Ontario Marijuana Laws

Re: Re: The law

Pallydin said:

Either way, you are mistaken and possession is very much still a criminal act. Please try not to mislead people so as to possibly getting a criminal record, whether intentionally or not.

Not true, but not false either.

The existing possession laws are on the books, but have been tossed as invalid/unenforceable/unconstitutional.

Until they are rewritten, there is no enforceable law on the books. Essentially that means that if you get a jarhead LE with an attitude who goes ahead with a simple possession charge, it's going to get tossed out of court.

If the decriminalization goes through as currently planned, anyone who is not a registered user would have their MJ confiscated, with a possible fine. At this point no one is talking about it being "legal" in the sense of there being no laws about possession.

Even with full legalization, you could expect the same type of restrictions as with alcohol. Some sort of sealed packages picked up at an LCBO equivalent, with sales appropriately age-restricted. Odds are having that package open in your car would result in similar penalties to open liquor. (Of course that's pure speculation -- there doesn't seem to be much support for full legalization, though it seems the better approach in the long run.)

Keep in mind, however, that the US border laws are not changing. Even if your case gets tossed, you'll have border problems if there is any record that can be searched by BP staff.
 
Re: Public Toking

groo39 said:
Somewhere in between is the equivalent of a 0.08, and the study's need to be done to identify where that line is. It's also important that any roadside tests for impairment deal with active THC and related cannabinoids, not with the metabolites that current drug tests identify. (Metabolites linger for many weeks, when anyone who's smoked can tell you the actual effects only last a few hours at most.)

The proposed decriminalization also takes this into account, they have ways of measuring THC levels and would enhance the existing Police detection programs to include these tests. The exact limits are not documented anywhere but they do state that the fines/penalties would be higher, similar to drinking & driving.
 
Re: Public Toking

groo39 said:
If you want to toke indoors, you'd best be at home or in a licensed facility (i.e. bar/smokeshop.) If you want to toke outdoors, it should be under the same restrictions as having a couple beer -- which you don't usually get away with on the sidewalks if spotted by LE.

I find it interesting that you chose to compare it to alcohol but not to cigarettes. Yes we have laws about drinking in public and the same laws may need to pertain to smoking MJ, but perhaps not. Its hard and certainly not fair to compare cigarettes to alcohol to MJ, since all are similar but different, including the affects they have on our minds and bodies and those around us.

Should we stop people from walking down the sidewalk and smoking cigarettes as well? The law pertaining to public drinking seems to be to curb public intoxication etc, if you walked down the street with a glass full of rum & coke you wouldn't get bothered by the police unless you were doing something else that required their attention.

Cigarettes are very similar to MJ, both have an affect on the brain, MJ is more compareable to Cigarettes than to Alcohol but because of how society perceives them to be (which is often ridden with falsehoods) we seem to think of MJ to be a dangerous drug like alcohol.
 
Re: Re: Public Toking

TravellingGuy said:

Should we stop people from walking down the sidewalk and smoking cigarettes as well? The law pertaining to public drinking seems to be to curb public intoxication etc, if you walked down the street with a glass full of rum & coke you wouldn't get bothered by the police unless you were doing something else that required their attention.

There is one huge difference in terms of the second hand smoke -- even the worst MJ fiend cannot smoke more than a few cigarette-sized joints in a day, while a tobacco smoker can go through a whole pack in an evening.

Tokers are not smokers who can chain one right after the other until the pack is gone.

There is also the intoxicating effects of an MJ-smoke-filled room that isn't a factor with tobacco smoke. Some people even rely on that second-hand-smoke intoxication by "hotboxing" a small room or their car.

The big concern with MJ decrim/legalization is the intoxication issues, not the potential for cancer.

As much as I've enjoyed a walk through the woods with friends and a few rollies in years gone by, I wouldn't expect to do the same on a public street. I'd also have to knock off a few dozen IQ points before I'd be foolish enough to claim that I should be able to light up anywhere a cigarette smoker would.

Unfortunately there are some rather selfish "advocates" out there who aren't interested in responsible use, but in being able to blow smoke in the public's face and basically go "Nah, nah! Can't stop me! It's legal and I'll toke wherever I want!"

I think you'll find the vast majority of them are well under 30 -- most of them grow out of it no later than 30. Please don't confuse the majority with that extremely public and obnoxious minority -- it'd be like treating all Jamaicans or Italians as criminals because a very few are involved with organized crime.
 
Re: Re: The law

Pallydin said:
If this was the case, why would the government be trying to pass a law to decriminalize instead of just making it illegal to the point they can ticket for it? The judgement you are referring to was in a lower court and I think the cases were thrown out and not ruled on (which would be necessary to strike down any law).

Either way, you are mistaken and possession is very much still a criminal act. Please try not to mislead people so as to possibly getting a criminal record, whether intentionally or not.

PAL

You're the one misleading people, pal.

Fernie
 
Yeah. Like cops know the law they are expected to enforce. Talk to the defence lawyers who go to court on this every day and stop getting your legal info from newspapers. It's freaking misleading.

Fernie
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: The law

Pallydin said:
Just because people are misinformed, it doesn't become the truth.

Absolutely true. And as I've been following this whole business with avid interest for many months, I think you should take another look at the information you're basing your statements on.

You aren't "wrong" per se in many of your posts, you just seem to stop reading the reports when you come across the section that supports your viewpoint. Whether for or against, you owe it to yourself to be fully informed before you make too many blanket statements.
 
I recall atleast two cases in the last year which have been thrown out of court, because there is no possession law for under 30 grams. I'm vaguely remember things here, but a few years ago a higher court found the existing possession law to be invalid and gave the government 1 year to refine the law , the government did not refine the law by the summer of 2002 so the law dropped off the books. The reasons the simple possession charges were thrown out is because the law no longer exists.

So yes the police have stopped enforcing/ticking simple possession because they know that its going to get thrown out of court because there is no existing law, so until the new law is passed its like a limbo.