Question 4cyclinder car, auto or manual

mymojosup said:
i drove manual my whole life, when i get into an autobox i cringe and never really understand why someone would want to do that to themselves. Except if you are a paraplegic or missing a foot or arm there is no point to get an auto. In traffic i just glide along in second gear and i find that very rarely i need to brake. Plus think about the associated costs for an automatic.
Initial cost 1000$,
Tranny rebuild 1500$,
Extra fuel cost 100$,
Saving your car from an iminent crash in winter, priceless!

Go manual, suck it up, and don't look back. Lets stop being a couch potato society :D


Do you think Tip-tronic would save you from a crash in the winter?..

You still can control the car like manual...but you incur the costs of the initial/tranny, since with tip-tronic acting like manual you'll save the gas
 
I don't care what anyone says, "tip-tronic" is not a replacement for manual unless you have a gear shift lever that lets you go from 4th or 5th to 2nd. If it's just the paddles or shifting up and down, it's just a glorified automatic, and I would question whether there are any fuel savings there. My understanding is that manuals are better on fuel because there is less energy being wasted in transmission with shifting.
 
i wonder where the clutch is in a tiptronic?
hmm....
I also just stick it in second and idle@10-15km/h and whenever i see them stoping i pull the clutch in and re engage as necessary.
 
Cobster said:
I got a manual 4cylinder at the moment, but I'm so sick of the traffic in the city that I'm almost tempted to get an auto in the next car purchase which is soon.

I LOVE manual, but the damn stop and go drives me nuts.

Would you guys say stick with manual, since in the winter, manual comes out the clear winner...or go with auto.

Let's hear it

I’m in the same predicament as you. I’ve been driving manual for years and have recently started to consider purchasing an auto for my next car.

However, if I do go the auto route, I would rather purchase a car equipped with a dual clutch transmission as opposed to a “tiptronic”.

The dual clutch transmission is actually a manual transmission with an automatic mode. There is no torque convertor. The twin clutches allow for instantaneous gear shifts. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twin-clutch_gearbox

The only affordable cars equipped with this transmission are the VW GTI, Audi A3, or the Mitsubishi Lancer Ralliart.
 
moresex4me said:
The other issue is the unavailability of manuals in a lot of cars, they just don't come with it. European cars are the exception to that, but ever try to get a manual Acura TL? Or just about anything Ford, GM or Chrysler that has 4 doors?

As to having a coffee, if I managed with a 5 speed with no cup holder, I think I can manage with a cup holder!

And mymojosup, if you can glide in second in stop and go traffic, I'd like to see it. You must not be hitting the full stop and go that this city is full of if you can "glide".


Dude, I have a manual Acura TL. What a sweet fucking ride! :cool:

I luv second gear!
 
wet_suit_one said:
Dude, I have a manual Acura TL. What a sweet fucking ride! :cool:

I luv second gear!

They are all sweet rides, but a manual would be off the hook. I didn't think they had that option to go manual, at least they didn't when I looked at them a few years ago.