Smart Cars!!!!!!!!!!!!

Smart Car Safety rating is a SHAM

Safety ratings (specifically for front and side impacts) for cars are determined with tests with a VEHICLE OF SIMILAR SIZE !!!!. For a Smart Car this essentially means ANOTHER SMART CAR, as there really are no other cars in its class. There is no published safety ratings for crashes with NORMAL vehicles. So as long as everybody else is driving one of these things - you are completly safe.

I have heard of (but not seen firsthand) of a front impact test (by the media I believe - some type of "investigative report) that was performed with a large sedan (Mercedes actually). Apparently the Mercedes passed with flying colors, but the Smart Card became airborn and rolled multiple times and KERPLAT - no more Smart Car.


END TRANSMISSON
 
Everytime I see one of these things I just can't help but think of this!

golf%20cart.gif
 
SilentLeviathan said:
That's not really the point. A lot of vehicles are unabashedly about image. The Smart car has the pretense of being a fuel efficient urban transporter. However, there are much more practical vehicles out there that will do the same job and more.

I can see their purpose in Europe where there are taxes and restrictions on vehicle size. But in North America they really aren't practical. The people who buy them are buying them more for image than anything. That's fine, I just think it's silly to try and justify it otherwise.

Again apples and oranges. Nothing like crashing a Smart car against on one the most solid cars ever design and think too bad the Smart car is so unsafe.

When gas is $4/litre, we won't be looking at it the same way. No it's not a great highway car but that's not why it's being sold. i'll bet the Yaris is no picnic either.

For $14,000 to start and approx. 75 kpg, it can't be beat.
 
blackrock13 said:
Who are THEY and how did they distort the test? Back up your statement.

Look how low the concrete barrier is. Nothings being said about a rear-end collision. :rolleyes:

It's a dinky toy....and that's coming from someone who drives a Civic.
 
The Bandit said:
Look how low the concrete barrier is. Nothings being said about a rear-end collision. :rolleyes:

It's a dinky toy....and that's coming from someone who drives a Civic.

They weren't trying to show a rear end collision. that;s also why they didn't show side impact and collision damage cause by a falling aircraft. It was just A test.

The barrier is just a standard highway barrier, I'm guessing Germany. but don't quote me. Still solid and still heavy. It didn't need to be 6 ft high for the same effect.

i love to see the Civic after a similar crash.
 
blackrock13 said:
They weren't trying to show a rear end collision. that;s also why they didn't show side impact and collision damage cause by a falling aircraft. It was just A test.

The barrier is just a standard highway barrier, I'm guessing Germany. but don't quote me. Still solid and still heavy. It didn't need to be 6 ft high for the same effect.

i love to see the Civic after a similar crash.

Actually the test was done by 5th Gear, a UK motoring show
 
blackrock13 said:
i love to see the Civic after a similar crash.

I was t-boned in my previous Civic (spun me around 180 degrees), the door and the crumple zone between the seats took the brunt of it. When I went to the wreckers to collect some belongings after it was written off, they couldn't believe I walked away with not even a scratch.
 
The Bandit said:
I was t-boned in my previous Civic (spun me around 180 degrees), the door and the crumple zone between the seats took the brunt of it. When I went to the wreckers to collect some belongings after it was written off, they couldn't believe I walked away with not even a scratch.

So people do survive crashes in sub compacts.
 
Last edited:
blackrock13 said:
Again, I say show me another micro car that would do better. To make those kind of scenario claims are really meaningless as it's too speculative.

Would a Versa do any better?

Would the driver survive if hit hit head on by a Hummer H3. dump truck, transport, or do a face plant of the Scarborough bluffs? The list continues. The answer is no.

Who are THEY and how did they distort the test? Back up your statement.

I didn't say that any other micro-car would do better, presumably, being built by Mercedes, the Smart is the state of the art in micro car safety. My point was the opposite, that all micro-cars are intrinsically less safe, because they weigh less.

It actually makes a big difference, my example was a little skewed, because it supposed that F150 hitting a Smart, where the Smart was hitting an F150. A more reasonable comparison would be each hitting a 3,200 pound regular car. If each were going 80kph and they hit head on, and momentum were perfectly transferred, the Smart would end up going 27 kph backwards, so its speed change is 107 kph. Where if a 6,400 pound truck hits the 3,200 pound car, the truck is going 27kph forward, a speed change of only 53 kph.

The speed change, along with the size of the crumple zone, are what determines the g force on the occupant. So in my example, even if the crumple zone was the same, the Smart driver gets twice the gs. Assuming the crumple zone in the Smart is half the size, he gets four times the g force, which is why it is so much worse for him.

All that the engineering can do is make sure that the crumpling is very linear, and that the force is applied evenly on his body, but that can not come close to making up four times the g force.

The way that the US Transportation Safety Commission skew the tests, is that they switched the testing, so that instead of running into walls, which would be based on the interior design, and the length of the crumple zone, they use based on a standard g force, so that it is only based on interior design. They did that in response to political pressure, because if it were more realistic, and took crumple zone size, and vehicle weight into account, it would reveal micro-cars as death traps. But the government want people to drive them, to reduce gas consumption. They should be testing based on a standard weight sled collision, as that is most realistic, but nobody would like the results.

If anyone has any fatality per mile statistics to post here, by model of car, that might shed more light on the subject.
 
Very impressive figures CDick, but the reality is, your F150 is like a mosquito on the highway compared to an 80-100 ton 18 wheeler. our highways are congested with massive disproportionate vehicles. The world is changing and smaller lighter vehicles are a natural evolution in reducing energy costs. Arguing that small light cars have no place on our roads is not very realistic. Perhaps the F150 is the pending dinosaur.
 
Had a chance to drive a fully tricked out F150 for a couple of days as a rental. Basically a very tall luxury car. No wonder they are approximately tha same price as cars now when years ago they were half the price, when they had half the stuff. I wonder how much of it is that size/compensation thing again.

One thing I did notice with the Smart car, it 'really' stops on a dime, maneuvers almost s fast as you think about turning, but has absolutely no acceleration. One owner told me that was the hardest thing to remember when negotiating traffic lights and intersections.

It will be interesting to watch if some of the smaller delivery vehicles from other countries make their way to NA and how long it will take.
 
HafDun said:
Very impressive figures CDick, but the reality is, your F150 is like a mosquito on the highway compared to an 80-100 ton 18 wheeler. our highways are congested with massive disproportionate vehicles. The world is changing and smaller lighter vehicles are a natural evolution in reducing energy costs. Arguing that small light cars have no place on our roads is not very realistic. Perhaps the F150 is the pending dinosaur.

I didn't say they had no place on the roads, I said they were death-traps, relatively speaking. I would not put my family in one, but I support your right to put yours in one.

Even against a highway truck, or bridge, the bigger vehicle is better because of the longer crumple zone, it just loses the momemtum transfer advantage.

As for the future, the way I look at it, is that even if everyone drove a fossil-fuel burning micro-car, the world would still end due to global warming, because there is so much of the world that do not yet have cars, that want them. I think that the only long-term solution is to have vehicles that store energy that is generated cleanly. For example, battery vehicles, with the electricity made by solar, wind, nuclear, but not fuel burning. And once you have that, you can drive big vehicles again, because they are just as zero emmission. So I think that the real trend will be towards technology: cleaner power production and storage. I believe that the micro trend is just a panic induced fad, that we should really be focusing on technology, not shrinking. So I expect that I will be driving an F150 in twenty years, not a Smart, but my F150 will have 1,000 pounds of batteries, that I charge with my windmill.
 
A lot of these posts really show that many people really are missing the point of the Smart.

Its a city car.... Its not designed for long highway journeys, I speak from experience... I have driven one several hundred miles on UK highways, and it wasnt fun.... BUT at the final destination (Central London) I couldnt have asked for a better car for driving in a busy city, finding somewhere to park etc etc.

My friend in the UK had one, he bought in brand new for GBP8,000. Used it as his commuter ride for 3 years (Had a nice BMW for other use), put about 45,000 miles on it and sold it for GBP5,500... Find any other vehicle that doesnt depreciate like that.
 
SilentLeviathan said:
I think a TDI Jetta or Golf will deliver just as good fuel economy while being a lot more practical. Even a Honda Fit or Toyota Yaris would deliver similar fuel economy and be a lot more practical. Smart cars seem to be more about image than anything.

I'll second that. My trusty 99 Civic Si got rear-ended by a Chev Cavalier early this year. Ins company wrote it off but the resale value was excellent so I got $7900 - not too shabby for a 10 year old economy car. I'm not sure about the Smart's resale but I doubt it would be any better than Honda's.

We also have a Matrix 4wd so the Civic was a 2nd car for around town. So I test drove a Yaris & Fit. The Yaris was really sluggish & boring and the instrument panel is in the middle of the dash which I didn't like. The Fit LX 5 spd was very responsive and agile - really fun to drive. So I stuck with Honda and bought the Fit. It got good crash test results so it should be at least as safe as a Smart. The new Fit LX weighs 2500 lb which is the same as my 99 Civic and probably a lot of small cars these days (the new Corolla is almost a mid-sized car and it only weighs 2800 lb). I'm not saying I'd do very well head on against a Navigator but I'm probably a lot safer than I was with my old Civic. Interestingly, the new Fit LX 5 spd, fully equipped, cost almost exactly the same as my 99 Civic Si similarly equipped. The only difference is the new Fit has no sunroof available but it was standard on the Si. Even so, costs have obviously been going nowhere in this segment but safety has improved dramatically.
 
At 6' 4", the Smart is the only subcompact that I can fit in and drive comfortably. All the others are mini versions of larger cars. The Smart is a two seater and the cab is designed to comfortably seat two large adults. No rear seat, not a family car. Anyone who compares a Smart to a Yaris or a four seater subcompact, really doesn't get the Smart concept.

I have driven my Smart all over Ontario. It is definitely a city commuters dream, but it works just fine on the highway. It has its limitations, but I have yet to find the perfect vehicle. The vast majority of vehicles on the road today have empty back seats and probably little of importance in the trunk? Why do you need a 4 1/2 ton SUV to navigate the paved roads of Central Ontario averaging <20MPG?

And we are a long way from developing batteries that will effectively power a vehicle the size and weight of an F150.
The concept is a bit of an oxymoron. I agree with CDick that we need to develop alternatively powered vehicles but part of the equation is too build smaller lighter vehicles, not fantasize about sustainable power sources to maintain our gluttony for over sized overweight vehicles.