Renting to an SP

I'd assume so? Wouldn't that constitute as profiting off of proceeds? I mean if they can prove it through bank records or CRA..
Interesting, so every landlord should ask a prospective tenant if he/she is an SP and/or an illicit drug dealer or risk being jailed for not more than 10 years?
 
Interesting, so every landlord should ask a prospective tenant if he/she is an SP and/or an illicit drug dealer or risk being jailed for not more than 10 years?

Actually no, that's not what I'm saying. I don't know what's on the checklist for a prospective tenant or what should be.

I'm merely saying I think if LE wanted to attempt to take the owner down as well, that would be their first accusation.
 
Interesting, so every landlord should ask a prospective tenant if he/she is an SP and/or an illicit drug dealer or risk being jailed for not more than 10 years?


A landlord doesn't have to ask but can prohibit illegal activities in the lease agreement.

If such a clause is not included, it could imply acquiescence if the circumstances were apparent.
 
I'm merely saying I think if LE wanted to attempt to take the owner down as well, that would be their first accusation.

Exactly
If LE wanted to fuck you (eg for not giving evidence against your renter) they will tear your life apart

Their entire modus operandi is finding the weak link in a chain and trying to get them to turn others over
 
This my dear:

Material benefit from sexual services

286.2 (1) Everyone who receives a financial or other material benefit, knowing that it is obtained by or derived directly or indirectly from the commission of an offence under subsection 286.1(1), is guilty of an indictable offence and liable to imprisonment for a term of not more than 10 years.
Okay, but doesn't 286.2(4)
(4) Subject to subsection (5), subsections (1) and (2) do not apply to a person who receives the benefit​

specifically subsections c and d
(c) in consideration for a service or good that they offer, on the same terms and conditions, to the general public; or

(d) in consideration for a service or good that they do not offer to the general public but that they offered or provided to the person from whose sexual services the benefit is derived, if they did not counsel or encourage that person to provide sexual services and the benefit is proportionate to the value of the service or good.​

lay out the exceptions to 286.2, and why wouldn't a legitimate landlord be considered covered by that?

Here's the wording from the Parliament's legislative summary:
(ctrl+f "286.2(4)" to find quickly)
These exceptions – listed exhaustively in new section 286.2(4) and limited to non exploitive relations within the meaning of section 286.2(5) – essentially refer to persons who have legitimate relations with a person involved in prostitution, such as co-tenants, children and other dependants, certain employees (such as receptionists, drivers or bodyguards) or certain firms that do business with the general public (e.g., Internet service providers).

I'm 99.9% sure landlords would be covered under that. C36 is problematic for a multitude of reasons, but part of what WAS exciting about C36 was the increased ability to work indoors. Or I just don't understand, which is completely possible and if so, may someone please help explain it to me?
 
Okay, but doesn't 286.2(4)
(4) Subject to subsection (5), subsections (1) and (2) do not apply to a person who receives the benefit​

specifically subsections c and d
(c) in consideration for a service or good that they offer, on the same terms and conditions, to the general public; or

(d) in consideration for a service or good that they do not offer to the general public but that they offered or provided to the person from whose sexual services the benefit is derived, if they did not counsel or encourage that person to provide sexual services and the benefit is proportionate to the value of the service or good.​

lay out the exceptions to 286.2, and why wouldn't a legitimate landlord be considered covered by that?

Here's the wording from the Parliament's legislative summary:
(ctrl+f "286.2(4)" to find quickly)


I'm 99.9% sure landlords would be covered under that. C36 is problematic for a multitude of reasons, but part of what WAS exciting about C36 was the increased ability to work indoors. Or I just don't understand, which is completely possible and if so, may someone please help explain it to me?


You are right and wise, smart cookie. I did remember an exception if it was a service provided to the general public, and I would use Subsection 282.2 (4)* as my defence, however, it doesn't give me much comfort when the government's legislative summary omits a reference to landlords or similar 3rd parties in their example, and it's NOT an exhaustive list like they state.

Most standard leases contain language to make residential tenants abide by the laws, by-laws and condo regulations, including prohibiting carrying on a business. That may be an exculpatory clause for a landlord.

*The Control + F feature doesn't seem to work when you add a bracketed sub-paragraph.


P.S. Someone I know who works mentioned that the rules pertaining to being near children could potentially impede having an indoor incall, although I tend to say no since it is not like a public playground or in open view.
 
Interesting, so every landlord should ask a prospective tenant if he/she is an SP and/or an illicit drug dealer or risk being jailed for not more than 10 years?

Not necessary unless a condo corporation requires a questionnaire or credit check form with those questions for all tenants of condo owners. Landlords are not LE officers or CBSA agents.

They can simply draw a lease that contains standard language making it a covenant to the lessee to abide by the laws, rules and regulations or to use it for lawful purposes only.

Therefore, it may constitute a breach of a tenant covenant for engaging in business with a john (the SP is not breaking the law against herself, but a law is being broken within the premises - i.e., the obtaining of sexual services for consideration by the john, which is not complying with a lease provision).
 
however, it doesn't give me much comfort when the government's legislative summary omits a reference to landlords or similar 3rd parties in their example, and it's NOT an exhaustive list like they state.
They do mention it :) Directly from the Legislative Summary again:
In this context, it will be legal for persons to:
* engage in prostitution activities at home or in premises designated for this purpose, so long as they do not profit from the prostitution activities of another person;
* allow a prostitute to use particular premises for this purpose (e.g., a hotel or community agency providing premises to one or more prostitutes), so long as they do not advise or encourage the person to engage in prostitution activities (new sections 286.2(4)(c) and 286.2(4)(d)).

None of which is to say that the condo board wouldn't kick you in the ass about it somehow or another (small business clause maybe?). My best guess is that you wouldn't lose your place or any of your rental income - just a tenant ...which still sucks. You'd have to be VERY selective about who was signing that lease!
 
They do mention it :) Directly from the Legislative Summary again:


None of which is to say that the condo board wouldn't kick you in the ass about it somehow or another (small business clause maybe?). My best guess is that you wouldn't lose your place or any of your rental income - just a tenant ...which still sucks. You'd have to be VERY selective about who was signing that lease!


Thanks for that little nugget Rebecca but I'm wary of the wording "...in premises DESIGNATED for this purpose". Standard-worded residential leases or condos with restrictive rules wouldn't seem to comply to this government narrative (false sense of security it seems).

If I were a landlord, I would either a) include exculpatory language and look the other way, as long as the tenant is very discreet and clean or b) use looser language* that doesn't outright prohibit such activity but to be careful not to seem to encourage it.

(Where in that article is your quote found?)


*Home businesses are the norm today, and may be permissible if not disruptive to neighbours and in compliance with local by-laws (eg. an accountant working from his home computer in a part-time side business doesn't need to obtain a licence from the city to operate there).
 
I think that wording indicates that you can have a second place (that's not your primary residence) and that's kept primarily for incalls? I really don't know, I'm completely inexperienced when it comes to reading and interpreting legislation, and this summary isn't much help. Remember it's two separate phrases, so it's both legal for a person to keep a space they've designated for it, and (separate phrase) legal for a person to rent space to a companion for the purposes of. That threw me for a bit; the relevant bit to this discussion is the latter point.

I found it here:
11s1s90.png


*I know home businesses are generally tolerated, I just figured if they were going to go after you for something it could maybe be that? Cause you KNOW that someone's going to have an issue with it, it's what are they going to do about it? What if children live in the condo for example? No clue. I'm pretty sure that purely under C36, it's legal.

Smart man you'd make as a landlord! I would NOT want to be seen as encouraging the activity either. And I wouldn't want to rent to anyone that wasn't clean and kept to themselves, companion or not!
 
I think that wording indicates that you can have a second place (that's not your primary residence) and that's kept primarily for incalls? I really don't know, I'm completely inexperienced when it comes to reading and interpreting legislation, and this summary isn't much help. Remember it's two separate phrases, so it's both legal for a person to keep a space they've designated for it, and (separate phrase) legal for a person to rent space to a companion for the purposes of. That threw me for a bit; the relevant bit to this discussion is the latter point.

I found it here:
11s1s90.png


*I know home businesses are generally tolerated, I just figured if they were going to go after you for something it could maybe be that? Cause you KNOW that someone's going to have an issue with it, it's what are they going to do about it? What if children live in the condo for example? No clue. I'm pretty sure that purely under C36, it's legal.

Smart man you'd make as a landlord! I would NOT want to be seen as encouraging the activity either. And I wouldn't want to rent to anyone that wasn't clean and kept to themselves, companion or not!


Thanks for cutting and pasting.

It seems okay if it's YOUR home.

It also seems okay if a hotel or 'community agency' (whatever that means) allows it, so long as they don't advise or encourage it but the latter point may go against advertising their establishment as a place where prostitutes can carry out their activities (therefore, Harper/MacKay's law is ambiguous).

And I guess it seems okay for a landlord, assuming they aren't further restricted by other rules or regulations.

[Don't get me wrong; practically-speaking, it's not like I'm worried when I visit hotels or condos, but if I was a landlord, I'd be extra careful to ensure I choose my tenants right and lay out the rules to ensure there's no backlash].
 
I really don't think money is an issue, if she is a high end, well reviewed lady she can make her rent in a day and I don't think she would jeopardize her lively hood and not pay the rent. Always deny any knowledge of what she does. Your neighbors would become suspicious of all of the people coming and going so it's best to claim she runs an at home spa or that she is a massage therapist, ect. Co-ordinate your stories. As for by-laws and things like that, I have no idea. These guys have it covered. I've had an incall in a several different apartments and it has never been an issue. I stuck to myself, always dressed appropriately and never disclosed my job to anyone. Despite what one commenter might think, we're not all sketchy. lol