New Governor General

Since it is the responsibility of the House of Commons to examine and bring forward legislation, shouldn't they be the ones to ensure that they get it right? (btw, we are talking about errors and omissions, not about the key purposes of the legislation, which opposing parties can and often do oppose). Thus my suggestion of a House committee devoted to this task.

It is not the exclusive responsibility of the House of Commons, but one shared with the Senate. Legislation, with few exceptions, can originate in either house, and, irrespective of in which house it originated, must be adopted in identical form by both houses before it can become law.
 
Senate appointments are definitely often patronage appointments, however, the Senate does have an important function. Moreover, often those patronage appointments really are handing an important job to an old hand who is no longer up for the hustle and bustle of running for office in Parliament. Often these are very experienced people, who have been around long enough to be able to spot common errors in bills that are missed by more junior parliamentarians.

Perhaps we need more review around Senate appointments to clamp down a bit on the patronage aspects, but I don't think that's a criticism of the Senate itself, and when the patronage appointments go to senior politicians who are looking for a slower pace, I think the Senate is actually a great place for those people.

I also think that it's valuable for each successive government to impart its stamp on the Senate. The Senate is kind of a sliding window, representing old hands from each successive government we've had. It's as a result a collection of individuals who bring a variety of views and a lot of experience to the inspection of legislation.
 
Often these are very experienced people, who have been around long enough to be able to spot common errors in bills that are missed by more junior parliamentarians.

Perhaps we need more review around Senate appointments to clamp down a bit on the patronage aspects, but I don't think that's a criticism of the Senate itself, and when the patronage appointments go to senior politicians who are looking for a slower pace, I think the Senate is actually a great place for those people.

I also think that it's valuable for each successive government to impart its stamp on the Senate. The Senate is kind of a sliding window, representing old hands from each successive government we've had. It's as a result a collection of individuals who bring a variety of views and a lot of experience to the inspection of legislation.

Pamela Wallin
Nancy Greene Rain
Frank Mohavalich
Linda Frum
Michael Duffy
Jacques Demer
Nicole Eaton
Elizabeth Hubley




Although some senators have experience in the political area, many don't. Above are some people, not picking on them, just for example, who may have been been good at what they did in their professional careers, but certainly have no experience in spotting common errors in bills, case in point, Jacques Demer can't even read!!!!!!!!!!

Many appointments are pure, unadulterated patronage appointments, or just rewards for being a good citizen, nothing to do with skills in the parliamentary process.

Personally I don't agree with governments in power should appoint loyal party supporters over the years, it should be a collaboration of the major parties who review and vote on each appointment, this should minimize the patronism and hopefully appoint more qualified individuals.
 
Elizabeth Hubley

As former deputy speaker of the PEI Legislature I would imagine she does in fact have a lot of legislative insight to bring to the senate. Several of the others you cites do not have legislative experience per se, but many of them sat in reviewing positions at large bureuacratic organizations and may well have something to contribute. Someone who has made outstanding contributions on a federal task force, for example, would presumably bring to bear the sort of experience that a Senator would require, and that would presumably explain the appointment of, for example, Ms. Rain.

I would not fault the senate for one or two bad appointments, I'd fault the politician who appointed them. I wouldn't object to having a bit more of a vetting appointment around senate appointments, although I do think it's important that they are partisan appointments, so as to ensure the government is able to put its stamp on the senate over time.

Nicole Eaton is an example of a questionable appointment--serving as a director for the ROM does not seem to be the sort of outstanding accomplishment that would set someone up for a senate appointment. It's probably the Eaton family's connections to the Conservative party that got her the job. I'd lay that at the feet of Stephen Harper, who appointed her, rather than list it as a critique of the senate itself, though.
 
Maybe it is not a bad thing that a small minority of senators have valuable life experiences outside the political arena.
That was actually one of the best arguments for the former hereditary House of Lords. The members had a vastly greater range of work and life experience than most members of the supposedly more democratic House of Commons.
 
Ken Taylor has admitted to spying for the CIA.
That is an incorrect statement! Helping to rescue U.S. Diplomats and engaging in espionage activities for the U.S. are radically different things.

Looked it up Aardvark154 - you were right on. Ken Taylor did spy for the CIA but at the request of Joe Clark (PM) because US had no presence in Iran after the hostages left. But I still would rather have a hot chick as GG. No panties and when the debates gets too boring - she slowly crosses her long legs to end it.