race to mars

Asterix said:
I've asked this previously in this thread and no one has given a decent answer yet. Why is it neccessary to spend what $Billions if not $Trillions to send astronauts to Mars to solve today's problems?
Because
 
Asterix said:
I've asked this previously in this thread and no one has given a decent answer yet. Why is it neccessary to spend what $Billions if not $Trillions to send astronauts to Mars to solve today's problems?

How do you think today's problems get solved? The technology we have today is a direct result of the money spent on getting to the Moon (and the prior breakthroughs from WWII, anti-biotics for instance). On what we learned about general science to solve the problems that were identified in getting there. We had to have a better knowldge of the weather, material sciences, physics, chemestry, etc. That new understanding filtered out into the general population creating new industries, new solutions.

What are you going to suggest? Build more social housing? Why waste you money doing that? Isn't it better to give someone a job and an opportunity to have a better life by raising their standard of living instead of dropping them into social housing with no hope of climbing out?

You want concrete examples, fine. Right now we are drowning in garbage and bad water. One of the problems that must be solved to make a Mars mission possible is how to recycle waste (human waste, urine, wash water, etc...) in a closed environment because there is no possible way for a mission to take all of the air, water, food they would consume with them. We're going have to reuse the water again and again. Produce our own air because you can't recycle it, and grow their own food. In affect build a sustainable closed eco system with technologies that could be applied on Earth.

Or about new power cells, fuel cells or batteries? Their bound to have a doctor on the crew, but he/she can't know everything so their going to have to have some sort of advance AI computer support to aid in diagnostics and treatment, maybe something like an autodoc that could perform minor surgery? Who can foresee what new things we will take for granted because of the knowldge gained in sovling the millions of problems that must be tackled before a Mars mission is possible?

My Dad could not foresee cell phones, PDA's and nano-tech. He grew up in an age when the only telephone for miles was the one at the village post office, no electric light or motor cars. But he died having watched men land on the moon, being able to read his local newspaper the same day it was printed in Ireland, listen to the local radio station over the net. None of this was thought of 50 years before hand, execpt by some gifted science fiction writers.
 
Asterix, think of the conquest of space as the next arms race.
Whomever controls space in the future will most likely control earth.


Would you rather have the Russians or the Chinese running space 100 years from now????
I wouldnt, and neither does the US of A.


Thats the main reason for NASA, to conquer space before any other county does.
 
WinterHawk said:
How do you think today's problems get solved? The technology we have today is a direct result of the money spent on getting to the Moon (and the prior breakthroughs from WWII, anti-biotics for instance). On what we learned about general science to solve the problems that were identified in getting there. We had to have a better knowldge of the weather, material sciences, physics, chemestry, etc. That new understanding filtered out into the general population creating new industries, new solutions.

What are you going to suggest? Build more social housing? Why waste you money doing that? Isn't it better to give someone a job and an opportunity to have a better life by raising their standard of living instead of dropping them into social housing with no hope of climbing out?

You want concrete examples, fine. Right now we are drowning in garbage and bad water. One of the problems that must be solved to make a Mars mission possible is how to recycle waste (human waste, urine, wash water, etc...) in a closed environment because there is no possible way for a mission to take all of the air, water, food they would consume with them. We're going have to reuse the water again and again. Produce our own air because you can't recycle it, and grow their own food. In affect build a sustainable closed eco system with technologies that could be applied on Earth.

Our about new power cells, fuel cells or batteries? Their bound to have a doctor on the crew, but he/she can't know everything so their going to have to have some sort of advance AI computer support to aid in diagnostics and treatment, maybe something like an autodoc that could perform minor surgery? Who can foresee what new things we will take for granted because of the knowldge gained in sovling the millions of problems that must be tackled before a Mars mission is possible?

Good lord, what encouraged this rant? So because I think it's a waste of our resources to send astronauts to a barren rock, you suggest my solution is to build more public housing? Where the hell did that come from? I'm all for technological innovation, I'm all for sending out unmanned missions into outer space because I think we will learn more faster and cheaper, especially if we put more effort to advance robotics. You sell humanity short if you feel the only way we can motivate ourselves to fix the problems we have created is to pursue a massively expensive human foreign adventure to a desert. Oh wait, we're doing that already.
 
Esco! said:
Asterix, think of the conquest of space as the next arms race.
Whomever controls space in the future will most likely control earth.


Would you rather have the Russians or the Chinese running space 100 years from now????
I wouldnt, and neither does the US of A.


Thats the main reason for NASA, to conquer space before any other county does.
Conquering what space? Anything approaching that in the next 100 years will almost certainly be in near outer space, which I agree will likely happen. Somebody wants to stake claim to Saturn, let 'em have it.
 
Last edited:
Asterix said:
Good lord, what encouraged this rant? So because I think it's a waste of our resources to send astronauts to a barren rock, you suggest my solution is to build more public housing? Where the hell did that come from? I'm all for technological innovation, I'm all for sending out unmanned missions into outer space because I think we will learn more faster and cheaper, especially if we put more effort to advance robotics. You sell humanity short if you feel the only way we can motivate ourselves to fix the problems we have created is to pursue a massively expensive human foreign adventure to a desert. Oh wait, we're doing that already.

That's were most people go who have such a negative outlook. Why spend money on space when we can spend it here on Earth, quote unquote. Hence the jab at dumping money into public housing. (and I know you didn't say that, so don't go there)

There is no drive to dump a couple of robot probes on Mars or the outer planets, it doesn't satisify our racial need to explore. You can do that kind of thing with today's technology, we've been doing so for years. Their doing that kind of work now to just improve on robotics, increase University grants for minor R&D and to statisify idle curiority. Does it matter what kind of rocks are on Mars, no. Only if you're going there to use them. If they did find evidence of life on Mars, it would just add to our knowldge and again, we'd have to go there to study it as it's to dam dangerous to bring something home to Pasadena.

Only MANNED exploration will get the people's immagination and spur on technological development at a pace to provide breakthroughs in the sciences and engineering.

Sending a probe may give us some basic insights into some of the mysteries of Mars and the other planets. But figuring out how to safely get Man back into space to live first on the Moon and then on to Mars will be far, far more benificial as they are far more complex problems and the knowldge learned from solving those questions can have real world benefits.

Yes you can do it cheaper in terms of dollars and learn little in comparison. If you are going to drive human innovation, it has to be done on a massive scale for decades and involve a wide range of disciplines for the money poured into R&D to have tangible benefits.

And you really think Human Beings are such noble creatures that they will do these things just because it nice to? Unless someone can make a buck off someone else's misery, not much has ever been accomplished in Human history. Our greatest periods of innovation have been when we've been searching for way to kill each other faster, cheaper and from a distance. Medical science advanced because it was the only way to try and save some dumb stupid bastard on a battle field so he could get better and go out and kill the other guy. Look up the guy who invented Lysol and how the knowldge that you needed to clean a wound and your surgical implements saved lives. After all, the goverment didn't want the time and money that went into making you a solider go to waste if you died. Don't believe me, then where did the concept of Medavc come from or a Para-Medic for that matter, Blood Expanders, etc. Not from some noble endevour I can assure you.

There have been the odd individual who contributed to our history, our science, our arts, to the better of us all. Divinci comes to mind. But he and others like him are a rare breed.

The space race is a way to channel the agressive creativity in hummanity to do something wonderful. Yes you can explore with a machine, but then you lessen us all. Without the drive to explore, to know, we will die. And the Human race only moves forward if self preservation or pro-creation is involved.

And if this is a RANT, so be it. When I have an opnion, I express myself and I'm prepared to debate it.
 
Well, you could stake a claim to saturn, but you'd have to buy up 51% of their stock........
 
WinterHawk said:
And you really think Human Beings are such noble creatures that they will do these things just because it nice to?
No, I think they will do things ultimately because they work better, and can lead to profit. You don't think there are myriad problems on Earth, that those who find a way to solve them won't make money? We have the tools here, and have to find a solution here. Sending a manned mission at untold costs, to a planet that will likely never be able to sustain life or to have it's resources sent back to us in any practical way, may fulfill some deep seated desire we have to wander but unfortunately will do nothing to help with the mess we've created.
 
Asterix said:
No, I think they will do things ultimately because they work better, and can lead to profit. You don't think there are myriad problems on Earth, that those who find a way to solve them won't make money? We have the tools here, and have to find a solution here. Sending a manned mission at untold costs, to a planet that will likely never be able to sustain life or to have it's resources sent back to us in any practical way, may fulfill some deep seated desire we have to wander but unfortunately will do nothing to help with the mess we've created.

This is the kind of talk that will get you beat up at a Star Trek convention. :D
 
lookingforitallthetime said:
This is the kind of talk that will get you beat up at a Star Trek convention. :D
Verbally, or are they going to bring out the lightsabers?
 
verbalks said:
It isn't the destination but the journey. ;)

Yes I bet the scenery to get there is amazing.

ok really , i'm not sure if this has been discussed here but , now I didn't pull these numbers out of my ass.

Any grade 9 astronomy student knows that the sun is a star, and star will eventually burn out, so that means eventually our nice warm sun, will burn and turn cold, but before it does it has one final gasp where it grows to millions of times it's size in a fireball, engulfing beyond the orbit of Earth, yes and the planet , third from the sun, will be vapourised, so we need to find a way out of here before that happens.
now the nearest star is 4 light years away.... that means light traveling at 186,000 miles per second, (roughly moon distance) would take 4 years to reach there, at our speed we can do, it would take thousands of years to reach the nearest star to us, that we so need for warmth.

Now do you see why we must become not dependent on our planet base in the future,
if the sun burns put before we get going, all of humanity and our history gets burned into oblivion.

But some of you guys are forgetting the real reason for the technology,
one word,...Holodeck.... if you know what that is, then you know why we need this technology. sorry to say this but when we get the holodeck, most of the ladies here will be out of business, cause we can replicate any living creature, imagine getting your holodeck time and programing a scenario
Angelina Jolie, and 10 other beauties spending time with you. at the same time. mmmmm
no safety precautions needed....cause they are only computer generated
people, .. yes I for one would love the holodeck when its invented. all the fun with no drawbacks....

and how about beaming out of a situation when ever you want..
space tech can make life better.....
computer... run 15 nurse and 6 cavegirl program Alpha 617 ....authorization code Gilbey 42rt....