New Illinois Rape Law

Re: Re: Re: Get real!

Barry-O said:
Quite frankly, a woman can cry rape ANYTIME and unless you have alot of money, you don't stand a chance in court as a male....you could be as innocent as the next guy and you'll still go down.
I find the court system to be VERY biased when it comes to this stuff. Don't get me wrong, I'm not "pro male" when it comes to this. all I'm interested in seeing is a FAIR trial and more often than not it won't be fair.
Face it guys....the possibility of a woman crying "wolf" is much higher than you think...it actually happens alot

Of course their are 'some' women who have lied about being raped. Women are human beings and capable of lying and being evil just like men, but how many women do you personally know who would even think about doing such a thing, I believe a small minority...... and there are also many men who have lied about 'not' raping a women and many have gotten away without punishment.

BARRY-O--And when you say that you find the court system to be VERY biased in rape cases, in favor of women, and if an accused male does not have a lot of money and innocent 'you will still go down'.... FROM WHAT FACTUAL AND PERSONAL BASIS DO YOU MAKE such a strong claim?

Barry-O what frame of reference do you have to make such a STRONG claim or accusation??????

Have you or how many of your close male friends/family have been accussed/arrested of rape?
Have you ever been personally involved in rape court case (accused or witness, are you a criminal lawyer or a judge or a social worker/police detective/psychologist/medical doctor who examines rape victims)? Have you ever even witnessed a rape case in your life?
Have you ever spken to a rape victim?
Did you ever personally know a woman who as you say 'cried wolf' and lied about being raped and was this innocent male arrested and convicted of this crime? And what was her motive?
Are you totally aware of the long, difficult and invasive process of reporting a rape and filing charges (ie. calling the police, filing a very detailed police report and the very indepth and invasive questions asked by the investigative officers-who are total strangers btw, an investigation, nude photos are taken and a very indepth medical examination, the very uncomfortable gyno exam-that every woman hates, and more questions and forms to fill out, testifying in court being cross examined by a lawyer who will do anything to discredit you and attack you, and every private incident in your life will be on display, to ruin your crediblity, etc.)?
Do you realize that studies show that most women who have been raped and are in relationships, boyfriends or married, that a very high percentage of these relationships will end, especially if the lady decides to file charges, because of the stress of enduring such a long emotionally charged court process?
Etc., etc., etc.
The above are just some of the reasons why so many rape victims never tell anyone or file charges.
 
fernie said:
Because of the stigma associated with a conviction, rape means a trial of the victim rather than the accused. How many times is there a corroborating witness to a rape? Unlike any other crime, why is the sworn testimony of the victim considered to be doubtful evidence more often than say a mugging victim? No wonder many victims don't want to testify.
Fernie

Do you know why that is the case Fernie?

In most cases of rape there is no physical evidence. So it becomes a situation of her word vs His; In as much as the courts lean in the favour of the female they can't over look that fact. The alleged victim is the one that is taking the alleged accused to court so they have to focus on her more.

Case in Point:

I personally know someone that was wrongfully accused of rape (hes not the only one mind you)...LE hauled him in....KICKED his ASS at the station, plastered his name and pic in the papers....turns out he wasn't even the guy...it was someone else who ended up admitting to the crime.
Now what was going through this womans mind when she pointed out someone who wasn't even guilty? Sure this dude was let go...given the apology...but what about the embarasment, legal fees, the ass whoopin he got from LE....


whos the victim now???
 
Barry-O, asserts a chilling fact. Times have changed because equality under the law isn't what contemporary feminists wanted. They wanted power and they got it by stealth.

I want to add a few further comments on the NO means NO slogan by the feminists. In a world where people respected rationality and the objectivity of langauge we would have no problems. But we don't live in such a world. Consider the following: What if a woman says NO but her body langauge says YES? What then? And, as I said before, what if it's a test for you to try harder at seducing her? (I'm, of course, not suggesting any coercive action, but I am suggesting a little more seducing, ie, kissing and licking of neck and ear lobs). If we were to drop the PC model and just observe reality we would notice that there is much more complexity in human realtionships then the simplistic, and oft heard mantra: No means No.
 
twinkle don't waste your time

twinkle said:
Have you or how many of your close male friends/family accussed of rape?
Did you ever personally know a woman who as you say 'cried wolf' and lied about being raped and was this innocent male convicted of this crime?
Are you totally aware of the long, difficult and invasive process of reporting a rape and filing charges (ie. calling the police, filing a very detailed police report and the questions asked by the investigative officers


YES I know at least a couple of guys that were wrongfully accused...and they got shafted!

YES I know of at least a couple cases of women crying "wolf" for whatever vengeful act.
Furthermore I have known many....MANY a woman who admitted that they are capable of just about anything in an effort to "get back" at someone. I've been warned of it by other women and have seen it with my own eyes..."hell has no fury like a woman's scorn"....believe that

and YES I am aware of the process.



Twinkle, you have your opinion and I have mine. I was simply voicing my opinion...and you are entitled to the same. However please do not try to test me and my knowledge if you don't even know me.

and just to reiterate my point....My focus is a FAIR trial
 
Re: twinkle don't waste your time

Barry-O said:
YES I know at least a couple of guys that were wrongfully accused...and they got shafted!

YES I know of at least a couple cases of women crying "wolf" for whatever vengeful act.
Furthermore I have known many....MANY a woman who admitted that they are capable of just about anything in an effort to "get back" at someone. I've been warned of it by other women and have seen it with my own eyes......

Twinkle, you have your opinion and I have mine. I was simply voicing my opinion...and you are entitled to the same. However please do not try to test me and my knowledge if you don't even know me.

and just to reiterate my point....My focus is a FAIR trial

Barry-O you say you know "at least a couple of men who were wrongfully accused of rape" and "at least a couple of women who cried 'wolf' for whatever vengeful act". WOW!

I would guess that the majority of men on this board, can even say that they personally know of *ONE* man who was accused of rape, falsely or otherwise (correct me if I am wrong). And Barry-O, you know of....' AT LEAST A COUPLE' in your life time, ...btw how old are you? WOW! I am not calling you a liar, but what are the odds of that?

I guess you know a lot of very 'unlucky' men who tend to draw to themselves and associate with the type of women who could be sooo vindictive, and messed up, that she would go so low as to lie about being raped.
And you say you know "MANY" women who have admitted to you and warned you that they are capable doing anything (including lying that they are raped) in order to 'get back' at someone, and you have seen it with your own eyes. WOW, where in the world do you meet so MANY of these type of messed up women? I hope for your own sake, that you begin to draw, less evil and vindictive females, into your life, who you can trust to not be so vengeful. There are a lot of sane and healthy women out there, who are not that vindictive.

***And if you think I am 'testing' you and your knowledge, I was just asking IMO very FAIR and REASONABLE questions to see what basis you would have to make such a strong sweeping claim as if it were based on fact, and not just your BIASES or ASSUMPTIONs... i.e. "it happens all the time to men, and that the courts are biased in favour of female rape victims". I just hate those type of one-sided and sweeping declarations and assumptions, that are stated as if they are fact, that really have not factual or statistical basis. You are free to express your opinions and I am free to express my opinions even if you feel I am testing you or your knowledge. This is an open discussion. forum.

Ultimately, we both agree that a FAIR trial for BOTH the male and the female is of primary importance in these cases.
 
Last edited:
twinkle: you GO GIRL! :)

WFS: You have this annoying knack for making things more difficult and complicated than need be- possibly to discourage feminists' ideas at all costs. sheesh! chill out! The situations being referenced are not always cut and dry, but oftentimes fall into a grey area. Welcome to life, Wired.

"NO MEANS NO" is an excellent guideline to follow if you are concerned about playing on The Safe Side of the Edge!!! If you don't want there to be any doubt(s) - NO MEANS NO. It's simple common sense and decency! Stay away from those nasty girls and their games lol
 
The Feminist Pot calling the Kettle Black

twinkle said:
Ultimately, we both agree that a FAIR trial for BOTH the male and the female is of primary importance in these cases.

I've my doubts about that. You've done exactly what you accuse Barry-O of doing. Anyone who has followed this thread knows that you've made generalizations as well, just not of the same kind.

Who has the more factual account about what's going on? Well, I think it doesn't matter if you're a man or a woman, e.g. Female writers such as: Wendy McElroy, Camille Paglia, et al, have presented evidence to show anti-male bias in our culture that is reflected in the legal profession.

To see who has the more factual account we should look at what's going on in the Universities. Those in the Governmental/legal profession graduate from the universitie's humanities departments. Now, in the humanities dep'ts you have women's studies programs that teach female collectivism and massandry(that is anti-male views, especially anti-white male views). Other social studies courses reinforce a predominantly collectivist worldview. The emphasis maybe different, but the broader abstraction remains the same:Collectivism.

Now, once these students (male/female) graduate they're firmly brainwashed to see the world as groups, as opposed to individuals. Group victims vs Group Victimizers. In other words, many take an apriori approach to guilt in sexual assault allegations made by females.

All the Students retain the faculty of free will, but, without a *fair* (strawman presentations, etc) presentation of alternative views to counter this dominant ideology, the students are left intellectually disarmed and silent once they graduate. The consequences are a legal profession biased against men which is left unchallenged.

Understand that there are injustices that happen to many women as well. Both sides in this debate can point to personal examples. But, the teaching in the Universities is what it is and no re-writing of reality will change that.
 
penguin_jf said:
twinkle: you GO GIRL! :)

WFS: You have this annoying knack for making things more difficult and complicated than need be- possibly to discourage feminists' ideas at all costs. sheesh! chill out! The situations being referenced are not always cut and dry, but oftentimes fall into a grey area. Welcome to life, Wired.

"NO MEANS NO" is an excellent guideline to follow if you are concerned about playing on The Safe Side of the Edge!!! If you don't want there to be any doubt(s) - NO MEANS NO. It's simple common sense and decency! Stay away from those nasty girls and their games lol

Take your own advice seriously. Yes, situations aren't "always cut and dry, but oftentimes fall into a grey area. Welcome to life", penguin_jf. Yet, we need black and white in oder to know about grey, right? We all know that No doesn't alway mean No. IT SHOULD. But it doesn't. Why do you suppose that is? Maybe because sex has to do with psychology and many of us aren't definitive about what we want. Many of us are confused and non-linear in our actions. What might be no now, maybe yes in ten minutes. Or conditional on something else. Camille Paglia is absolutely right about this. Do I follow it as a guildline? It depends on the context; in certain contexts ABSOLUTELY. And you can't know apriori who the nasty girls are.
 
Damn i leave the state for a few days and look what happens.
 
Stigma

I have a very close friend who was raped at a bar. 3 strangers put Ryphenol, other wise known as the date rape drug, in her drink, and took her to their place and brutally raped her. When she reported this incident to the police, she was asked an number of questions, one being what had she been wearing that night (as if the clothing she wore was an invitation to be drugged and brutalized). they also asked her if at any point she said "no" to the men (well as she was drugged to near unconciousness her reply of course had to be no). They then took her to the hospital and the doctors prepared a "rape kit", after having so recently brutalized she was forced to undergo an examination by a male doctor as no females were available. Also since she had very little info on the men who had done this, they assumed she was some sort of "loose" girl who acepted drinks from anyone. hardly the case. By then end of everything she felt so ashamed that she refused to continue with charges, as the officers had made her feel like it was something she invited upon herself. Although this case was clearly one of unconsentual sex, questions regarding my friend and her lifestyle frightened her off persuing charges. Due to this there may be other girls who have unfortunately suffered the same fate.

I know this does not directly relate to what is beign said, but rape is an issue I feel very strongly about. When a girl says no, or is not given the choice to do so, and sex is initiated, it is RAPE!!! No questions asked. Changes of heart can occur for any reason, but it is the sign of a true MAN when he accepts it.

Emma
 
Wired For Sound said:
Take your own advice seriously. Yes, situations aren't "always cut and dry, but oftentimes fall into a grey area. Welcome to life", penguin_jf. Yet, we need black and white in oder to know about grey, right? We all know that No doesn't alway mean No. IT SHOULD. But it doesn't. Why do you suppose that is? Maybe because sex has to do with psychology and many of us aren't definitive about what we want. Many of us are confused and non-linear in our actions. What might be no now, maybe yes in ten minutes. Or conditional on something else. Camille Paglia is absolutely right about this. Do I follow it as a guildline? It depends on the context; in certain contexts ABSOLUTELY. And you can't know apriori who the nasty girls are.
What a self-contradictory pile of rubbish! Do you post just so you'll have another chance to use 'apriori'?? I said it's NOT cut and dried, then you said we need black and white BUT it depends on the context?? You can't have it both ways WFS - at least strive for a bit of intellectual consistency please.
 
penguin_jf said:
What a self-contradictory pile of rubbish! Do you post just so you'll have another chance to use 'apriori'?? I said it's NOT cut and dried, then you said we need black and white BUT it depends on the context?? You can't have it both ways WFS - at least strive for a bit of intellectual consistency please.

Penguin_jf, what's self contradictory about what I said? Where's the rubbish? Where's the intellectual inconsistency? If I say killing is *always* wrong, but then I, say, kill someone in self defense; then I can be accused of self contradiction. I, however, have said that No means No depends on context.

Re-read what I've been saying all along. You'll notice that I don't DISAGREE with you. Again: I act on the No means No slogan, GIVEN CONTEXT! No means No is a slogan that is MEANT as a OUT OF CONTEXT absolute, which it clearly isn't. That's all I've been atempting to explain.
 
Wired For Sound said:
And some people here are so simplistic in their arguments. No means No. Well, Duh! But, we all know that men are REWARDED by women for being ASSERTIVE. When is no, a real "NO!?" A no could be: I want you to try harder because you have to prove you're worth it.
All through the animal kingdom it's males that are in competition with other males to seduce females. Yes, humans have reason; but we have also evolved a certain psychology that PC ideology can't escape. Women, in general, want men who are stronger and assertive. They will test men and want them to do the opposite of what they say. The men that don't are wimps and they will want them to be -- at best -- friends, not lovers.

To Be Clear...ASSERTIVNESS and AGGRESSIVENESS are two very different things, dont confuse the two? Yes most women do like an assertive man but NOT an AGGRESSIVE man who disregards a womans direct and clear NO.

Are you really comparing human males to males in the animal kingdom? Thank goodness humans have reason, and we are higher life forms, because males in the animal kingdom also eat the young.

WFS- you say a womans "no could be: I want you to try harder because you have to prove youre worth it" or "They will test men and want them to do the opposite of what they say". WTF are you really serious?......Excuse me but....where in the world are you meeting these 'types' of women? Is there some secret nighclub at the Toronto Zoo, in the monkey section, stay away from the lower primates? LOL . All joking aside, I dont know any women like that-who say no but dont really mean it. Based on your above statements your perception of females is obviously very distorted and prejudiced. You are not a mind reader and it is the height of arrogance to think you can disregard a womans clear NO because you think your are psychic and can read her mind. No means no, end of the story. **** NEWS FLASH this is a very simple concept for most reasonable and respectable men to grasp.

WFS......FYI this *IS* a very SIMPLISTIC argument. No means no regardless of the context.
 
Re: The Feminist Pot calling the Kettle Black

Wired For Sound said:
I've my doubts about that. You've done exactly what you accuse Barry-O of doing. Anyone who has followed this thread knows that you've made generalizations as well, just not of the same kind.

Who has the more factual account about what's going on? Well, I think it doesn't matter if you're a man or a woman, e.g. Female writers such as: Wendy McElroy, Camille Paglia, et al, have presented evidence to show anti-male bias in our culture that is reflected in the legal profession.

To see who has the more factual account we should look at what's going on in the Universities. Those in the Governmental/legal profession graduate from the universitie's humanities departments. Now, in the humanities dep'ts you have women's studies programs that teach female collectivism and massandry(that is anti-male views, especially anti-white male views). Other social studies courses reinforce a predominantly collectivist worldview. The emphasis maybe different, but the broader abstraction remains the same:Collectivism.

Now, once these students (male/female) graduate they're firmly brainwashed to see the world as groups, as opposed to individuals. Group victims vs Group Victimizers. In other words, many take an apriori approach to guilt in sexual assault allegations made by females.

All the Students retain the faculty of free will, but, without a *fair* (strawman presentations, etc) presentation of alternative views to counter this dominant ideology, the students are left intellectually disarmed and silent once they graduate. The consequences are a legal profession biased against men which is left unchallenged.

Understand that there are injustices that happen to many women as well. Both sides in this debate can point to personal examples. But, the teaching in the Universities is what it is and no re-writing of reality will change that.

Please show me where I have made generalizations and presented them as fact?

Regarding the rest of your post. I AM CONFUSED. OMG I have re read your post over a dozen times and I am more confused than the first time I read it. Your communication style is very muddled and confusing to say the least. If you are trying to make a point make sure it is clear and easy to understand for your audience. As my english teacher use to say K.I.S.S. .
 
my question is: since no means no and anytime during the act SHE (not he) can withdraw concent. Do we as men consider yes to be a green light and clear the intersection as quickly as possible???????