question about dvd camcorders

monkeychan said:
Ummm, how's MPEG at max 9 Mbps (for DVD standard) can be better than DV (at a constant 25 Mbps)? MPEG is NOT better than DV. MPEG is IN FACT worse than DV.

Because MPEG2 has interframe compression, DV does not. In fact MPEG4 @ 5 Mbps can look way better than MPEG2 @ 9 Mbps due to better interframe compression. If you think bitrate = quality then think again.
 
mmouse said:
On a personal note, someone who comes to an escort review board trying to impress people with video editing expertise is a fucking loser.

... and someone who feels the need to always put someone down, is what? :D
 
mmouse said:
Because MPEG2 has interframe compression, DV does not. In fact MPEG4 @ 5 Mbps can look way better than MPEG2 @ 9 Mbps due to better interframe compression. If you think bitrate = quality then think again.


lol.. and since he can't win, he changes the format we are discussing, again. How droll.

Interframe compression was what I was saying is the problem with mpeg.. sheesh. And since this interframe compression bucket brigades over any baddies that are in the picture, it ends up contaminating the entire GOP until it clears. Sounds just great to me. (ack) Why do you think Sony quickly shifted gears with the AVCHD system, that has a GOP of only 5 frames? Becuz IFC suxorz, but it's the only way to get that amount of info onto a removable medium quickly and somewhat cheaply.

BTW, I'm till waiting to see ANYTHING about these mysterious full sized DVD cams that I was assured existed. :D
 
I was responding to someone else. I've already pointed out where you were wrong in your earlier posts. But thanks for enlightening us that interframe compression sucks. It's a shame because DVD uses it, and so do all the codecs for BlueRay and HD-DVD. Also all HD programming and in a few years all TV. I guess we should all go back to VHS?
 
So back to the Original question
is there a make and modle out there that uses Full size 5-1/4 inch Dvd's and not that 3" one?
 
mmouse said:
I was responding to someone else. I've already pointed out where you were wrong in your earlier posts. But thanks for enlightening us that interframe compression sucks. It's a shame because DVD uses it, and so do all the codecs for BlueRay and HD-DVD. Also all HD programming and in a few years all TV. I guess we should all go back to VHS?


lol... you really don't get it do you?

You keep talking about delivery modes... yet we are talkling about recording. I stand by the fact that recording source footage with MPEG is a bad idea. Since everyone uses it for end delivery, that means it is GOOD?

LOL, way friggin LOL dude.

It means it is cheap and convenient, that's all. Simple tidy little packets to transmit and/or store. Again, it goes back to the CD versus MP3 analogy.
Ahhh yes, any reasonable person would bring up VHS now wouldn't they? Beta was in all technical ways, signifiantly better than VHS, but what did that mean to the general public? Nothing, they wanted cheap and long. You didn't think that one out too well now didja? Par.

That is all. Thanks for playing. Come again.


Robio said:
So back to the Original question
is there a make and modle out there that uses Full size 5-1/4 inch Dvd's and not that 3" one?

Supposedly the bear knows of some... lol :p
It's a shame that he can't seem to supply ANY sort of evidence to support his rude "WRONG" comment to me and prove how "WRONG" I am though eh?
 
Still Looking for a full size DVD Camcorder

the ones Bear linked were 3" sonys I am looking for full sive 5-1/4" DVD type maybe they do not make them . I thougth I saw a Hitachi one but I am not a big Hitachi fan and looking for other options.
they claim the 3" play in most dvd players but do not have the recording time and I do not like transfering editing etc. I just want to record and be done with it .


Supposedly the bear knows of some... lol :p
It's a shame that he can't seem to supply ANY sort of evidence to support his rude "WRONG" comment to me and prove how "WRONG" I am though eh?[/QUOTE]
 
VidiEdit said:
and yes, you need to re-encode mpeg, always..

wow 20 years.
 
DVD camcorder that uses 5" discs: doesn't exist.

Reasons:
Too much wobble produced when burning in the outer portion of the disc.
To make the camcorder fits in (most) people's palm.
 
I don't buy it

A DVD disc man fits in my hand my lap top burner can do a burn on a very bumpy ruff car ride down a windy road
the fact that they want us to buy more shit makes sense I just want to save time after transfusing 50+ Digital 8 and hi 8 tapes to DVD I said screw this I just want to record to the same media/format I will be playing them on

monkeychan said:
DVD camcorder that uses 5" discs: doesn't exist.

Reasons:
Too much wobble produced when burning in the outer portion of the disc.
To make the camcorder fits in (most) people's palm.
 
I think it's because if errors occur during reading, the player can usually correct itself. But if it's writing, the whole disc can get screwed up or something. Actually VidiEdit said this already but nobody noticed because he was trying too hard to impress everyone.

As far as I know no camcorders use full size discs. However, the little discs will play in most DVD players. If you look at your player you should see an inner groove in the tray to take the smaller discs.
 
Robio said:
A DVD disc man fits in my hand my lap top burner can do a burn on a very bumpy ruff car ride down a windy road
the fact that they want us to buy more shit makes sense I just want to save time after transfusing 50+ Digital 8 and hi 8 tapes to DVD I said screw this I just want to record to the same media/format I will be playing them on

laptop burner works due to burner being positioned horizontally. Try this experiment. Burn movie DVD on your laptop while holding and jarring the laptop in a vertical position, you'll easily get about 20% failure rate on the outer part of the DVD. At any rate, you don't want to have ANY failure when you're recording your precious moments (well, at least most people take importance on actually capturing and storing the moments).
 
mmouse said:
wow 20 years.

lol.. glad you can keep to the debate at hand.

As I said, I was not saying that as if to brag or impress. It was just to lend a little credibility to my statements but I guess it takes a while to get that through that little rodent skull of yours, eh?

:p

Glad to see that you are finally agreeing on some of my statements though. Possibly, we could be friends after all. heh
 
monkeychan said:
DVD camcorder that uses 5" discs: doesn't exist. .


NOOOO.. Bear said they exist and so they MUST! I mean he wouldn't want to berate me in public for this now and then be incorrect?!?!?

Oh, my!:D