Sea Shepherd conservation group declared 'pirates'

The post that you quoted was an illustration of what is termed "cutting sarcasm". It pointed out the weakness (see third sentence in said post) of using terms like "magical creatures" in a grown up discussion of a moderately serious topic.

No, no. You misunderstand. When I do it, it's cutting sarcasm. When anyone else does it, they're being way to literal.
 
What is more "magical" about a whale than a pig, a cow, or a goat?

I can understand and respect conservation of a endangered species. But not all whale species are endangered. Specifically, the common minke whale is labeled "Least Concern". There is no logical reason, other than maybe the chance of mistakenly capturing endangered species, to not whale common minkes.

And common minkes constitute the vast bulk of Japanese "reasearch" whaling.



You base your argument on ecology and protection of a non-endangered species.

That is silly.



It is legal. The Japanese are exploiting a legal loophole to do so, but by definition that is legal.

Do you eat sushi? Two out of the three major bluefin tuna species (you know, sushi tuna) are more endangered than minke whales. Why would you have a problem with the eating of whales but not with the eating of tuna?

For that matter, why do people have a problem with the Japanese eating dolphins? Bottlenose dolphins (the species the Japanese eat) are far from endangered. What, because they're smart? A dolphin can't do anything (adjusted for aquatic v. terrestrial environments, of course) that a pig can't do. And pigs are delicious. Go ahead and try to take my bacon away from me, silly boy.

Every argument for the non-havesting of non-endangered species is an emotionally-based, I-didn't-actually-think-about-it-I'm-just-reacting-because-I'm-an-illogical-child argument. Go ahead and let the Japanese eat minke whales.

Personally, I'm not touching them, but that is my choice. I'm not touching dolphin and very rarely eating tuna as well, but that's my choice. The heavy metal issues with the much deeper aquatic food pyramid tells me to stay away from seafood except as an occasional treat.


What is more magical? They are very few of them. If the Japanese find a way to farm whales then no problem. But many species are endangered and the ones that are not immediately at risk are not exactly plentiful.
 
What is more magical? They are very few of them. If the Japanese find a way to farm whales then no problem. But many species are endangered and the ones that are not immediately at risk are not exactly plentiful.

Again, minke and humpback whales are considered "Least Concern." It's worth paying attention to their numbers and any quotas for their whaling would have to be set quite low, as these things go, but there are plenty of fish species that are under much greater threat and pressure than minke and humpback whales, and nobody gives a crap about them. Again, two out of the three major bluefin tuna species are under major pressure. How many of you have had bluefin tuna sushi in the last month?

White sturgeon is Least Endangered. How many of you Canadians fish? The American Alligator is Least Endangered. I've had alligator in the last year.

What is magical about a species that is Least Endangered, that we can get everyone to agree to a very low harvesting quota for, and that if we get this agreement we could probably get the Japanese to stop whaling for fin whales, who truly are endangered but the Japanese whale 50 of every year. Why? Because they're not allowed to whale for more than ~800 minke and ~50 humpback whales a year. Meanwhile, your very opposition to allowing whaling means the Japanese will continue to kill 50 of the truly endangered, nearly extinct fin whales every year.

Your very emotions are causing an outcome that you are against. That's called counter-productive silliness. Correct it, please.
 
Evidently because it has been defined as too far outside the norms set by Yeahx3, JTK and others.

Which is what I'm pointing out. That's all. A small, monitored harvesting of whale species that are not endangered will relieve the pressure that legitimately endangered whale species are feeling. Instead, people think prohibition will work.

No, no. You misunderstand. When I do it, it's cutting sarcasm. When anyone else does it, they're being way to literal.

Good point, good sir. My apologies.
 
What is more magical? They are very few of them. If the Japanese find a way to farm whales then no problem. But many species are endangered and the ones that are not immediately at risk are not exactly plentiful.

What....is....more....magical? Hmmm, the right answer is they're all magical. Some of us see the whole goddamned thing as "magical". These are complex issues that neither you nor I created, but here we are, making awful choices in a world with lots of hungry mouths. If you spent some time being less logical and perhaps equal time in your heart, you'd realize that lots of humans are conflicted about eating what they love. In fact, despite what you think, your arguments against eating other humans or your family dog are just as arbitrary and emotional as mine. You're a hypocrite, too.

But then you already said in another thread that you "don't give a damn about animal cruelty" so I guess I'm arguing with the wrong guy.

Just stop flattering yourself that you're any smarter than me or anyone else about this. It's just not quite as simple as you think it is, and Paul Watson has brought more attention to these issues than just about anyone else. In an imperfect world we have to turn to pirates to wake us up to the beauty of the natural world.
 
What....is....more....magical? Hmmm, the right answer is they're all magical. Some of us see the whole goddamned thing as "magical". These are complex issues that neither you nor I created, but here we are, making awful choices in a world with lots of hungry mouths. If you spent some time being less logical and perhaps equal time in your heart, you'd realize that lots of humans are conflicted about eating what they love. In fact, despite what you think, your arguments against eating other humans or your family dog are just as arbitrary and emotional as mine. You're a hypocrite, too.

But then you already said in another thread that you "don't give a damn about animal cruelty" so I guess I'm arguing with the wrong guy.

Just stop flattering yourself that you're any smarter than me or anyone else about this. It's just not quite as simple as you think it is, and Paul Watson has brought more attention to these issues than just about anyone else. In an imperfect world we have to turn to pirates to wake us up to the beauty of the natural world.

Ok. So it's all magical.

So animals are magical. Plants are magical. So why only eat plants and not animals?

Hint: magic isn't real. Stop being a rube. I don't give a crap if you don't want to eat animals. Fine and dandy. Good for you. But the "magical" argument is like trying to speak with someone who actually believes in astrology or John Edward. I look at those people and I seriously wonder where they broke.