Ontario embraces no-strings-attached basic income experiment

Where is the Ontario government going to get an additional $8 billion a year?

The idea is that the benefits will result in savings that will cover most of the 8B. Who knows, but all the current social safety net costs a lot to manage and police, so this will add huge efficiencies. Also the long term costs of poverty are MASSIVE, so the idea is, that if you eliminate this the longer term benefits will vastly outstrip the initial costs.
 
Fuji, I wonder if you are one of those people who have not lived, worked or paid taxes in Canada for years, but are happy to come back when you need healthcare or collect from our pension plan or GIS, etc?

I worked in Canada for many years and each year paid more in tax than the average person's gross salary. I still pay tax in Canada on the rental income from my properties there but that's much less.

So I won't qualify for GIS.

But as for CPP under the Canada/US tax treaty my contributions to CPP and my contributions to Social Security will be harmonized and I'll receive a pension in total equivalent to what I would have gotten had my contributions been all in one country.

I'm not counting on that. Social security is headed for bankruptcy and CPP will be such a small portion of my income that I just view it as a bonus.

Healthcare is an issue though and definitely a reason to retire in Canada. First because the care is better. Second because by the time I retire I might not have enough years of contributions to qualify for Medicare which would mean I'd need to pay almost entirely out of pocket, absent my employers plan.
 
Last edited:
Hey, if it works and is a net zero cost, I'm for it, despite thinking the current system is already too "no strings attached".

But in order for it to be a net zero cost, they'll have to close down dozens of departments and let go of a lot of public workers. Who wants to bet that'll happen?
Like most provincial programs in the modern era, they implement the program, then fail to implement the part that pays for it. And so taxpayers foot the bill instead.
 
Hey, if it works and is a net zero cost, I'm for it, despite thinking the current system is already too "no strings attached".

But in order for it to be a net zero cost, they'll have to close down dozens of departments and let go of a lot of public workers. Who wants to bet that'll happen?
Like most provincial programs in the modern era, they implement the program, then fail to implement the part that pays for it. And so taxpayers foot the bill instead.

Thank you for this intelligent post, it cuts to the heart of the matter.
 
Hey, if it works and is a net zero cost, I'm for it, despite thinking the current system is already too "no strings attached".

But in order for it to be a net zero cost, they'll have to close down dozens of departments and let go of a lot of public workers. Who wants to bet that'll happen?
Like most provincial programs in the modern era, they implement the program, then fail to implement the part that pays for it. And so taxpayers foot the bill instead.

Its not so easy as you think, the net zero cost or even lower cost can only be measured over a longer period of time. How do you count the savings in lower crime, better health, and higher productivity? The costs, like most investments, are up front. The payoffs are 8-15 years. If you want a govt that runs like a business, that is exactly how many businesses think...
 
Its not so easy as you think, the net zero cost or even lower cost can only be measured over a longer period of time. How do you count the savings in lower crime, better health, and higher productivity? The costs, like most investments, are up front. The payoffs are 8-15 years. If you want a govt that runs like a business, that is exactly how many businesses think...

I run a business, so I would know. The problem is that government does not run that way (nor should they in some regards, but that's a different issue). 8-15 years down the road, this probably won't be on anyone's radar. And if it is, it likely won't be an analysis of the preceeding years to see if we made our money back.

I also don't see how basic income improves crime rates and productivity. I find the evidence presented for these anecdotal.

I truly hope it works out. We need solutions to growing wealth inequality brought on by globalization and advances in technology. I'm not sure this is the solution, but who knows?
 
I run a business, so I would know. The problem is that government does not run that way (nor should they in some regards, but that's a different issue). 8-15 years down the road, this probably won't be on anyone's radar. And if it is, it likely won't be an analysis of the preceeding years to see if we made our money back.

I also don't see how basic income improves crime rates and productivity. I find the evidence presented for these anecdotal.

I truly hope it works out. We need solutions to growing wealth inequality brought on by globalization and advances in technology. I'm not sure this is the solution, but who knows?

Well someone has looked at the evidence and decided its more then anecdotal, but this is why they are doing an experiment with a subsection of the population to see what the results are. You are right, who knows if this will work, but its worth considering and I think its hard to deny that poverty has huge long term costs. I am surprised how you cannot make the connection to lower crime rates when its show that crime rises when the economy declines. Also the connection to productivity is pretty simple, people will have the ability to work, rather then being trapped on welfare, and child poverty rate will drop and as a result education of children will improve. Medical costs will also decline as a result. In the end you have to add all that up and to some degree take a leap of faith and try it out in come fashion.