Sign The Decriminalization Petition

JoyfulC said:
Be as insulted as you'd like
heh, permission appreciated

-- however, that won't stop innocent women from being murdered by predators. It has nothing to do with the law.
So how do you explain the increase in murders since 213 was implemented in Canada, and the rates on violence and murder drastically decreasing since decrim was implement in NS Wales? Must be a coincidence.

If that's what you believe, fine.

However, I believe that sex workers tend to be murdered for a couple of reasons:

1) because predators believe that we're "disposable" -- that no one will give a shit if we're murdered; and

Agreed. And the laws most definitely reflect that. Sex workers on the most part are criminals, and subhuman.

2) because sex workers too often allow customers to be anonymous, "no questions asked," which offers predators the opportunity to evade the consequences of their actions.

I don't know about you, but I will not see someone unless I verify his identity first. Yep, I lose some business over this -- but I also have essentially a zero rate of problems.


I will agree with this as well, and no, the laws won't change this. Educating sex workers about safer business practice will change that.


I think you are looking at them, but I don't think you're looking at the broader context. It's not just about how it affects you, but how it affects communities, the vulnerable among us and -- yes -- even other business operators -- that counts. You need to take a broader, less subjective view.
Granted this is a very involved topic for myself, but I am mindful of steering clear of totalitarianism. I think that everyone's pov needs to be taken into consideration, and I also genuinely feel that decrim works best for all parties.
..c..[/QUOTE]
 
laurelg@maggies said:
Decent working conditions or deplorable ones...hmmmm....

I guess the thing that alarms me right now are some of MP Mac Harb's notions about "licensed brothels." They look like a good opportunity for quasi-organized crime -- but not good for the women who are currently working independently in Canada.

Well seeing as how they don't 'zone' brothels in NS Wales, and numerous independent sex workers work out of their own incalls, it can be done.

That's interesting.

Do they zone other adult entertainment operations, such as massage parlours and strip clubs?

I assume that municipalities would deal with brothels by zoning here because that's how they deal with other licensed adult operations.

In a legalized system where they have licensed brothel owners, it is a monopoly, so there is no chance for independent sex workers anyways.

Yep, and that's what they're talking about here. It would plunge our industry back decades of progress.

It's funny how in NS Wales where the brothels are not licensed any differently then any other business, that they go to the point of have co-op brothels, and non-profits. And hey, the indies seem to do just fine.

I'm not sure that's the paradigm that they would adopt here in Canada, though, based on the discussions that I've been following.

Hey, it would be terrific if they just said, "everybody go do what you want! It's all legal!!!" But I don't think that's going to happen here.

Already I think we're enjoying the best possible situation: already, even though we're technically illegal, we are tolerated unless we generate complaints. And at the same time, we don't have to adhere to any scheme of licensing or regulation.

That just makes me feel all warm and fuzzy.

I've got to find something to make me feel that way yet tonight! ;-)

And for those like me who are most definitely not being exploited can't say much if and when our loved ones are classified as pimps.

But you could! You could challenge the law. And I believe you'd be successful and the law would be struck.

That's why they're never going to charge your loved one (or mine!) as a pimp.

The courts know the law is overly broad and could easily be challenged. A similar example is the public communication law -- back in the late 80s/early 90s, NOW Magazine in Toronto was charged under these laws for carrying extremely explicit prostitution advertising. Technically, the case had merit -- NOW was a free A&E magazine, available on street corners, in diners, etc. and carried obvious solicitation for prostitution. BUT the courts did not want to set a precedent of having a print ad classified as "communication in a public place for the purposes of prostitution." Ultimately, the case was dropped.

We need to trust the powers that be a bit more. They know that our business exists and isn't going away. They also know that the stricter they are with us, the more problems our business generates. And they ALSO know that this is an individual rights issue: individuals should have the right to be or to use the services of an adult prostitute. And so they maintain a balance in the law that, on one hand, allows us the freedoms we all currently enjoy, while at the same time, giving the law the teeth to deal with true problems.

There are anomalies: the agency busts being the main one I see. And that's where we should be focusing our attention. Not tilting at windmills.

There are a various laws in place (I would assume it would be different in each locale) that deal with rowdy and bothersome neighbours.

The bawdy house laws are a lot quicker, though -- from the day charges are laid, I believe they can shut the operation right down.

Ya, and the saddest thing is that they have closed her case, along with Lien Pham's.

That is sad.

But it's also a wake-up call for all escorts to 1) verify their clients; and 2) work with other escorts to ensure that someone always knows where you are and who you're with.

Perhaps this might not have saved their lives (although it might have) -- but at least it would have given the police something more to go on in solving their murders. When escorts accept "anonymous" clients, who knows when they might become "anonymous" killers?

verify, Verify, VERIFY!

..c..
 
lol, I must thank you for the debate. It's been awhile since someone has sparked my interest on this level. A few posts later, and the poor old eyes hurt, so alas, I must turn in for the night. I look forward to picking up where I left off soon.

Cheers ;)
 
laurelg@maggies said:
heh, permission appreciated

I aim to please! ;-)

So how do you explain the increase in murders since 213 was implemented in Canada, and the rates on violence and murder drastically decreasing since decrim was implement in NS Wales? Must be a coincidence.

There might be a lot of reasons for it. I'm not sure at this time, but I find it hard to believe that a change in the law is the primary reason.

Agreed. And the laws most definitely reflect that. Sex workers on the most part are criminals, and subhuman.

I don't see that reflected anywhere in our laws! On the contrary, I view prostitution laws in the Criminal Code of Canada as being focused on protecting communities from prostitution-related problems and protecting individuals (for the most part prostitutes!) from exploitation by third parties. I feel that our current laws are extremely respectful of individual rights and choices, and seek to protect us.

I'm not sure why you see it differently.

And with respect to society, again, I don't see it. I do believe that sexual predators feel this way, but in Canadian society, I've been very open about my choice to be a sex worker, and have found mostly acceptance.

I will agree with this as well, and no, the laws won't change this. Educating sex workers about safer business practice will change that.

Yes!

Granted this is a very involved topic for myself, but I am mindful of steering clear of totalitarianism. I think that everyone's pov needs to be taken into consideration, and I also genuinely feel that decrim works best for all parties.

My big concern with decriminalization is that it opens the door for provinces and municipalities to come up with their own laws. Under the federal criminal code, I feel we stand a better chance of having our rights and freedoms respected. I look at some of the problems that strip clubs and massage parlours have been through with municipalities over the years, and I shudder to think we'd have to deal with the same.

Street prostitution, though, is another matter. I know I'll get blasted for saying this, but it is a serious problem for communities. It isn't about sex work or gender politics -- if you had dentists dragging their chairs out on street corners, hawking their services to passers-by and tossing their used, contaminated supplies and utensils on the street, I think we'd have laws about public dentristy solicitation too.

That said, I don't think street prostitution will ever go away -- only that I dread the idea of them making laws that affect the overwhelming majority of sex workers and customers who are NOT street participants with a new set of laws, surplanting our already excellent and humane laws.

..c..
 
Some of us here are incorrectly assuming that there is only two possible outcomes that could result from this process:

1) Nothing, or
2) Some type of decriminalization.

I'd like to remind everyone of a third possible outcome: a total prohibition on paying for sex, as was enacted in Sweden a few years ago. This is not good for anyone except those who don't care how dangerous it makes the sex trade as long it's out of sight so they can pretend it's been abolished.
http://www.petraostergren.com/english/studier.magister.asp

http://www.bayswan.org/swed/rosswed.html

This is exactly what the religious zealots and anti-sex trade feminists want, and some of them have already been telling the committee what an amazing success it's been. Let's hope someone tells them it isn't true.

And it would be much more difficult for our elected officials to back decriminalization than it would be for them to naively vote for prohibition, because its backers proclaim prohibition to be pro-feminist, pro-family values, pro-law and order, and against the "evils" of the sex trade.

Art Hanger is one of the five MPs on the committee. From link:
...Conservative MP Art Hanger, a former Calgary detective, is very much on the side of prohibition...
 
Last edited:
You make a good point, Heywood -- especially in this political climate. I think many of us have assumed that total prohibition would be too much of a swing from what we've had over the past couple decades.

But when you look at some of the politics going on around the world, it's not all that unreasonable.

Still, somehow I'd personally feel more comfortable with total prohibition on a federal criminal code level than some of the forms that "decriminalization" or regulation might take. Having worked in the States for a decade before I came to Canada (where most laws are State based), I never found it all that difficult to work around the code. The rule seems to be that, the higher the level of law, the more reasonable it is and the easier it is to work around. Municipal laws would still be the absolute worst in my estimation.

Look at those cities in Canada where escorts are licensed under bylaws (Calgary, Edmonton, Windsor, et al). Totally screwed up.

We probably enjoy our best outcome when prostitution-related problems (and let's face it: they exist) are dealt with on a federal criminal code level.

..c..