Property Rights Questions?

Actually, there is another solution. I have checked in my gas code book YOU CAN RUN 636 through a chimney! It will need a specific liner and what not but I have done it once before. It is not very common and like I said a major pain in the ass(nevermind more costly) but it can definitely be done. (assuming the chimney is in usable condition). I ran into this problem one time when we were doing an install for an older italian guy who was veryyyy (and i mean verrrrry) picky. He seen no reasaon to have to cut new holes in his walls etc etc and said the only way he wanted a new furnace was if we ran it up the chimney. That was indeed what we were forced to do. The fresh air intake was forced to suck from inside the house because there was only enough room for the exhaust pipe. Which resulted in other problems, adding grills to furnace room door to create adequate combustion air.
 
Moraff Not really sure what your question is here. Nothing in 636 systems comes pre assembled. You can adjust every fitting you put on before you glue it. To remove you have no choice but to cut the fitting off just below where it is glued and put on a new one...

Also to answer sky riders question about why you would have to downsize your chimney. The reason you must make the vent smaller when downsizing from a mid efficiency furnace and water tank combo to just a water tank has to due with the amount of flue gases being sent up the chimney. For example a 6 inch exhaust vent going up the chimney would remove alot more flue gas than a 4 inch vent (duh) so you'd think whats the worst that can happen by leaving that 6 inch vent in there. What ends up happening when you oversize your exhaust vent is the flue gases have more room to move around and not as much heat forcing them up the chimney. This results in the flue gases cooling before they reach the top of the chimney. Flue gases cooling to early creates many issues. Usually when the gases cool they turn very acidic and run back down your chimney/pipe right back into your furnace. When you use a smaller pipe, it in turn make your flue gases hotter. Eliminating any condensation problems.


And to answer rockslingers question... Why would it matter if anything hits the ground and freezes? Your clearance from ground for any 636 pipe terminating through a wall is 12 inches. 12 inches being the clearance desginated for snow build up in toronto. It have nothing to do with anything hitting the ground. The only instance I could see that coming to play is where you would have to vent over a public sidewalk(aka a common walkway) where you would 1. want your pipe out of the way and 2. let the condensation disperse before hitting the pavement so there would be no ice build up/ falling hazard that you were liable for.
 
Last edited:
The reason you must make the vent smaller when downsizing from a mid efficiency furnace and water tank combo to just a water tank has to due with the amount of flue gases being sent up the chimney.
Your answer makes perfect sense since there is less flue gases then the flue should be downsized accordingly.

let the condensation disperse before hitting the pavement so there would be no ice build up/ falling hazard that you were liable for.
I assume this is the reason for the "7 foot" rule. Plus, it means most people would not bang their head against the nozzle that sticks out at the top of the exhaust pipe.
 
Thanks for this thread Sky, and seth-gecko for the Code ref., both were useful when I came home and found my neighbour's HVAC installer putting their vent into the space (24", 6" of it his, the rest mine) between our houses. His story was that adding a riser to keep the exhaust six feet up made it code-compliant, although the guys who quoted my own install two years earlier said no vent would be permitted there.

The City's HVAC permit doesn't look at neighbouring buildings, and they referrred me to Enbridge who were mystified as to why they were called but did say contractors were their own inspectors, and I should just call one to give an opinion. When I said I'd had two already, and asked what happens when judgements conflict, they gave me a number at the TSSA, which led eventually to an e-mail addy in Fuels, Technical Services and someone who finally said that: "…the section of the code referring to vents in common walkways has been removed from the code" and therefore "If the requirement to "not" vent into a common walkway has been removed from the code then there is no requirement to "not" vent into a common walkway." What is not forbidden is permitted.

Be persuasive—offering money may help—with your neighbour and good luck.
 
Thanks for this thread Sky, and seth-gecko for the Code ref., both were useful when I came home and found my neighbour's HVAC installer putting their vent into the space (24", 6" of it his, the rest mine) between our houses.

This scenario will be more and more common as people convert to HE furnaces. Your situation is a shared 30" space albeit your neighbour's share is only 6".
 
This scenario will be more and more common as people convert to HE furnaces. Your situation is a shared 30" space albeit your neighbour's share is only 6".
No, as I said, it's 24", of which 6" is his, the rest mine. The deleted Code section required a 2M height for a vent over such a shared walkway. If it was the sole property of a neighbour—as I think was your case—that section had nothing to say. In either case, as the TSSA said, since the section is deleted and the Code has nothing to say, any vent is OK anywhere there between houses. Lucky us!!

What is disturbing, as you discovered is how difficult it is to get a plain answer about the situation. No one is responsible. 311 was useless. The Building Dept. at City Hall issues a HVAC permit without regard to impact on neighbours, and doesn't know if there are restrictions or who enforces them. Enbridge couldn't say either, just that the contractor you pay is responsible for telling you, "you can't do that". The TSSA's automated answering system is unbelievably opaque (except for options to pay their bills, which were very clear), and it was only after several wrong guesses that a helpful voice gave me an e-mail. "You cannot get them by phone", they said. True. The number on the e-mail I eventually got led only to the automated system which needed a first and last name—no access to a department name—and the respondent who reluctantly and finally supplied the info insisted on one name only. It took three repeats to get a reply to, "is this location permitted?". That's at least in part because the TSSA doesn't write the standard. They just collect fees from the contractors who they license to self-inspect and who pay them for the privilege. The standard's written by the CSA, and they can delete whole sections for whatever reason, perhaps only because they think the grammar needs improving, and they have no enforcement responsibilities.

In fact, no one is responsible. Can we assume that as there is no rule about venting furnaces over someone else's property or into a shared space that such vents are safe? No one's willing to say so. Thank you Mike Harris, another example of the efficiencies of privatizing working for the citizens of Ontario.

There's a reason why the TSSA's being sued over the Sunrise Propane explosion. Same section that answers the vent questions BTW. But ask your plumber how many times a TSSA guy has checked if the TSSA number on his truck is the right size.
 
Oldjones, the above sounds like a legitimate political issue. Now if you can only get someone interested in it.
 
No, as I said, it's 24", of which 6" is his, the rest mine. The deleted Code section required a 2M height for a vent over such a shared walkway.

Your situation is more complicated as the 24" is split between your 18" and his 6". In my case, all 28" is on my property as her wall is flush against the property line.
 
In my previous home both the new HE furnace and water heater pipes were installed in the existing chimney. If the OP allows the exhaust to be installed as the owner suggests I would be concerned that if the OP goes to sell and the new purchaser takes issue with this it might cause the sale to fall thru.
 
Your situation is more complicated as the 24" is split between your 18" and his 6". In my case, all 28" is on my property as her wall is flush against the property line.
Quite so. In your case not only the fumes but the piping they come out of intrudes over the line. However, as I read that code section that was deleted, since the common walkway is entirely owned by one owner, the code always was silent on whether a vent would be forbidden, or restricted as to placement. So according to the TSSA guy's e-mail, even when there was a mention of jointly-owned passageways, discharge over a soley owned walkaway was unrestrictedly permitted. Lucky you.

One must assume that a code that allows unrestricted vent placement has elsewhere ensured the fumes are completely safe and non-injurious to structures or people, but wouldn't it be nice to believe the system ensures that. Aardie's advice above is pertinent, but when the TSSA couldn't be bothered to keep a propane facility safely operated and no one at Queen's Park is doing anything —let alone anyone at 100 Queen West where they still imagine a surplus is a deficit—I hold out little hope.

What the Cons have corrupted will take more than me and you to re-build.
 
In your case not only the fumes but the piping they come out of intrudes over the line. However, as I read that code section that was deleted, since the common walkway is entirely owned by one owner, the code always was silent on whether a vent would be forbidden, or restricted as to placement.

Fortunately, my neighbor and I reached a compromise agreement. She installed her HE furnace and the two vents protrude from the front wall of her house, so the vents are strictly on her property although still only 2 feet away from the property line.