Deep sea drilling has to and will continue for much of the rest
of the century until the last drop of oil is squeezed out of the bottom
of the pacific. Not that I want to see the utter destruction of the
oceans but the consequence of stopping offshore drilling
altogether could be even more devastating.
http://transitionmilwaukee.ning.com/profiles/blogs/why-anger-towards-bp-is
Erik Lindberg, May 30th 2010
Why Anger Towards BP is Largely Misplaced
Like anyone who gives a damn about anything, I too have been watching
the BP oil spill with horror. It is becoming increasingly clear that
this is well on its way to becoming an unprecedented ecological disaster
for North America, perhaps our Chernobyl. At the least, it is likely to
have environmental ramifications for decades to come and may prove to
be a watershed moment in American energy policy as the images of futile
technological efforts to stop the leak begin to inhabit our collective
consciousness alongside the terrible images of ruined wetlands and the
gruesome wildlife casualties we have inflicted.
But I have also experienced growing horror as I witness the inadequacy of
our public debate about oil, energy, and the environment. True, the media
has done a decent enough job of broadcasting unvarnished images of the
depths and scope of this ecological tragedy, and has been willing to hold
both BPs and the governments feet to the fire. But a broader discussion
of oil and energy, at least one that demonstrates a basic understanding
of either the economy and geology of energy, has been negligently absent.
Like most people, I now scowl at every BP station I drive past and can
conjure up alternative images of what a BP corporate “top kill” might
involve. But I also believe that anger and outrage towards both BP and
recent federal energy policy and regulations are largely misplaced. I am
also convinced that while broadcast and print journalism have a duty to
provide a larger context for a debate which might begin to help us aim
our criticisms and complaints with more effective and deserved precision,
I believe that journalists have instead been complicitous in providing
easy targets for outrage rather than encouraging deeper (if any) analysis.
Not that we shouldn’t be angry and sad at what we are doing to our
only planet. But to the question of “why is BP undertaking such risky
drilling,” we hear only a limited range of answers. Of course BP is
a greedy corporation interested only in its shareholders profits—this
should go without saying. And, it turns out, BP seems to have fostered
a culture of risk-assessment which feared inefficiency more than the
consequences of an accident which would of course threaten the lives of
their workers and the ecosystems in which they were already trespassing
with little care. Obviously, too, federal regulators had become too cozy
with the corporations under their jurisdiction, over-determined by way
of the Bush/Cheney pro-oil and general anti-regulation mentality.
But if we rest satisfied with these answers, and at this point turn to
our facebook petitions, to our personal boycotts of BP (in favor of Exxon
Mobil or Royal Dutch Shell?), we probably won’t consider further what
is driving this risky off-shore oil exploration. Off-Shore drilling, as
with increased attention to arctic, heavy-oil, or tar-sands, is not the
easiest way for an oil company to pursue profits. An important concept
for energy analysis is Energy Return on Investment (or ERoI). This refers
to the amount of energy it takes to extract energy. While East-Texas oil
fields in the 1930s provided and ERoI of about 100-1 (only 1 barrel of
oil was needed to extract 100), the ERoI of an offshore oil well is down
to about 4-1. If there was any more of this low hanging fruit, the sort
found in the Texas or Mid-East oil booms, we can be sure BP and all the
others would not be bothering with high risk, low gain ventures.
For these ventures do have an astounding risk to benefit ratio. According
to BP, the Maconda oil field in which the Deep Water Horizon was drilling
contained an estimated 50 to 100 million barrels of oil. This may seem
like a lot, unless one pauses to make a simple calculation. With a
world-wide liquid fuel consumption of about 85 million barrels per day,
this entire oil field could over its entire life-span provide only 14 to
28 total hours of world energy capability. In the light of the sort of
basic math that neither our journalists nor our government sees important
enough to share, if they’ve even performed it themselves, this sort
of off-shore oil quest seems a bit desperate. This desperation instead
looks pathetic and just plain depressing if you take enough time to note
that the total amount of oil spilled as of today would have provided
enough of the world’s oil supply to last about 35 minutes. Consider
the overall loss of marine wild-life and local livelihood lost and
perhaps irreparably damaged for a half hour of energy. This high-stakes
gambling, the sort of gambling that humans are in fact making with the
very inhabitability of our planet, is not driven simply by corporate
greed or by lax government regulations.
It is driven by us and our insatiable thirst for oil. But our
cultural ignorance concerning basic energy numeracy, as well as an
understanding of the economics of oil and energy allows otherwise
intelligent and well-informed people to participate in outrage towards
BP without reflecting for a moment on their own attitudes, habits,
or behavior. Well-meaning and sincerely concerned people believe
their responsibility ends with a scowl towards BP or by the hitting
the “like” button on an anti-BP or anti-offshore drilling facebook
link. While we as citizens are victims of a broad ideology of consumption
and a persistent lack of information about energy, we are nevertheless
responsible for informing ourselves whenever the opportunity arises. And
the opportunity has not only arisen, it is screaming for immediate
attention.
The attitude I see, however, is that we should simply stop offshore
drilling, or should simply switch to renewable energy. It seems
unaccompanied by any sense that as long as we buy it, they will drill for
it. It is an attitude that doesn’t grasp the fact that if we demand
an end to offshore drilling (which we should) that not only will our
fuel prices go up, we will eventually, perhaps in the very near future,
be presented with a far more acute situation.
The only thing simple in all of this is that if we stop exploring for oil
in difficult and hazardous locations, even in spite of their low return
on investment, the 85 million barrels a day that the world currently
consumes and demands will soon fall to 84 million, then 80 million, and so
on. The result of this sort of shortfall will not simply be $4 or $5 per
gallon gasoline (about which people are more likely to take to the streets
than about ecological devastation), but, unless we change our habits and
expectations, a decline into permanent recession and economic depression.
I am going to set aside the issue of alternative fuels, information
about which represents the other great point of energy ignorance in our
culture, and the expectations about which represent an additional cultural
hallucination. Our economy is entirely dependent not only on cheap fuel,
but on the promise of abundant fuel, the supplies of which will always
be able to meet demand. This, after all, has been the experience of
industrialized civilization for the past 200 plus years. Our economic
and political infrastructures and modes of organization are predicated
on the promise that we can have as much energy as we want and that more
energy will be available next year than this year. All economic growth
has been accompanied by increased use of fossil fuels.
As if to emphasize and clarify this point, the few times in which oil
supplies have experienced temporary declines (the oil shocks of the 70s)
or at which oil prices have spiked (the first decade of the 21st century)
the result has been rather severe economic dislocation. This is not the
place for a full elaboration of the connection between monetary policy and
the basic facts of currency as a measure of wealth and its foundation on
the promise of continued and permanent economic growth. But let me simply
note that this year’s investments make sense only given the belief that
there will be economic growth and that next year’s GDP or GWP will be
larger than this year’s. And let me note, also, that next year’s GDP
can only be larger under two circumstances: that there will be more energy
available and that people believe there will be more energy available.
Thus the desperate, drill at all costs, approach to oil. If we limit
ourselves in such a way that there will only be 84 million barrels of
oil available per day next year, the economic system breaks down. And
as we should all realize, a recession of 2% doesn’t simply mean we all
have to “make do” with 2% less stuff. This is what gives politicians
and economist insomnia, and what allows them to accept fully unrealistic
projections such as both the supply and demand of oil at a level of 120
million barrels per day in 2030. From this perspective, it doesn’t
make sense to put this sort of limits on ourselves, and this is why we
don’t and probably won’t.