Crosby might be the one that is tougher 1 on 1... he's definitely the stronger of the two- both in strength and in skill and stays on his feet better than almost any superstar out there... not taking anything from AO, but, he AO, is 3,almost 4 years ahead of Crosby when considering how much longer pro experience he has by playing in a pro-mens superleague in russia... he is also 2 years more advanced in age. also, AO's game is that he's purely a better shooter and hitter. but the shooter title could be called into question also (not that i agree that it should be questioned), Syd has a bit more accurate shot, his scoring %age is much higher, but that is due to the pure volume that AO shoots on net. 425 shots on net! 2nd was Jagr at 368 shots, then Olli Jokinen at 351. it is my opinion though that AO is still a better natural goal scorer and hitter than Syd. Just as how Lemieux was a better natural goal scorer than Gretzky- Gretz was still the better player.
many people say Crosby's the best to come since Gretzky. this has been said before about Lemieux, Jagr and even Eric Lindros at one time. but, the one thing that stands out is the growing consensus among his opponents in the nhl now saying that he will probably have a Gretzky like career. he has taken on the big game as a teenager- the youngest active player last season, the youngest ever to have scored 100pts., in fact and Syd clearly excels at it.