james t kirk said:Well yes and no.
I will agree with you that Susur has a high opinion of himself. He has has bragged in the Canadian media something to the effect of, "Do you know how much money I could make in New York"
He was also hauled up before the Ontario Labour Board for example for abusing his employees.
http://www.thestar.com/News/GTA/article/256999
(That said, my employer does pay me, however, they work the SHIT out of us, and bullshit is part of the work a day world.)
The format was a tasting menu. He comes up with things you'd never think of or try in a million years. And it works and it doesn't. For me, when I was there, it definitely worked.
As to his cooking, you're right, he doesn't get his hands dirty so to speak. But he does come up with the IDEAS. He's the guy who creates the food. He is an artist in the true definition of the word.
You don't think that Eiffel was out there hammering rivets into the tower do you?
Or Henry Ford was working on the assembly line, or Frank Lloyd Wright was out there shingling a roof do you?
Susur is a genius to cooking as Wright was to architecture. He is an artist, the only difference is that he uses food in his creations. (Now that said, in my world, no chef comes close to a guy like Frank Lloyd Wright, but the principle is the same.)
I do really like Susur's food....however a restaurant should be about the food, the service and whether the business values the customer. My last visit left me with the impression, that the cusotmer's needs were secondary to the menu. Having only one tasting menu with x number of courses versus the previous tasting menus where you could order x + 1 dish or x - 1 dish leaves me unimpressed from a customer service perspective. Not having the option of ordering a la Carte is also reinforcing this impression.
As to your analogy of Eiffel, Wright or Ford, I respectfully disagree with your choice. I would rather compare this to ....let's see..... Monet providing a student with an idea for a painting and having the student then paint it - after which Monet puts his name to it and it is then sells it as a "Monet". Once again from a customer's perspective I find this unacceptable.
I do wish him well in New York, but his attitude, and, dare I say, his work ethic has to change.

