Hot Pink List

Review of Reviews

Status
Not open for further replies.

manzoftestz

Member
Feb 1, 2014
5
7
18
I want to talk about reviews.

I can categorize reviews as:

- Postive: review speaks highly of the SP
- Negative: review speaks poorly of the SP
- Useful: reivew provides good information
- Useless: review does not provide information

Personally for me, a useful review is one that explicitly describes what sexual acts were performed / not performed while also confirming accuracy of ads (pictures, price, ect). If a review is vague and does not explicitly describe sexual acts then its probably not useful (on its own). I will put a caveat that atleast for me, since I'm very picky, any negative review is useful, because it tells me automatically to not see this SP.

A review that says "I didn't enjoy my time with her because she didn't seem interested" is vague but its all I need to see to avoid her, so it is useful in that regard.

What I am interested in are useful positive reviews. Looking at this thread (https://terb.cc/xenforo/threads/katyanna.744519/), there are several reviews, some useful, some useless. Note that the point of this thread isn't to review Katyanna, I'm just using that review thread to provide examples.
1 - Useful positive review
Saw this lovely lady today, agree with everything that was said, gnd looks with a great attitude and service was top notch.
Acronyms included during my session: dfk, bbbj and mpos
2 - Useful positive review
Can confirm. Very attractive face, body (abs), tiny waist and then curvy hips/butt. Her attitude is awesome and very refreshing. She's a good communicator and is just a happy person to be around. Activities are spirited whether she is receiving or giving. Her giving was a bbbj (so I also passed the freshness test), very wet bj. Main act with top hat was her on her stomach/pillow under her hips and the view of her ass was amazing. Finished after a decent amount of time, which was surprising to me. Went down afterwards to reward her for a job well done with some extra daty. Great afternoon session. Highly recommend.
3 - Useless positive review
I saw Katyanna recently. She is amazing. Communication was great -- she responded quickly, provided all the requested information, and confirmed the appointment right away. Started the session right on time. She is very pretty and sexy. She is sweet and funny and outgoing. I won't go into details but she is very accommodating and will make sure you leave very happy. Highly recommended.
4 - Useless positive review
I took the plunge and saw katyanna yesterday. This lady is simply stunning. The hour flew by. She knows how to make a man feel like a rockstar.
If you want more examples of what I consider a "useful positive review" you can also look at the montreal board. They're much more explicit than the Ottawa board and are a good example of how to write a useful review. I can provide examples from there with links if you want.
 

Cigarman16

Active member
Mar 27, 2017
831
246
43
I do not.

Are you attempting to "school" the members of a long-standing adult entertainment forum? Like really, who cares what you want?

Consider yourself ignored.
I respectfully disagree with your assessment of the OP's post. I think it is right on the mark, and he isn't schooling me. He's providing helpful info to any member who is open enough to accept it. Most reviews are absolutely worthless. I think he is trying to help and if others improve their posts because of it, kudos to the OP.
I'll sit back and wait for the vitriol now, cause unfortunately that is how this board seems to work 😔
CG16
 

krealtarron

Hardened Member
Nov 12, 2021
4,937
9,350
113
A useful review does not have to be explicit. I have had several dates with providers who have done things with me that they advertise as "limits". I am never going to talk about those things or even call them out as YMMV. It is between me and her. Similarly I have gone by multiple explicit reviews and then the provider has refused to do things that she did with everyone else or is simply disappointing. In short explicit reviews mean nothing.

If reviews speak to the punctuality, attitude, demeanour, looks, hygiene, professionalism and at the most acronyms without going into the play by play, I am good.

What I look for is consistency between multiple reviews so I know the provider is trustworthy, fun and safe, but not necessarily the actual sexual acts - because I can always ask the lady what she is comfortable with when I email her.
 

kherg007

Well-known member
May 3, 2014
9,015
7,033
113
It's never a bad idea to remind the troops to aspire for quality reviews, whilst keeping in mind we're talking about a human being hence being sensitive to that.
 

Gurney

Active member
Feb 7, 2018
220
162
43
I respectfully disagree with your assessment of the OP's post. I think it is right on the mark, and he isn't schooling me. He's providing helpful info to any member who is open enough to accept it. Most reviews are absolutely worthless. I think he is trying to help and if others improve their posts because of it, kudos to the OP.
I'll sit back and wait for the vitriol now, cause unfortunately that is how this board seems to work 😔
CG16
I agree, most review are useless, particularly the glowing one or the the peoples that never had a bad review. That doesn't exist in the real world.
This is impossible to only have awesome encounter. Perfection doesn't exists in this world but it seem some peoples were able to find it.
That make their review useless...
 

Gurney

Active member
Feb 7, 2018
220
162
43
A useful review does not have to be explicit. I have had several dates with providers who have done things with me that they advertise as "limits". I am never going to talk about those things or even call them out as YMMV. It is between me and her. Similarly I have gone by multiple explicit reviews and then the provider has refused to do things that she did with everyone else or is simply disappointing. In short explicit reviews mean nothing.

If reviews speak to the punctuality, attitude, demeanour, looks, hygiene, professionalism and at the most acronyms without going into the play by play, I am good.

What I look for is consistency between multiple reviews so I know the provider is trustworthy, fun and safe, but not necessarily the actual sexual acts - because I can always ask the lady what she is comfortable with when I email her.
I'm also with you on that. I'm not the type that will openly describe what happen on my encounter. It is personal.
But I will talk about it in private messages.

And I will not be afraid to also report bad encounter. THAT was the primary goal of that board initi8ally. Help OP, not SP or MA...
 
Oct 29, 2019
20
36
18
I want to talk about reviews.

I can categorize reviews as:

- Postive: review speaks highly of the SP
- Negative: review speaks poorly of the SP
- Useful: reivew provides good information
- Useless: review does not provide information

Personally for me, a useful review is one that explicitly describes what sexual acts were performed / not performed while also confirming accuracy of ads (pictures, price, ect). If a review is vague and does not explicitly describe sexual acts then its probably not useful (on its own). I will put a caveat that atleast for me, since I'm very picky, any negative review is useful, because it tells me automatically to not see this SP.

A review that says "I didn't enjoy my time with her because she didn't seem interested" is vague but its all I need to see to avoid her, so it is useful in that regard.

What I am interested in are useful positive reviews. Looking at this thread (https://terb.cc/xenforo/threads/katyanna.744519/), there are several reviews, some useful, some useless. Note that the point of this thread isn't to review Katyanna, I'm just using that review thread to provide examples.
1 - Useful positive review


2 - Useful positive review


3 - Useless positive review


4 - Useless positive review


If you want more examples of what I consider a "useful positive review" you can also look at the montreal board. They're much more explicit than the Ottawa board and are a good example of how to write a useful review. I can provide examples from there with links if you want.
"what sexual acts were performed / not performed"

Some ladies don't really do that to begin with though. We can't make people feel like they need to perform sexual acts, that's dangerous thinking.
 

Deviance

Bond: Shaven Not Furred
Feb 13, 2022
111
108
43
Um, before the brass starts flyin' I think he's simply trying to say "I prefer explicit reviews" ya/no?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Ashley Madison
Toronto Escorts