Paschendaele a century on

I noticed the bolt-action rifles
British/Canadian/American troops all had magazine fed bolt action rifles of these the best was generally considered to be the U.S. Springfield M1903 the worst the Canadian Ross Mk.III (in large measure because it had such exceedingly tight tolerances and was very easily hopelessly fouled in combat conditions). It was withdrawn from service (save for snipers) over the howling protests of Sam Hughes, the Minister of Militia and Defence, during the early summer of 1916.
 
A stupid, pointless war about nothing that killed millions, created more problems than it solved and bankrupted all involved(except the Americans). I guess we can remember the dead, but we should also remember that their sacrifice was wholly pointless. Especially for the colonials involved.
 
British/Canadian/American troops all had magazine fed bolt action rifles of these the best was generally considered to be the U.S. Springfield M1903 the worst the Canadian Ross Mk.III (in large measure because it had such exceedingly tight tolerances and was very easily hopelessly fouled in combat conditions). It was withdrawn from service (save for snipers) over the howling protests of Sam Hughes, the Minister of Militia and Defence, during the early summer of 1916.

If my memory serves me correctly, did Mr. Hughes not have money invested in this venture, with the Ross Rifle Co. or the owner was his friend or something?

A complete shame that our boys were subjected to this kind of nepotism, instead of using the British Lee Enfield. I believe soldiers used to toss the Ross away and pic up any discarded Enfields that they could find.
 
Last edited:
A stupid, pointless war about nothing that killed millions, created more problems than it solved and bankrupted all involved(except the Americans). I guess we can remember the dead, but we should also remember that their sacrifice was wholly pointless. Especially for the colonials involved.
Listen to what the Belgium has to say in the BBC video, he certainly doesn't believe it was pointless.
 
Listen to what the Belgium has to say in the BBC video, he certainly doesn't believe it was pointless.

Yeah, Belgium. A great narrative for the recruiting posters. The conflict did not start there, it was never about it, nor did it conclude there. Don't get me wrong, but I get angry every time the subject of the Great War comes up. I lost faith in humanity while studying the subject. The accolades and the demands for hero worship make me want to throw up. It was one of the greatest failures of humanity, ever.
 
^ Then you should remember back in 2014 when there was an extensive thread. The consensus among historians is that if the British Empire had not come into the War in 1914 the War would have occurred regardless, and the Central Powers would very likely have won. Since the underlying causes of German - British conflict would have remained, war between the two would have eventually followed but now the British Empire would have been utterly alone.

Further, Great Britain's word as a guarantor of treaties would have been utterly worthless from that point forward.

p.s. I can tell you didn't watch the first half hour of the video.
 
^ Then you should remember back in 2014 when there was an extensive thread. The consensus among historians is that if the British Empire had not come into the War in 1914 the War would have occurred regardless, and the Central Powers would very likely have won. Since the underlying causes of German - British conflict would have remained, war between the two would have eventually followed but now the British Empire would have been utterly alone.

Further, Great Britain's word as a guarantor of treaties would have been utterly worthless from that point forward.

p.s. I can tell you didn't watch the first half hour of the video.
That's what they say. I don't really agree. Britain stayed out of the 1870 conflict, after all. And the Hapsburg Empire would have still come apart at the beginning of the 20th century, war or no war. A swift German victory over France in 1914 was the most desirable outcome as far as the continental Europe was concerned because the butcher bill would have been marginal and the Russians, facing one front Germany and Austria, would have sued for peace in no time. Britain's entry into the conflict prevented that. It's a what if game and there are many unknowns, but almost any outcome was preferable to the one we actually got.