. In order for a State to criminalize a religious act, the State must have a "compelling interest" and be the "least reasonable means" (this is AZ but similar in most States). The state will argue it has a compelling interest since prostitution often involves children (rare), brings in other crimes and gangs and pimps that force women into prostitution).

American Indians have won in order to use Peyote in ceremonies.

Huge case I am following and attend the Court hearings on since the SWAT team raid 3+ years ago is the Phoenix Goddess Temple. 36 were indicted and threatened with 40 years in prison by mere association with a "criminal enterprise" related charges. Tantra is part of their religious beliefs. There is no evidence of any "fee arrangement" for sex. The case now on the 4th judge. Trial maybe late 2015 or 2015 (military assault type raid was in 2012 on the Temple's Church in Phoenix). Many lives ruined unable to get jobs with felony charges hanging, some lose their massage licenses (LMT's in U.S. like RMT's in Canada), etc. I am now on update #160 on my reporting from Court, etc. to defendants, many in the Tantra community nationally, lawyers, etc.

Yes, the conservatives and religious groups are powerful in most States, and there are $millions of funding to the abolition groups that want to eliminate all sexwork. The end-demand movement is also very strong as in Canada with the new C36. Major funding by the Hunt sisters (as in oil money), Disney and many others.
 

oldjones

CanBarelyRe Member
Aug 18, 2001
24,490
11
38
It would only be copyright infringement if they were trying to make money from the ads.

Goodbye backpage in the US.
How will sp's advertise now down there?
Back to the street?

Yikes.
Making copies can be considered fair use, and that has to get argued and decided in court. If a doctor photo-copies pages from a medical journal and the charges for the treatment he learned from the article, which he stuck on the tackboard in his office he's making money from the copies, isn't he?

The data folks are charging for their collecting, sorting and evaluating; if that's copyright infringement, so's half the internet.
 

onthebottom

Never Been Justly Banned
Jan 10, 2002
40,556
23
38
Hooterville
www.scubadiving.com
There is a fundamental shift in data analytics with "big data" and social monitoring. Organizations (companies, governments) can easily combine what they know about you (accounts, transactions, tax filings) with what you do publicly (ads, face book posts, TERB profile) to get a more complete view.

Banks have all deployed big data "lakes" on Hadoop to better understand you and predict your behavior.
 

corrie fan

Well-known member
Nov 13, 2014
934
359
63
The company, Rescue Forensics is making money from prostitution. They are selling information about the sex industry. If they someday operate in Canada could they be charged under C-36 with receiving material benefit from the prostitution of others?
 
Ashley Madison
Toronto Escorts