NFL MVP and Rookie of the year
- Thread starter thumper18474
- Start date
MVP is either Payton or Brady
Rookie is either RGIII or Luck
You really need to see how they do in the grind to the playoffs to rate any further.
Rookie is either RGIII or Luck
You really need to see how they do in the grind to the playoffs to rate any further.
Here comes the most valued 4 games of their season. I am not talking about playoffs,but the race to get there.
Name of the award should just be renamed to MVQB. Awards go to the QB way too often for my liking. And with more teams going to a RB by committee system and with fewer "bell cows" around the league its likely that QBs will win the award with even greater frequency moving forward.
How about Von Miller, J.J. Watt, Peanut Tillman as candidates? Nevermind, I must be dreaming in technicolor to think that these voters would give defensive players consideration. The award is a joke in my mind.
How about Von Miller, J.J. Watt, Peanut Tillman as candidates? Nevermind, I must be dreaming in technicolor to think that these voters would give defensive players consideration. The award is a joke in my mind.
Yeah they should award the best QB, RB, FB, Reciever, TE, OL, DL, LB, S, CB, K, P as each position has vastly different skill sets and responsibilities.
I think Manning looks good for MVP
Luck for ROY although RG3 could steal it if he finishes the season strong. Both are having great seasons.
I think Manning looks good for MVP
Luck for ROY although RG3 could steal it if he finishes the season strong. Both are having great seasons.
Yeah they should award the best QB, RB, FB, Reciever, TE, OL, DL, LB, S, CB, K, P as each position has vastly different skill sets and responsibilities.
I think Manning looks good for MVP
Luck for ROY although RG3 could steal it if he finishes the season strong. Both are having great seasons.
Really?
RG3 QBR 104.4 (second to Aaron Rogers at 105)
Luck QBR 76.1
RG3 17 TD to 4 INT
Luck 17 TD to 16 INT
RG3 67.1% completion
Luck 55.5% completion
Luck has more passing yards but RG3 has WAY MORE rushing yards.
... and RG3 needs to "steal" the rookie of the year awards from Luck?
This is not the MVP award where making the playoff is a huge factor...
Ive always heard...the MVP' award is being the most valuable player to their respective team...based on the regular season...
If you compare the supporting cast...RG3'.... has more to work with...remember.. Indy basically gutted their team on offence...Reggie Wayne the only hold over....
And don't count out Wilson in Seattle....although he does have lynch in the backfield....
If you compare the supporting cast...RG3'.... has more to work with...remember.. Indy basically gutted their team on offence...Reggie Wayne the only hold over....
And don't count out Wilson in Seattle....although he does have lynch in the backfield....
Would be quite the story (one day a movie) if Manning is MVP and his replacement in Indy wins ROY.MVP; would have to go with Payton
Rookie; Luck
I believe Indy has two games left with Houston...if he leads his team to a win in one of those two games I would think Indy makes the playoffs and Luck is a lock for ROY. Manning is a tougher call. As a dark horse, if Houston goes 15-1 I think Watt could win defensive player and MVP.
Luck almost has as many interceptions as touchdowns. RGIII leads one of the highest scoring offenses but their defense has been decimated by injuries. I just dont see your logic.I would have to give it to Luck. MVP I'd say Payton
MVP - Tom Brady
Comeback - Adrian Peterson
Rookie - Andrew Luck
Defensive - JJ Watt
Adrian Peterson is a worthy comeback player of the year candidate but my personal choice would be Thomas Davis.
Watt is a great choice for defensive player of the year. Von Miller is definitely in the running too. And a solid case can be made for Peanut Tillman. Some have argued Aldon Smith but he would be below those other 3 guys in my personal opinion.
