need advice re: blu-ray players

Unless there is a lot of action does it make any difference whether it is 720P or 1080P?

On large screens, 96"+, it makes a big difference. On smaller <42" screens where you sit more than 6' back, not so much.

There are 2x the number of pixels on a 1080P (1920x1080=2,073,600 pixels) picture than a 720P (720x1280=921,600 pixels). Keep in mind your digital TV only displays in it's native resolution, so if you send a 720P picture to a 1080P TV, it has 2 options: 1) display the picture as is, and present a picture that does not fill the screen, or 2) Upscale the picture to fill the screen by "filling in" extra pixels that the TV's software has created based upon the characteristics of adjacent pixels.

So, to put a 720P picture on a 1080P screen the TV actually "makes up" 1/2 of the picture. The upscaled 720P picture tends to be "softer" than if you fed it a true 1080p source. Pixel shaders and filters sharpen and enhance the upscaled picture.

For sports it is a completely different situation. While the "game" may be recorded in 1080 hi-def and arrive at your home as "1080", by the time it has been compressed for the satellite hops, expanded, processed and recompressed at the studio, bounced back off the satellite and fed to the cable company, much of the clarity is gone and artifacts during motion appear. I've watched Letterman live some nights in 1080, look worse than standard def. TV's and transmission systems had problems with hi-def motion in the earlier days of compression, but faster processors and refresh rates have about eliminated the issue.
 
Unless there is a lot of action does it make any difference whether it is 720P or 1080P?

As wheelman said: on broadcast images not really but for things like discovery channel, national geographic, and some bravo converts, it does make a huge difference.

With BR discs however, since they are 1080, if you only have a 720 monitor, BRs are a waste of time and money because you'll never see the higher resolution on a 720 monitor and that is THE only reason to buy a BR movie.

Put it in simpler terms: it would be like buying a lambo gallardo with 12 cyl engine, then disconnecting the spark plug wires to 6 of the cylinders so they would never produce power to the wheels.

If you only have a 720 tv, stick with regular DVDs......
 
Oh you can count on it. They spent way too much money fighting with HD DVD to give it up easily.

Plus they are gouging on the price of the discs so they are making millions from it.

Frankly I think they'd make a lot MORE money if they'd lower the prices somewhat......I know I would buy more BR but frankly, for often double, or triple the price, my upconverting DVD player does a great job for 1/3 the price......

I agree although at Best Buy this weekend there were racks of Blu-rays for $15......

OTB
 
Here's the latest

Sony PlayStation 3 Slim - 120GB

More affordable $299 price; slimmer, more compact design with quieter operation; all games in high-definition; easy-to-use interface; doubles as a Blu-ray and upscaling DVD player; built-in Wi-Fi; 120GB hard drive; HDMI output with 1080p support; no external power supply; built-in Web browser; free online gaming service.

Dell is selling it for $269.99
http://reviews.cnet.com/consoles/so...05-10109_7-33765068.html?tag=TOCrightColumn.0
 
I rarely use my Bluray player as well. When it was new, I bought several BR disks to compare to the h.264 ripped versions. The compressed h.264 versions were so good I rarely buy BD discs anymore...only for my favorite classics.

Instead my old PC received couple of 1.5TB drives and became a Linux media server. It now streams audio to devices around the house, and movies via my PC and MPC-HC to my projector.

The MPC-HC player's hardware acceleration, scaling, pixel shaders and filters make a 720P encoded movie look sharper than an untouched 1080P one. I can store more than 250 720P (or 150+ 1080p) movies on 1 drive, download a new movie in about an hour, surf my entire library, and load a movie without leaving my chair.

Torrents suck.
For while it lasts, newsgroups are where its at.
$15 per month to a USENET provider, and you have every movie, and TV show at your fingertips.
http://binsearch.net/browse.php?bg=alt.binaries.hdtv.x264

PS3 for Bluray...Hah ! who needs it!


you are talking about terrabytes, streaming, Linux and a bunch of other stuff the majority of people have no clue about. Most people just wanna turn on their player, pop in a movie and watch it,

and anyone who believes that Blu-Ray is a flash in the pan, well take a look at some of whats released out there, do you really think a company would waste money on doing a movie with Larry the Cable Guy in blu-ray if they didnt think it had a future??
 
I agree although at Best Buy this weekend there were racks of Blu-rays for $15......

OTB

That's worth checking out...if you can pick up a few movies for $50, movies that you would watch over and over again, it's a good deal.

...maybe I'll find Larry the Cable Guy for $15 and I can send scouser1 a copy :D Git 'R Done!
 
That's worth checking out...if you can pick up a few movies for $50, movies that you would watch over and over again, it's a good deal.

...maybe I'll find Larry the Cable Guy for $15 and I can send scouser1 a copy :D Git 'R Done!

We're on the same page. I always buy DVDs used at Blockbuster and they almost always have: buy 2 get one free, 30% off, 3 for $24 etc. They charge $5.00 to rent, I buy for $10 and then you can always trade it back in for (on average) $5.00.

I checked out Best Buy online and they really didn't have anything worth buying. For eg: I was at walmart (god I hate admitting that) and they had the BR Total Recall disc on for $11.99. It SUCKED. It was a crappy upscale (I read this online but didn't listen). I traded it in at Blockbuster the next day and they gave me $10.00 for it.

One of the great things about Blu Ray and HD: you can see all KINDS of things you wouldn't normally see. For eg: In one CSI (or something) one of the hotties had a big piece of lint or kleenex on their top. Another had a tag sticking out of their low cut T, In The Scorpion King there is a scene where the "princess" climbs on top of the rock (he's laying on his back by a fire) and I thought I caught a glimpse of pink. Sure enough, frame by frame there it was: her P lips out for all to see.....

Just thinking: maybe we should start a thread where we post all the little tidbits we pick up via HD? (but I tell you: Marisa Tomei was HOT in "The wrestler" (oh man she only gets better with age).