Own or Rent?

Own or Rent?

  • I OWN my abode.

    Votes: 90 67.2%
  • I RENT my abode.

    Votes: 34 25.4%
  • I live with my parents.

    Votes: 7 5.2%
  • I am HOMELESS.

    Votes: 7 5.2%

  • Total voters
    134
I I have many friends that rent because they can't afford to own a house but to say renting is the same as owning in the long term does not make sense. .

Don't assume that all renters can't afford to own a home. For those who choose to rent, like myself, I know that my retirement plan will not result in having to "sell" my house. Or downsizing for the sake of having money to spend.
My plan is similar to your own vs rent scenario. Fatone calculated that value to be $2.38 million. You are absolutely right. Owning is not the same as renting !!
 
Should factor in also that everything around you nominally increased in price about 5x in that time frame.
I am not an expert on any of this, but I think owning or renting in the short to mid term is virtually the same thing--you are "throwing away" money into a black hole for utilities/maintenance/insurance/etc.
Owning a house for the long term (the above time frame 1973 to 2008) coincidentally hedged you from the ravages of inflation. That house that was worth $80,000 in 1973 and is at $400,000 in 2008 only kept up with the rate of inflation...you are not richer in real terms. You gained nominally, but that 400k in assets is the equivalent wealth of 80k in 1973. What feels a bit warped to ponder is if you rented instead, and just saved up 80k that you put under your mattress or in a cash account in 1973 (you were well off) and then take it out in 2008...it only has around 20% of the purchasing power it had in 1973. Probably more drastic sounding if you look at it as losing 80% of the purchasing power.

Okay, so I am only working from memory:
Bag of chips in 1973 10 cents Bag of chips in 2010 $1.29
New Car in 1973 $2,500 New Car in 2010 $25,000
Can Coke 1973 29 cents Can Coke in 2010 99 cents
Chocolate bar 1973 25 cents Chocolate bar 2010 $1.29

Avg house in 1973 $75,000 Avg House in 2010 $400,000
 
Renting depends on your situation, if you're happily single why not rent a one bedroom for under 1000 a month, travel whenever you want. If you have a family, owning is better, your kids can damage the house and you don't have to worry about a LL, and if he wants to sell you have to go through the hassle of that.

Your own house isn't an investment, it's a place to call home where you're the boss, if you plan right you shouldn't have to sell your house to have money, your 30+ years of work should look after that.
 
Avg house in 1973 $75,000 Avg House in 2010 $400,000

That doesn't sound right, I think the average house in 1973 was about half that amount.

I prefer owning because I can't stand the idea of a landlord being able to walk in for any reason with only 24 hrs notice.
 
Probably right that it might be a touch high. Operating off my extremely hazy memory...I am aware of a small house in the family that was a bit of a fixer-upper purchased for (I'm guessing) 1/4 to 1/2 of that in 70s...and sold in the $80k range in the mid 80s.
Interesting list theycallmebruce. For my "5x" figure I was strictly going off CPI.
 
theycallmebruce;3252272 My plan is similar to your own vs rent scenario. Fatone calculated that value to be $2.38 million. You are absolutely right. Owning is not the same as renting !![/QUOTE said:
I was just doing the proper math on somebodies elses assumptions. Personally I think the stock market is over rated, people understate their risk tolerance.

Renting and putting the capital into a REIT like cap.un or tga.un [apartment, nor commercial] would after all expenses taxes and inflation put you on par or even ahead of ownership. You also get the mobility to move at will if you get a great job opportunity, or if zombies move into the neighborhood, without getting assraped by realiters.
Also if you are a single guy, or a childfree couple, buying a house can be overkill sq footage wise, and condos leaves one too sucked into potential problems with management.
OTOH if you got a family, and a government job, or for some other reason moving isn't an option, and you gotta have a backyard, and loads of storage space your crap, getting a home is the way to go.

Granted in a few years when bedbugs infest everything, home ownership will start looking pretty good.