Non - kosher Jews??????

I believe your Jewish friend either got the facts wrong or was feeding you a line. Rabbis don't give dispensation for anything. Kosher Jews are allowed to eat non-Kosher food if there isn't any alternative. For example, kosher Jews during WW II ate all non-kosher rations on the front lines because no kosher rations were available. Once kosher food is available again, they're expected to eat it.

Thanks 4Tees,

Your observations are the same as my observations from a non Jew prospective. Since we are all here at this hobbying forum, we are all hypocrites to some degree. I think that in all religions there is a Thou shalt not hobby clause. Being kosher or halal does not make a better person. It is just adhereing to your beliefs, A person must adheres to ALL his or her beliefs to be pius. Thou shalt not kill or do harm to others is at the heart of all beliefs.


.Years ago, I was at a Chinese buffet filling my plate next to two old Jewish brothers that I know. I cautioned one of the old guys telling him that the won ton soup he was putting in his bowl was made of pork. He told me he liked pork and that he had dispensation from the rabbi to eat pork. His brother told me that in 1945 the older brother was conscripted to fight in WW 2. They sent him to England to train and he marched around for a few weeks, and shaved in cold water but by then the war was over by then. Before he went into the army, a rabbi gave him dispensation to eat pork ( if there was no alternative food )
He learned to like pork and claimed the dispensation to be life long as the rabbi never lifted the dispensation
These two guys were good honest men that contributed to Jewish causes as well as to non Jewish causes to improve society. One brother kept kosher as much as possible and the other brother enjoyed non kosher culinary delights. They were both honest and honorable men. Keeping kosher is just a reminder of your faith. No extra brownie points are awarded if you do or if yout don`t.
In high school I use to go to literagy every day ( 20 minute mass ) Twenty years later I see the chaplin from the high school and he asked me if I still go to mass every day. I told him that the last time I went to mass was the last time I saw him. He asked me if I was proud of myself. I told him that being a good person is better than going to mass. The preist had no retort.


If a real life Tony Soprano character went to mass every day, it would not make any difference on judgement day.
 
I believe your Jewish friend either got the facts wrong or was feeding you a line. Rabbis don't give dispensation for anything. Kosher Jews are allowed to eat non-Kosher food if there isn't any alternative. For example, kosher Jews during WW II ate all non-kosher rations on the front lines because no kosher rations were available. Once kosher food is available again, they're expected to eat it.

Who knows if he actually got dispensation to eat pork? Maybe he just liked ham and bacon. In those days he had to do what the goyms did to get the shikza girls.

I found this on the internet :

Life in England during World War II
Special dispensation from the rabbinate that allowed Jews serving in the armed services to eat pork.

www.jewishmag.com/136mag/uk.../uk_rationing.htm



 
I think kosher and halal meats are better quality than typical supermarket and restaurant fare.

I think most modern jews are respectful of the intention of their religious customs but temper it with the reality that most of these dietary laws are based on food safety issues that are no longer as relevant as they were in biblical times.

Having said that, it seems there is big pressure among some of jewish society to be seen to be "keeping up with the Jacobs' "

Many excellent points. As I am not attached to any particular religion, I tend to find most of the various "taboos" to be somewhat amusing. Basically if people want to follow a bunch of rules that were defined centuries ago then all the more power to them. I only get concerned when they want to impose their beliefs and rules on me, particularly in the name of God (or the many variations Jehovah, Buddha, Krishna, Allah, Satnam and two of my favourites - George Burns and Morgan Freeman.)

Keeping kosher or following halal is one of those personal things that I suppose is intended to show one's piety and faith. But frankly if you slip in a Big Mac, fries and a Coke every once and awhile I don't think God is going to throw you out of the club. After all, Allah is a kind and merciful God. He'll understand.
 
I couldn't find the specific article. Regardless (and I don't wish to belabour the point), but the rabbis didn't make a specific "dispensation" during WW II that they were allowed to eat pork but told them they could based on an interpretation made by rabbis centuries ago based on specific situations then.

Who knows if he actually got dispensation to eat pork? Maybe he just liked ham and bacon. In those days he had to do what the goyms did to get the shikza girls.

I found this on the internet :

Life in England during World War II
Special dispensation from the rabbinate that allowed Jews serving in the armed services to eat pork.

www.jewishmag.com/136mag/uk.../uk_rationing.htm



 
Being Jewish is as easy (or, in reality, complex) to define as being Christian.

Look around the world at the diversity of Christian cultures that have very little in common except for a belief system that includes a guy named Jesus.

Why not simply accept that there is just as much diversity amongst Jews. Some are fundamentalist Orthodox, some are completely secular. In the middle, there are many denominations and variations on each.

There are many Jews who keep Kosher. However, if you don't, you're unlikely to run into them in situations where you're both eating. The guy on the subway across the aisle from you could be Kosher and you'd never know. On the flip side, many Jews don't observe the dietary laws or only observe them at a less strict level. To each his (or her) own.

My view is, you can eat anything you want and decline to eat anything you want. Just don't tell me what to eat.
 
Speaking about topic of Jews, I have always wondered what is the definition of a Jew exactly? I am confused, is it a race, religion, both? How do you define it?

I would always argue that it is a religion/belief system. However upon discussing it with someone of the faith, I learned that at least she consideres it more of a culture/ethnicity as it permeates many aspects (if not all) of one's life. I still view it as a religion, but I understand the enormity of its influence. However, it is surely not a race.
 
Read the book"To be a Jew"
by Donin.

then you will know.

Maybe, but that may be one person's perception. However, I caution people from labelling themselves (whether Jewish, Islamic, etc.) as inherently different as it opens up the door for people to make claims of biological superiority/inferiority.
 
Maybe, but that may be one person's perception. However, I caution people from labelling themselves (whether Jewish, Islamic, etc.) as inherently different as it opens up the door for people to make claims of biological superiority/inferiority.

It is required reading to convert so start there...superiority? Were the" chosen ones" bro. You need to see the 10 plagues happen again? Mohammed knew that too....he just decided to book on his own...
 
It is required reading to convert so start there...superiority? Were the" chosen ones" bro. You need to see the 10 plagues happen again? Mohammed knew that too....he just decided to book on his own...

Gotcha!! Believe it or not, I was told that I would make a 'good Jew'.
 
Perhaps by certain rabbis, but I would hardly call it a "requirement" to convert. It is certainly a useful and well respected book, though.

ok. I stand corrected. By the United synagogue of america rabbis it is. I think thats mostly conservative. For reform...well if you can figure out where the kipah goes your in.
 
ok. I stand corrected. By the United synagogue of america rabbis it is. I think thats mostly conservative. For reform...well if you can figure out where the kipah goes your in.

As I said, it is a useful and well respected book. I would not be suirprised that is recommended, or used as a resource in any conversion program. However, to describe it as a "requirement" for conversion, in any denomination, goes too far. Also, given that it is written from an orthodox perspective, it would surprise me if it was used as anything more than a reference in a conservative conversion.