Old Navy - Time waster....Another retailer I HATE!

Ding! Ding! We have a winner. :)


If you get a THE RULES ARE THE RULES type of lower management wannabee, he might pull the attitude that I am God here and I will not allow you to circumvent what I have just told you.

It is better to buy the new coat at the lower price and on another occasion when you know that you will be passing the store to bring back the old coat and get the full refund price.
 
A few years ago I bought a piece of photography equipment at a large store on Queen St. About 2 weeks later I saw an ad for the same thing for 50% off, I took the item and receipt to the store and asked for the difference, the guy at the counter basically told me to take a hike.

I went to my car got the item and brought in to him and said I would like a refund for this item. He asked what was wrong with it and I said "here on the receipt it says, if I am not completely satisfied I can return it for a full refund, so I am not satisfied and I'm returning it" after some grumbling and a few questions to which I responded " I am not COMPLETELY satisfied" he gave me a full refund.
I went across the street to a cafe got a take out coffee and walked back into the store and bought the item again at 50% off.

I'm still using it today.

You should have gone home and got the coat returned it and bought a new one. I would have.

F*ck them and their horse!
 
My worst ever customer service experience was with Linksys. I bought a Linksys WIFI router and it turned out to be incompatible with my laptop.

I found this clearly documented on the Linksys website, that it was incompatible. So I wanted to return it, and buy one that was compatible.

I called Linksys technical support and explained the problem. They INSISTED that I run through their full diagnostic process, which in total, takes about four hours.

I asked the rep to search their support database, and they agreed that they could see reports that the devices were incompatible. I said, "So you know and I know that in four hours this still won't work, and you will issue me a refund?"

Yes, said the rep, but it's company policy that we have to run through the diagnostics...

So not only four hours of my time, four hours of their time, on the phone, to get a refund for a $100 device.

I hung up and returned it to the store and paid the stupid 15% "restocking" fee that you have to pay when you return an open box item there for no reason (typical college st policy).

It wasn't worth $15 for me to spend four hours on the phone with them and I guess Linksys knows that--fuckheads.

They make good products but I will never again buy one.
 
If I was the manager of the store I would be a little suspicious of someone producing only the receipt and not the actual item and then wanting store credit. Too many scams going on nowadays. I am in no way suggesting that you were doing something like that, as I believe your story. The guy probably figured it would be easier (for him) to do everything by the book then get yelled at by his superiors for giving out store credit. And he probably doesn't get paid enough to worry about losing you as a customer.
 
Why didn't you just buy one of the ones they had on sale there, and returned it right away using your old receipt?

Works for me all the time when I don't have the product but have the receipt and I find something for much less of the price than I paid...
 
So i bought a coat 3 weeks ago at Old Navy. Today I am in the mall and notice the coat is 50% off. I happen to have my receipt so I ask for a price adjustment. Store credit would be fine.
Me: You want me to drive 15km home, get the coat, return it for a full refund, go to the coat aisle, get another off the rack, and pay for it at half price?
Me: Can you explain to me how on earth this makes sense? Essentially, you will give me money back, but you want me to earn it? Waste gas, waste my time, your staff time, have you restock the first coat I bought etc etc. Please explain how this helps YOUR store or the CUSTOMER?

So hold on...you're telling me all you had was the receipt and not the coat you bought and expected they'd just hand over store credit (gift cards) to you simply because you produced a tattered receipt?

What's to stop them from thinking you just found a receipt and never actually bought the coat? Or that you've just gone and made a recipt up....don't think that it doesn't happen.

I'm all for raging against bad customer service, but in this case the manager was totally in the right in protecting the store from what could have easily been a case of fraud.
 
So hold on...you're telling me all you had was the receipt and not the coat you bought and expected they'd just hand over store credit (gift cards) to you simply because you produced a tattered receipt?

What's to stop them from thinking you just found a receipt and never actually bought the coat? Or that you've just gone and made a recipt up....don't think that it doesn't happen.

I'm all for raging against bad customer service, but in this case the manager was totally in the right in protecting the store from what could have easily been a case of fraud

Good catch, it certainly does change things a bit.
 
If I was the manager of the store I would be a little suspicious of someone producing only the receipt and not the actual item and then wanting store credit. Too many scams going on nowadays. I am in no way suggesting that you were doing something like that, as I believe your story. The guy probably figured it would be easier (for him) to do everything by the book then get yelled at by his superiors for giving out store credit. And he probably doesn't get paid enough to worry about losing you as a customer.

I didn't think the manager did anything wrong. Store policy is store policy, even if it is stupid.

I can also see your point, without the actual product and only the receipt, would bring up some questions. I wouldn't refund anything without product and receipt.
 
So i bought a coat 3 weeks ago at Old Navy. Today I am in the mall and notice the coat is 50% off. I happen to have my receipt so I ask for a price adjustment.
What the hell are you carrying a three week old receipt around for? Do you carry all your receipts around with you?
 
Its over.
Get on with life.

I have to concur with Stang.

Also, rather than rag at the manager realize,
a lot of these lower levels managers get reprimanded if they started varying from policy.

In the long run, they end up winning because they don't give you the cash back as a result of what probably is an intentional strategy to make it inconvenient to come in after the fact and get a discount.

Is the sale still on?
 
It is over. I didn't really care about the $50.

It was a matter of convinience that I even walked into the store when I saw the sale signs.

Fact of the matter is that I have been in the Customer Relationship Management/Building Consultant field for some time and whomever is writing their policy and giving marching orders to their managers seems to be quite out of touch.

Maybe that is why I proceeded to push the envelope when the "policy" was explained.

Case closed for me. I will only read the rest of the discussion if there are any more thoughts on this.

In the end though, after a little more follow up, I did return the original coat for a full refund and I do have a $100 gift card coming in the mail :)
 
It is over. I didn't really care about the $50.

It was a matter of convinience that I even walked into the store when I saw the sale signs.

Fact of the matter is that I have been in the Customer Relationship Management/Building Consultant field for some time and whomever is writing their policy and giving marching orders to their managers seems to be quite out of touch.

Maybe that is why I proceeded to push the envelope when the "policy" was explained.

Case closed for me. I will only read the rest of the discussion if there are any more thoughts on this.

In the end though, after a little more follow up, I did return the original coat for a full refund and I do have a $100 gift card coming in the mail :)

Frankly, if you gave the manager a hard time about their policy, you should be the one offering an apology. I'm sure there are plenty of fraudsters out there trying to pull scams to get free money out of retailers based on receipts they find on the floor etc.

Their policy is perfectly reasonable, and you were probably too pissed off at the time to realize that.
 
Always remember with regards to receipts....if it's an important one photocopy it, most receipts now are on thermal paper and fade away with time.
 
I'm kind on the fence on this one. While I agree it would have been good customer service to offer the discount, I don't blame the retailer for wanting the customer to bring back the item. There is something to be said about paying the price of the item at the time you made the purchase. I dunno, I just think it's about accepting responsibility and sometimes you win, sometimes you lose.

If you really want to get that discount, then take the time to bring the item back. Otherwise suck it up and take it as just one of those things.

All that being said, if I was a retailer and I valued a particular customer's business, I'd give them the discount. But if it was just some joe blow off the street, probably not. Maybe I'd look you up on the computer and see if you've shopped there before and/or if you're a good customer. If not, too bad.