Ontario Harmonized Tax

fuji said:
That depends on whether they really do implement enough tax cuts elsewhere to make it revenue neutral. You don't know. No-one does yet, we will have to see the details.



No. This is misinformation.

There is a lot of PST already in the price of ALL homes that are sold in Ontario. The builder pays a substantial amount of PST on many of the materials and machinery used to build the home.

That tax is invisible to you, but it is real, and it is built into the price that the builder offers.

That invisible tax is now going to be visible to you. The builder is not going to pay any PST, the purchaser is going to pay the full amount. Much of that tax was already there to begin with, but it is simply being surfaced in the price.

There is additional tax however, probably about 5% more PST being paid than there used to be. That has to be compensated somewhere else for it to not be a tax grab. We will have to wait and see.



Yes. That is WHY it is being done. That is the PURPOSE of implementing this change. The claim is that this will make business more competitive, and especially more competitive in the case of export businesses where foreign customers do not pay the PST in any case.

It will make Ontario goods 8% cheaper than they are now in foreign markets in many cases.

The cost of a home was pst exempt until this budget. The PST components of the materials are included in the bills of the subtrades who actually build the home the invoice is written as a business expense at present. In future you will get input credits as a builder so that you can write off the diference between what you collect and what you spend, the builder will write off must of the PST and the new home owner will be paying 8% of the value of any home over 1/2 of a million dollars. That 40,000.00 is new tax revenue to the government, it would not have been collected prior to this budget.

The difference between the tax on the total amount and the input tax credits will be huge. When you add the tax will now be collected on the total invoice of all the subtrades instead of just on the materials purchased the bill will get even higher, unless of course anybody thinks the additional costs won't be passed on.

The question of revenue neutral does not even come into the equation due to the difference between the pretax saveings to the business that can write off the costs and the after tax money that most of the people will be using to pay the increased bills.

Revenue neutral to a government means that they have the same amount of money coming in before as they do after, that is considerably different from the people who have to pay more money for groceries , products and services.
 
Did the gov't promise this was "revenue neutral"? My impression is that it is a tax grab...on the things that are now exempt from the provincial tax, the biggest being services I think.

It may be neutral on things that were already subject to provincial tax...that part I can believe.
 
Radio_Shack said:
I don't sale any goods(PST), only services(GST) so there is no PST. Where ever you got info that an IT contractor should collect the PST is wrong. If I was sellign them computers or some good then yes PST should be charged on those goods but not for a service.

I deal with one of the largest accounting firms in Canada and thats the way they set up all the IT contractors, just GST collection. As far as remitting, yes, of course I remit back the GST but i do pocket a GST sundry as do all who use the Fast method of GST accounting.

My point about cash flow is that I will just have more cash flow until I have to remit quartly back the HST. Just wondered if I would collect 13%, thats all and sounds like I will.

I do not sell any goods either. The issue is in what services that you provide and on what. For example, if you provide programming services on canned off the shelf software (ie. modifiying a package accounting system), the programming service MAY be taxable. The issue can be resolved in how the services are phrased on the invoice.
 
Some IT services are taxable. "High level" services, like advising a customer in a meeting, are not taxable. But "low level" services, like replacing a hard disk, are subject to PST. An IT business I am involved with has had a couple of PST audits, it is practically impossible to do it right, you just accept that the auditor will take his pound of flesh.
 
fuji said:
Right now PST is charged repeatedly at every step in the chain of transactions that lead to a new home.

That is not entirely true either, when a business buys things for resale, they are bought PST exempt. But things bought for internal use in the business, you must pay PST on. So in principle, PST is a value added tax, where no price charged should include more than the PST rate worth of PST. Same principle as GST, but GST is much simpler and easier to achieve the same thing.
 
C Dick said:
That is not entirely true either, when a business buys things for resale, they are bought PST exempt. But things bought for internal use in the business, you must pay PST on. So in principle, PST is a value added tax, where no price charged should include more than the PST rate worth of PST. Same principle as GST, but GST is much simpler and easier to achieve the same thing.
That is not true wrt houses. Anything purchased that becomes part of real property is subject to PST so a builder would have to pay the PST on materials.
 
LateComer said:
That is not true wrt houses. Anything purchased that becomes part of real property is subject to PST so a builder would have to pay the PST on materials.
yes, PST becomes part of the cost of materials.PST is buried into the cost of all materials
What this tax adds is PST to labour of all the trades etc,which currently is only subject to GST
 
All this tax change really is a shifting of the tax from the manufacturers to the consumers. The theory is that the manufacturers will then reduce their prices due to the reduced taxes and the consumers will pick up the tab, thereby making it a net change of zero (or better).

I say theory because that's all this is. How many sellers reduced their prices when the GST went down? All of them? Hardly. Many pocketed the savings and didn't pass it on to consumers. So that just shifted the money from the consumer's pocket to the producer.

This is what I hate about economics. The whole tax change is based on a HUGE assumption that producers will pass along the savings to the consumer. There is no assumption for consumers; we definitively get stuck paying the increased tax.

This whole thing is all about helping out the manufacturers (at the expense of the consumer) due to the disastrous situation that faces them right now.

It's being sold as a zero-sum game but in reality it's a way to get joe consumer to prop up the manufacturing industry, based on the premise/assumption/hope that short-term pain will lead to long-term gain for the economy.
 
So... to put it in terms we are all familiar with then...

Bait & Switch!:mad:

Like I said... farkin politicians!
 
guelph said:
The theory is that you will not pay any tax on the assets you buy in your bussiness - computers, office supplies, Vehicles etc. therefore your expenses will decearse by and you will of course pass the savings on to your customers by reducing your fees.
Not sure where you got this advice.

The govt makes clear that things consumed by your business are taxed; things you sell are creditable because they are taxable upon sale.

So if you sell computers, you get credit for the computers you buy for resale. You have to pay tax on the computers you use in your office.
 
C Dick said:
That is not entirely true either, when a business buys things for resale, they are bought PST exempt.
This assumes that the purchaser fills out a PST Exemption Certificate (PEC). There are some who just don't bother, and pass along the added cost to their customers. This might be the case, for example, for small importers who buy goods internationally and have taxes added automatically by the courier company, that it's easier to simply bury the first PST in the cost of goods sold, rather than filing and tracking all the paperwork to get it refunded.
 
Anynym said:
Not sure where you got this advice.

..........................You have to pay tax on the computers you use in your office.

Not true, GST paid on computers, supplies, furniture etc etc is used as a tax cedit, end result is that no (GST) paid . PST is different, under harmonized tax, PST follows the same rules as GST, therefor there will be no tax paid on purchases for consumption in a business, (provided you're registerd GST)
 
landscaper said:
That 40,000.00 is new tax revenue to the government, it would not have been collected prior to this budget.

No, you are still missing the point. Previously about $15000 of that would have been collected in PST on the building materials. That $15000 is no longer being collected. Now instead $40000 is being collected on the sale so only $25000 of that is new tax revenue.

When you add the tax will now be collected on the total invoice of all the subtrades instead of just on the materials purchased the bill will get even higher

No. This is wrong. This will work as the GST works today: The subtrades and builders tax is NOT ADDITIVE. It gets passed along to the consumer.

Here is an example:

You're a builder and I'm a supplier. I charge you $1000 and tack on $130 in HST which I remit to the government. You collect more than $130 in HST from the home buyer so you get a refund of $130 from the government in your HST tax claim.

The net result is the ONLY tax that has been paid here is the final 13% tax paid by the consumer. All other intermediate collections of HST get refunded just as GST does today.

So today, without harmonization, there is PST being collected by the suppliers that is NOT being refunded to the builder because that is now how PST works. Now that money will be refunded.

The question of revenue neutral does not even come into the equation

Yes it does because the Ontario government has said that it will rebate and cut taxes elsewhere, outside of the PST, to reduce government revenues by an amount equal to the amount of extra PST collected.

In the example above they have $25000 in new revenue from the home sale so they will presumably have to cut taxes elsewhere (say, income taxes) by $25000 to make the tax changes in the budget revenue neutral.

Whether they will actually manage that we won't know until we see the implementation details.
 
Flinty McGimp should have lower the combined rate to a flat 10% to allow for the greater reach of the HST over the PST, but since he lowered income taxes and corporates as part of this package then I have to reluctantly say that he made a good move overall (that is, iff they keep the lower income tax rates....watch some future gov. keep the HST rate while raising income tax rates back to their old levels.)

Of course, the real reason for these higher taxes in the first place is the extra 26 Billion in spending that his government is responsible for since he acceded to power in 2003.....but I'm convinced that Ontarians love big governent despite all their griping about it.