I wanted it to suck but it wasn't bad and the visuals were actually pretty good. Early on I felt it was a little fruity with all the gay guys in weird costumes. I thought the last song wasn't very good and it ended on a down note. She was definitely lip sinking.
I thought that MIA chick was anti-establishment? Guess not! [EDIT: My bad, apparently she flashed the finger and I missed it.]
I don't normally watch the halftime show and honestly I don't care enough to say whether it was the best show ever or not.
TMZ has a much better poll up: Madonna or Kelly Clarkson... who would you rather?? Tough fucking call!!!