serious thread: Han Solo vs Captain Kirk

who would win in a fist fight?

  • Han Solo

    Votes: 14 31.8%
  • Captain Kirk

    Votes: 25 56.8%
  • neither, they would make sweet love under the stars

    Votes: 5 11.4%

  • Total voters
    44
  • Poll closed .
First things first, let's deal with the 800lb elephant in the room: the "Star Trek Must Lose" rule. Whatever validity that rule might normally have, it means nothing today. Today we are talking about Jim Kirk, and that means that faster than you can say "Kobayashi Maru" the rules are going to change. For once we will have a match that will be settled on the actual merits of the combatants involved, and that of course means that Kirk will fustigate Solo.

Let's just compare resumes here. Kirk routinely defeats gods, thumped the Klingon Empire so badly that a hundred years later it's being all but run by a bald Frenchman, and has scored with more women than Hugh Hefner and Wilt Chamberlain combined. By contrast, the toughest opponent Solo has ever defeated have been stormtroopers, he managed to get himself captured in every movie (including one memorable incident where he was captured by Ewoks and another where he had to be rescued by the same), and needed three movies to score with a single woman when the only competition for her was her brother.

And what experience does Solo have that will help him in a barroom brawl? His only notable hand to hand win was against Boba Fett and came about due to a one in a million lucky accident. Kirk whupped Khan, mano a mano, an opponent with five times his strength. He survived a Klingon prison (and learned how to fight dirty in the process). And perhaps most important, Kirk knows how to fashion makeshift weapons from whatever's handy, and this time he's not limited to just sulfur and diamonds. With the full contents of a bar to play with, Kirk should be able to bring a virtual napalm strike down on Solo.

There was a time when Solo would have known what to do when challenged to a fight. He would have just pulled out his blaster and shot Kirk. But that was a long time ago. Now we have the Special Edition Solo, the Solo that lets Greedo take the first shot, the Solo that has been Lucasfied. But it's not all bad for Solo. At least he'll be safely in intensive care by the time Kirk decides to start up with the karaoke.
 
Not only could Kirk kick ass but he was also powerful public speaker. He could open up a can of whoop-ass then give a very moving speech about the meaning of justice. Hell even Public Enemy referenced him.



But seriously...What did happen to William Shatner? Of all the products he coulda endorsed why All Bran? Why the commercials about how All Bran makes you take a good dump? Why I gotta see Shatner on the can? Why the dancing All Bran figures? Why is his face on the bloody All Bran Box? I mean to Trekkies he was a God and now his career is in the (literally) toilet. Hell man he coulda done life insurance like Ed Asner.

He coulda done Viagra:

Shatner as Cpt. Kirk: Y'know as a young Startfleet Cpt. I've bedded down chicks from here to Qo'noS. But as I've gotten older I've found it difficult to maintain my intergalactic playboy lifestyle. Tha's why I use Viagra. Now whenever that blue chick comes a callin I'm ready for some of that all night lovin.