SPERM Donation ..... LOL Hmmmm........ Would YOU do it.........

That's correct. The law does not care about the how, it only cares if you are the biological father.

In some situations, even non-biological fathers have been assigned the responsibility of child support. Those situations are rare but have occurred when children have bonded to an adult male in their life. Think a guy dating a single mom and decides to unofficially play a fatherly role during the relationship.

I believe the legal concept for this is called "in loco parentis". However, IANAL. Perhaps one of our resident lawyers can explain.

Ok, I found a resolved case that occurred in Canada and in loco parentis was used in the ruling.

http://www.canada.com/reginaleaderpost/story.html?id=c9204fcd-2867-43d8-a8c6-cd453c89fa9d&k=64293
 
http://www.rhrealitycheck.org/blog/...es-anonymity-gamete-donors-unconstitutional-0

A British Columbia judge has ruled that anonymity for gamete donors in the Canadian province is unconstitutional. The ruling referred to sections of the B.C. Adoption Act and Adoption Regulations that provide adopted children – but not donor offspring – the right to information about their biological parents. The judge also issued an injunction to prevent any donor records from being destroyed. Olivia Pratten, a Toronto journalist conceived using an anonymous sperm donor, brought the claim to B.C. courts, arguing that the law is discriminatory because it does not give donor children the ability to identify their biological parents.

I know I won't be donating sperm anytime soon.
 
IIRC, the biological maker of a baby is ALWAYS responsible for child support. You CANNOT contract out of it. You can always be sued and the judge will always make you pay.

The "gun seller" analogy that was used earlier in the thread is not appropriate. This is family law, not tort law.

If another guy raises the kid, he is indeed in loco parentis and can be made to pay part of the child support. But the biological daddy is always responsible for paying the rest.

The only exception is if the baby IS FORMALLY, LEGALLY ADOPTED WITH A COURT ORDER BY THE NEW DADDY. This takes the biological daddy off the hook.
 
IIRC, the biological maker of a baby is ALWAYS responsible for child support. You CANNOT contract out of it. You can always be sued and the judge will always make you pay.

The "gun seller" analogy that was used earlier in the thread is not appropriate. This is family law, not tort law.

If another guy raises the kid, he is indeed in loco parentis and can be made to pay part of the child support. But the biological daddy is always responsible for paying the rest.

The only exception is if the baby IS FORMALLY, LEGALLY ADOPTED WITH A COURT ORDER BY THE NEW DADDY. This takes the biological daddy off the hook.

Thanks for clarifying, oagre.

I have a question for you. Let's say I were to provide an anonymous donation of sperm at a sperm bank in Ontario. A woman takes my sperm, gets pregnant with it and during the course of the child's life is unable to meet financial obligations.

What is my legal liability in this situation?

Thank you.
 
Sorry ButterCup, but as djk points out and I quote a Toronto Law Firm here.
".... Dealing with matters relating to your children... A contract cannot deal with custody of, support for, and access to children."

You will end up paying in the end if she or the child comes after you.

To answer your question djk... this is why sperm banks "try" to keep files anonymous; but a DNA test and or court order; your life is screwed.

Here one for you, a man in NY (Whilst young and single) was making deposits to a Sperm bank for cash. Several years later, he finishes his education, gets married and has two beautiful girls; at the age of 45 he is promoted to VP Sales for the company that he has been working at for over 10 years. All is perfect.

Then, he receives a letter from a law firm identifying him as a father to a 10 year old boy in upper state; His wife freaks out because she believes he had an affair, it took him months to convince her, but he saved his marriage; because as the case developed, it was discovered that the child was from the Sperm Bank donation;
Now the long and short of it was; He ended up paying $2,000/yr for Child support, and giving the female sperm recipient $50,000; and he two girls have a younger brother. He sued the Sperm Bank - it went bankrupt - and so goes the legal system.

Oh, as an FYI - I have first hand knowledge of this.... happen to a friend of my family -

So boys, keep track of you swimmers, they can come back to haunt you later in life - Just my opinion here, but if your married, get a "V". lol
 
Sorry ButterCup, but as djk points out and I quote a Toronto Law Firm here.
".... Dealing with matters relating to your children... A contract cannot deal with custody of, support for, and access to children."
You will end up paying in the end if she or the child comes after you.

What I was suggesting was a personal contract under which the lady agreed to indemnify the gentleman for whatever costs were ordered against him. Of course, any agreement between them, under which she gives up the child's right to be supported by the gentleman cannot be enforced when it's against the interests of the child.

I explained that, if the lady was serious about letting the guy off the hook as much as poss, she (or they) might set up a trust, from which child support could be paid to the father; that would assure the father that, even if she should change her mind about not wanting him to provide support, any money he is then forced to pay will be reimbursed by the trust.

Of course, if there is no trust, or if it's not for a large enough amount, he will then have to pay whatever she can get the court to order him to pay.

I also mentioned that such a contract, if made after the child was conceived, might be unenforceable for lack of consideration. So - sign before shag!

Finally, if you're contemplating doing this, don't bother to consult your lawyer - that would be so silly.
 
I'm looking forward to the future thread.

About 9 months from now, where cdnbigpp is posting with his tail between his legs, freaking out because the MPA is demanding child support.
 
Thanks for clarifying, oagre.

I have a question for you. Let's say I were to provide an anonymous donation of sperm at a sperm bank in Ontario. A woman takes my sperm, gets pregnant with it and during the course of the child's life is unable to meet financial obligations.

What is my legal liability in this situation?

Thank you.

don't worry ! My father has 500 biological children due to donating sperm. The oldest are around 28 and youngest around 13 years old.so far, no one has come calling yet! Though he even if some of the mothers did, my father has no money for child support and depends on me to help pay the rent.
 
Just to clarify ..... LOLOL

I would not be a donor --- I was just in the discussion with her about it and wanted to share ......

I am not that stupid LOL

don't worry ! My father has 500 biological children due to donating sperm. The oldest are around 28 and youngest around 13 years old.so far, no one has come calling yet! Though he even if some of the mothers did, my father has no money for child support and depends on me to help pay the rent.